Difference between revisions of "Main Page"
(→The power of framing and context) |
(→The power of framing and context) |
||
| Line 615: | Line 615: | ||
In the TPP reading rooms, which are open to the public, the books on the shelf need to be able to communicate on their own. Therefore we wrote for each book of the collection a “library card”. It functions partly as an index catalogue (which is also available online). But it foremost describes the books’ genesis. The card names the original source, the material properties of the pirate copy, what strategy has been used, who is the pirate, how it got into the collection. All in all it functions as an entry point to the book. At New York Art Book Fair, a librarian from Pratt institute stepped by our reading room every single day, because she was so fixed on the questions the books raise in respect to normative cataloguing and bibliography standards. Take Jaime Bayli’s “No se diga a nadie” for example. Who would be named as author? How can you pay justice to the complexity of the more than one “authorships” in this work? | In the TPP reading rooms, which are open to the public, the books on the shelf need to be able to communicate on their own. Therefore we wrote for each book of the collection a “library card”. It functions partly as an index catalogue (which is also available online). But it foremost describes the books’ genesis. The card names the original source, the material properties of the pirate copy, what strategy has been used, who is the pirate, how it got into the collection. All in all it functions as an entry point to the book. At New York Art Book Fair, a librarian from Pratt institute stepped by our reading room every single day, because she was so fixed on the questions the books raise in respect to normative cataloguing and bibliography standards. Take Jaime Bayli’s “No se diga a nadie” for example. Who would be named as author? How can you pay justice to the complexity of the more than one “authorships” in this work? | ||
| − | The problem discussed earlier is that standard modes of classification use a controlled vocabulary. The most widespread standard classification systems (Dewey, Library of Congress) claim to be universal and neutral, so that everything can find its place within its structure. However we know that the organisation and framing of knowledge is not neutral and informs to a large degree, whether material is been found and if and how it is being read. To cut deeper into the questions around framing cases in our collection, we organised a workshop during the two-month reading room opened at Grand Union in Birmingham | + | The problem discussed earlier is that standard modes of classification use a controlled vocabulary. The most widespread standard classification systems (Dewey, Library of Congress) claim to be universal and neutral, so that everything can find its place within its structure. However we know that the organisation and framing of knowledge is not neutral and informs to a large degree, whether material is been found and if and how it is being read. To cut deeper into the questions around framing cases in our collection, we organised a workshop during the two-month reading room opened at Grand Union in Birmingham (6 December 2013 – 8 February 2014). Archivist Karen Di Franco helped us to collectively develop an alternative vocabulary by thinking through how selected cases operate. A set of useful new terms came up: “Unauthorised”, “Impersonated”, “Hijacked”, “Invisible/Ghost”, “Altruistic”, “Esoteric”, “Accidental”, “Communal”. <ref name="Di Franco"/> |
| − | On another instance, when a TPP reading room opened at Kunstverein Munich | + | On another instance, when a TPP reading room opened at Kunstverein Munich (7 – 28 November 2014), we looked for classification criteria, how to spatially organise the books. Parallel to the reading room we ran a two-week workshop visiting independent publishers, bookshops, archives and a copy shop in Munich, which all operated off mainstream practices and found alternative ways of distribution.<ref name="Kunstverein Munich publication"/> Correspondingly we organised the books on display in the Piracy Project Reading Room according to their modes of distribution: |
Revision as of 13:08, 2 December 2018
Contents
- 1 About this wiki
- 2 Introduction: first notes only
- 3 State of the art in this domain/survey of the field (still a mess)
- 3.1 Early conceptual artist books 60s and 70s.
- 3.2 Setting up infrastructures of production and distribution
- 3.3 Terminologies and identity politics - this discussion needs perhaps to go elsewhere
- 3.4 Making Public: “Insertions into Ideological Circuits”
- 3.5 Publishing as pedagogical, dialogical process
- 3.6 Libraries as a space of dissemination – Questions of access and organisation, classification and validation
- 3.7 Topic Classification
- 3.8 KvinnSam, the National Resource Library for Gender Studies at Gothenburg University
- 3.9 Feminist Search Tool
- 3.10 Radical Librarianship / Teaching The Radical Catalog
- 3.11 Dissemination: Digital Turn / Open Access
- 4 What are the experiments that I have carried out?
- 5 Summary of projects and submitted material
- 5.1 AND Publishing –– with Rosalie Schweiker, multiple collaborators (2009 - ongoing)
- 5.2 Library of Inclusions and Omissions (2016–ongoing)
- 5.2.1 Library of Omissions and Inclusions: The open call
- 5.2.2 Library of Omissions and Inclusions: The index card catalogue
- 5.2.3 Library of Omissions and Inclusions: Temporary Reading Rooms installed in different contexts.
- 5.2.4 Published text: 'Dear Hannah'. On the occasion of 'Utopia of Access', Pavilion of Artistic Research, Venice Biennale 2017
- 5.2.5 Published chapter 'Library Underground – a reading list for a coming community
- 5.2.6 Performative reading of chapter 'Library Underground' at 'Miss Read', Akademie der Künste Berlin, 2016
- 5.2.7 Filmed performative reading of chapter 'Library Underground- welcome to my tent' at symposium 'Photography in Print and Circulation', Valand Academy Gothenburg, 2016
- 5.2.8 Published presentation: 'Radical publishing practices ask for radical librarianship' at: 'Artists as Publishers as Artists', University of Media Arts Cologne
- 5.2.9 Alternative cataloguing workshop: 'Reading Gendered Words'
- 5.3 The Piracy Project – with Andrea Francke and multiple collaborators (2010–ongoing)
- 5.3.1 Forthcoming chapter 'The Piracy Project', in “Archives of the Commons II - the Anomic Archive”, Red Conceptualismo del Sur, Museo Nacional Reina Sofia Madrid, 2018
- 5.3.2 Forthcoming chapter 'What Matter who’s speaking' in “Whose Book is it anyway - an anthology”, Cambridge: Open Book Publishers, 2019
- 5.3.3 Published interview 'The Piracy Project' at 'Giving What you don’t have', 2013
- 5.3.4 Transcript of interview 'The Piracy Project' – Abigail de Kossnik (Berkeley Media studies) interviews Andrea Francke and Eva Weinmayr, 2016
- 5.3.5 Published text 'The Impermanent Book', co-authored with Andrea Francke, Rhizome, 2012
- 5.4 Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy? three-day mobilization and workbook – with Feminist Pedagogy working group at Valand Academy, University of Gothenburg (2015–2016)
- 5.4.1 Working group 2015-2016
- 5.4.2 Published Workbook: 'Let's Mobilize What is Feminist Pedagogy?'
- 5.4.3 The organising of the mobilisation - administrative creativity
- 5.4.4 Subsequent invitations to workshops and talks
- 5.4.5 Forthcoming chapter 'Outside the Page' in issue "The Filmic Page", On Curating ZHdK Zürich
- 5.4.6 Forthcoming chapter 'Make your own adventure' (working title) in "Decolonialism after the educational turn"
- 5.5 Unboxing, AND Research Residency, MarabouParken Konsthall, Stockholm – with Rosalie Schweiker April – August 2018
- 5.6 Topic Co-option
- 6 Reflection, theorisation of projects and submitted material
- 7 method
- 8 to do
- 9 bibliography references – (I'll do them at the very end)
- 10 Getting started
About this wiki
This wiki is a method to develop, map, share and communicate the writing of my PhD thesis in artistic practice at Valand Academy, University of Gothenburg. The wiki records and maps a looped, iterative and knowledge-creating process of structuring, writing, thinking, discovering, discarding and restructuring. Hence it is meant to be a testament to all the messy uncontrollable and creatively spiralling decision making processes, which differentiate "a practice" from a finished output.
Finding practical ways to share and communicate my research, has been an ongoing, and at times difficult, negotiation process between at least four forces seemingly pulling in different directions: academia, institutional policies, feminist and activist practice, the arts and education. Using a wiki is an attempt to find a way out of this dilemma. It allows me to bring to live the standoff between those forces and thus make transparent everything that is usually developed and discussed behind closed doors, when PhD theses are created: the learning process, the struggle while articulating, the shaping of arguments, the various agreements and disagreements within my head and in the dialogue with others.
This wiki constitutes also a practical strategy to depart from the solitary Word document that is saved over and over again on my hard disk and frequently sent to my PhD supervisors from where it returns as an annotated version only to be saved again on my disk. Instead of having multiple versions of half-finished fragments populating my computer hard disk, the wiki structure, with its varied page frameworks, allows me to neatly organise topics, ideas and fragments and most importantly make these moments of "taking shape" comprehensible, traceable and transparent.
My doctoral research is practice-led and is (and has been) supervised by Jyoti Mistry and Mick Wilson, Dave Beech and Andrea Phillips at Faculty of Artistic research Valand Academy, Gothenburg University. In a few months time, once this draft will have evolved and reached critical substance, I will invite peers to enter into dialogue, to comment, to work the draft over, to debate and improve it.
Please be aware that what you are reading is at this stage a draft in progress. It is worth mentioning that citing from a wiki in flux can be problematic. When you nevertheless cite from it, please do reference this fact or just get in touch: eva.weinmayr(at)akademinvaland.gu.se. Thank you.
Introduction: first notes only
The format of my dissertation is a compilation thesis, comprising a distinct set of practices / practical experiments and a "kappa" (Swedish, translated as "coat") The kappa provides the context by mapping the field, lists and to a certain degree reflects on the practical experiments (although this happens in more depth in published articles), and closes with an analysis and outlook.
The decision that a kappa is more generative, than a traditional monograph is based on several arguments:
1. My artistic practice consists of long-term projects. There is not one distinct ‘work / outcome / result’, which can be circulated, exhibited and audited, but a growing string of practices.
2. Most of these long-term practices are collaborations with people inside and outside academia. Two points here: Things/practices feeding back into this range of communities, requiring a variety of outcomes, formats, and languages, in order to make meaning. (see Charlotte Cooper Research Justice Diagram... rev) While this working method has clearly political implications by attempting to resist systems of subjectivation and individualisation, it also poses a distinct set of problems, when collective practice is being assessed and audited – in the framework of a PhD for example. The syllabus for doctoral education at GU requests, that roles in teamwork can be defined and specific accomplishments credited [1]. However, all collective work, as I will argue, is based on a dialogical process where ideas flow freely back and forth. And more, sometimes it is impossible or even counterproductive to assess “who did what?” trying to separate distinct roles in collaborations. (needs reference? Deleuze/Parnett "Dialogues" or "See Red" Feminist Collective?)
3. Questions of dissemination are therefore crucial, and an integral part of my research. Both characteristics of my work – that it is (1) long-term and (2) collaborative – mean, that the format of the individually authored monograph is not suitable. I publish and communicate “on the go” and in many different contexts. That implies, that I expand our understanding of the word “publishing”: Publishing as a time-based and contextual practice. To understand publishing as a “verb” (a process) instead of a “noun” (verb). Here I wonder whether I can make the case for practice itself as a form of publishing, and ask how much public and particularly which “publics” a process of publishing requires. So for example: Is a teaching situation a form of publishing? A workshop, where knowledge is collectively produced and disseminated at the same time? When we think of the collaborative as a situation, scene, process, dynamic, method, or mode, can we frame such a situation as “publishing”? What is ‘contextual publishing?’ Is publishing necessarily based on a document? What IS a document? The French librarian and documentalist Suzanne Briet (Bibliothèque Nationale de France) proposed in Qu’est- ce que la documantation? (1951), that an antelope running wild is regarded as an animal, however the antelope caged and exhibited in the zoo is arguably turned into document, analysed, described, categorised, classified, framed and exhibited. This thought seems relevant for my inquiry and needs more exploration.
–––––
The overall inquiry investigates publication as a social and pedagogical – and as such a political – process.
Artists have used publication to further their ideas since the turn of the last century, and in recent years there has been a sharp increase in this practice. While the current academic drive to publish for Research Excellence Framework (UK) might be considered part of this expansion, arguably this institutional pressure erodes artistic practice based on agency, creativity, criticality, experimentation and collective knowledge making. Publishing (and writing) in such contexts has been arguably reduced from a process of communication, discovery and exploration, to a system for the assembly of more and more new products. (Fitzpatrick, 2011) What are possible publishing strategies of artists, academic and activists that contest these dominant paradigms of creation and dissemination of knowledge? I will ask what is the relationship between “making” and “making public”? Between experience and articulation? How does the “outside space” (distribution) shapes the “inside space” of publication (content). How can publishing create spaces, in the figurative and physical sense, for better mutual understanding and rethinking relations between people? How can publishing develop our capacities to establish the grounds for more lasting and emancipated forms of cultural production, education, and research? The starting point is my own artistic practice which investigates the politics of production and dissemination based on concepts found in feminist theory, feminist pedagogy, social science, philosophy, media theory and radical pedagogy.
This inquiry is located at the intersection of contemporary art, radical education and institutional analysis. It is based on my long-term individual and collective publishing practice. Publication as an artistic means became early on a main field of my practice. Partly because I could set the terms and conditions of production and distribution myself and could act without being authorised by galleries, curators, collectors, etc.). Secondly publications were a useful means to capture ephemeral processes into a document, that could be circulated beyond the immediate context.
I took the first two publications, Lery - a story of facts and faxes (1998) and Mexico (with Vera Büchlmann and Joachim Melf, 1997) on my first trip to New York, walked into Printed Matter art book shop and sold them 10 copies each on consignment. What an empowering moment, which was more exciting than any exhibition opportunity I ever had.
Ten years later, having published with big mainstream commercial publishing houses (Hatje Cantz) as well as small independent presses (Temporary Services, Occasional Papers, BookWork London) I got more and more interested in exploring setting up own publishing infrastructures and co-founded (with American artist Lynn Harris) AND publishing in London.
So while until recently I would have said - without hesitation, that publishing, that ‘making public’ is an outright positive and constructive act, a tool of giving voice and developing emancipatory agency, I am much more cautious today, because as will argue, publishing has become an asset in the knowledge and cultural capital industry. As I will argue in the following, we are facing an growing imperative to ‘publish or perish’, which has problematic consequences on many different levels.
To articulate these problems and their implications on emancipatory, political art practice is one strand of my research. To experiment with and develop social, emancipatory, critical, feminist models of knowledge making and disseminating is another.
>>>authorship, authorisation and authority >>> key challenge: how to get out of this triangulation?
Thinking through the entanglement of the three concepts "authorship, authorisation and authority." I am authorised to become an author by the institution, which is funding me, in order to become an authority in the field. What if I don't want to become an author or an authority? What if I don't want to become an institutionally authorised author authority? Who authorises whom?
Footnotes Introduction
- ↑ The syllabus for doctoral education at Gothenburg University states: ’In certain cases, dissertation work can be pursued as team work. This shall then be organised in such a way that the individual efforts can be specified and assessed on the same grounds as for individual pieces of work.’
State of the art in this domain/survey of the field (still a mess)
The artistic examples and practices I will describe in the following, spread widely in geography, time in history and disciplinary framings. This wide field serves as a key methodological element of my cross-disciplinary approach, because this demonstrates that my own analysis and thinking is not bound to one disciplinary category such as "the artistic field", but seeks to connect seemingly disparate domains by by thinking and practicing transversally.
On closer inspection, the practices I discuss all share two distinct features: They are discrete instances, where the dominant paradigms of publishing and the formation of knowledge have been in some way or another adjusted and they act as declared counter-political project.
All the examples and practices described interfere in distinct critical ways with notions of authorship, editorial processes, design and production as well as distribution, but also with concepts of classifying, archiving and also reading publications. Overall this communality ties them together into a broader act of contesting power.
Early conceptual artist books 60s and 70s.
The situation:
What did they do:
What did it achieve:
Artists' books at the time were arguably a means to circumvent established institutions and perhaps to a certain degree an attempt to reform the art system by: “(1) the use of inexpensive printing and production methods allowed anyone to be a publisher, (2) alternative distribution networks were ‘aiding in the decentralization of the art system …’, (3) this form of art was portable and disposable and (4) these works were, or could be, ‘democratic objects’”.[1] [2]
These artistic practices criticised the paradigms of the art market by avoiding the aura of preciousness, uniqueness by using mass production technology such as commercial litho printing. In contrast to traditional, unique art objects “a book’s text is infinitely replicable, the number of copies that can be printed is theoretically limitless.”[3]
Art theorist Lucy Lippard argues that the main reason the book has proved to be so attractive as an artistic medium has to do with the fact that artists’ books are ‘considered by many the easiest way out of the art world and into the heart of a broader audience’.[4] Lippard describes here the fundamental political potential of the artists book as a conceptual and material means to question, intervene in and disturb existing practices and institutions.
Setting up infrastructures of production and distribution
The challenge however was the setting up production and distribution systems, that provided an alternative way to circulate the books without falling back to exclusionary market mechanisms of the art system. Investigating whether artists could set up independent systems of circulation the editors of Art-Rite magazine put out a call:
“Artists’ Books – We are investigating the possibilities of a publishing and distribution system for artists’ books. (This does not mean catalogues.) Do you have: a) already published books that we can distribute or sell on consignment? b) Completely planned, unpublished books with or without dummies? c) names of other artists who have either one? Let us know. Please send information to: PRINTED MATTER, 164 Mulberry St., NYC 10013.”[5]
Due to their perceived potential to subvert the (commercial, profit-driven) gallery system and to politicise artistic practice - artist books according to Joan Lyons played an important part in the rise of independent art structures.[6] Artists started to set up their own distribution infrastructures by founding independent artist book shops[7], in an attempt to counter the hegemonic art gallery market –to a certain extend. This disclaimer is necessary, as history has shown, that artists books were prone to be easily recaptured by the system. Firstly because many artist at the time were relying on gallery representation and gallery distribution. And secondly, because the descriptor “artist book” implies, that we deal with an object, which can easily be recaptured by the market as a collectible. Ed Ruscha for example writes in a letter to John Wilcock, the founder of Village Voice in New York: “I made a terrible mistake by numbering my “26 Gasoline Stations” books, because then the books became a limited edition rather than just another book, which is what I am after”.[8]
Terminologies and identity politics - this discussion needs perhaps to go elsewhere
The term artist book is still widely in use, as the names of New York Art Book Fair (founded by A.A. Bronson/Printed Matter in 2004[fact check]), London Art Book Fair (Whitechapel Art Gallery, London) evidence. However for my inquiry into the social agency of publishing the term “publishing” seems more useful. This new terminology suggests to shift the focus from the finished object to the process. … XXXX more here.
However while the term “artists’ publishing” opens up the practice it limits its applicability to authors, who define themselves as artists. Richard Kostelanetz writes in 1979 “One trouble with the current term artists’ books is that it defines a work of art by the initial profession (or education) of its author, rather than by qualities of the work itself. Since genuine critical categories are meant to define art of a particular kind, it is a false term. The art at hand is books no matter who did them; and it is differences among them, rather than in their authorship, that should comprise the stuff of critical discourse.”
This observation of authorship assigned to specific identities, professions or disciplines is very relevant for my inquiry and has been discussed and experimented with in a variety of forms.
Due to the problematic of the author question in “artist’s publishing” the term ‘independent publishing’ and self-publishing has been introduced. Both terms are seeking to distance the practice from institutional or mainstream commercial publishing practices.
Making Public: “Insertions into Ideological Circuits”
The situation:
What did they do:
What did it achieve:
In his series of works “Insertions into Ideological Circuits” (1970) the Brazilian artist Cildo Mereiles infiltrated already existing infrastructures of circulation by screen printing anti war slogans on recyclable Coca Cola bottles, or rubber stamped critical questions about the dictatorship on one dollar bills to circulate them through many hands. Here the artist merely “piggy-bagged” on already existing infrastructures of circulation as carrier for his messages. In the same vein in November 2008 activists around the US prankster collective The Yes Men “hacked” the New York Times by printing a “special edition” of 80,000 copies, which was distributed for free to passers-by on the streets of several US cities. This special edition was a perfect replica of The New York Times. The activists co-opted the authority and visual appearance of the New York Times in order to circulate a visionary “best case scenario” with hypothetical headlines and articles, such as “Iraq War Ends”, “Minimum Wage Law Passes Congress”, USA Patriot Act Repealed”, All Public Universities to Be Free”. [9]
Publishing as pedagogical, dialogical process
In the 60s and 70s political and feminist groups in a politicised climate of counter-information radical print-shops and collective screen print workshops (See Red) in London [10], feminist magazines (Spare Rib), and a vivid feminist zine culture (Riot girrrls) developed in many cities across Europe and the US in order to raise awareness against inequality and discrimination. Rejecting the role of the artist these activists participated in a network of campaign groups, radical publishers and distributors. One could argue, that the focus here was less on concepts of format or material qualities of a publication, instead the poster, magazine, book were a means to an end, to agitate, to activate, to get the message out, to give voice, create solidarity and work collectively towards change.
For the See Red feminist silkscreen poster collective, for example, which started in London in 1974 working collectively was central. “In the early days the posters were mainly produced about our own personal experiences as women, about the oppression of housework, childcare and the negative image of women. An idea for a poster would be discussed in the group, a member would work on a design, bring it back for comment, someone else might make changes and so on until the collective was satisfied with the end result; no one individually took the credit. This was a concept many in the art world found hard to accept: ‘who holds the pencil? Someone must hold the pencil!’” [11] The collective of women got together to combat the negative image of the women in advertising and the media. Suzy Mackie and Pru Stevenson, founding members of the See Red Women’s Workshop stressed in a public talk at The Showroom in London how important it was to gather in person and generate ideas about how to visualise a particular issue that was important to them. It was the activity of articulating experiences and collective brainstorming and the discussion of ideas that led to sharp slogans and imagery for the posters.
I understand from these self-descriptions, that the collective work on developing a slogan, an image for a poster was a collective process of discovery, a dialogical process which was facilitated through collective making. So when does the making public start? Around the working table?
Example 2:
Elise and Celestin Freinet purchase of a printing press for the classroom, elementary school in France (1926) to work in the classroom with students to produce own teaching material and textbooks. collective editing, peer review, school journal to be exchanged with other schools. Contextual publishing. School archive own classification system. (see Eva Weinmayr PRINT, in der Fahrende Raum, Munich, 2015)
Libraries as a space of dissemination – Questions of access and organisation, classification and validation
Setting up self-organised libraries has become a field of practice for a range of artists and activists as a way to rethink the infrastructure of knowledge formation. Their practices can be described as creating a knowledge commons and as social and anarchist technique, which problematises the enclosure and privilege of knowledge in institutional libraries. [12]
Among the range of artists who have worked with libraries as part of their art practice, is for example Martha Rosler’s personal collection of books, which she lent to e-flux in order to create reading rooms in New York, and several cities across Europe open to the general public. This collection of books is curated by the artist and has been framed as artwork by an individual artist. While Rosler rejected the perception, that this exhibited library can be read as a kind of portrait of hers, it nonetheless focusses around her artist personality and lines of thinking. While it can be seen as a generous gesture to provide temporarily public access to a personal library, conceptually one could say it replicates the power structures of one individual deciding what goes in and what not.
By comparison a different and perhaps more community building approach take various small libraries and reading rooms emerging in cities in the Europe and US in recent years. Often set up by artists or connected to newly emerging maker spaces, these small community run libraries are informally organised and cater the needs of local residents and various community groups living in the area. They are building on the tradition of collectively run infoshops or community archives arising in the 70s and 80s in the UK as part of social movements. They operated independently, not council-run or organisationally affiliated and were catering explicitly for the information (and other, social and cultural) needs of its users. (Atton 1999)
In the same vein, the curatorial principle of online library projects by artists and activists, such as the peer-to peer sharing platforms aaaaarg.fail or memoryoftheworld.org are starting from the idea “when everybody is a librarian, library is everywhere”. Both projects are digital platforms. They are open and non-theme based online repositories for sharing mostly theory texts, which are uploaded by the platforms’ users. Memory of the World, initiated and hosted by Marcell Mars states “The Public Library is firstly — free access to books for every member of society, second — a library catalog, and third — a librarian. With books ready to be shared [online], meticulously cataloged, everyone is a librarian. When everyone is librarian, library is everywhere.” [13] I will come back to the cataloguing aspect of such practice in the next paragraph.
By comparison, aaaaarg.fail comes from a slightly different angle. It is often understood solely as an open source platform for freely sharing books, but is actually born from a desire to share books with others in order to start a conversation. It developed from gatherings of the Public School, a self-organised educational project in Los Angeles, which started in 2007.[14] It was founded by Fiona Whitton and Sean Dockray. They felt that a curriculum always comes with an institutionalised agenda defining a prescribed canon of learning. In the Public School people propose classes they want to take or want to teach and collaborate in exploring the proposed subjects together. [15] Public School has been spreading to other cities such as Buenos Aires, Berlin, San Francisco, New York, Durham, Helsinki, London, Vienna among others. Aaaaarg.fail has become over the years a huge repository of theory texts and therefore a vital tool for artists, theorists and academics, who have not access to academic libraries or are not able to find the material in institutional repositories.
Other practices likewise share the aim to counter institutional distribution monopolies and a wide range of online repositories have been built over the last two decades. However these repositories differ in one crucial aspect from user generated peer-to-peer platforms in that they are individually curated. Ubuweb, for example is a highly controlled online archive for text, audio and video and curated by conceptual writer Kenneth Goldsmiths in New York. Monoskop, a private book collection turned into a public online archive run by Dusan Barok in Amsterdam. The Public Collectors online archive is curated and maintained by Marc Fisher in Chicago (Temporary Services).[16] In contrast to these digital libraries Antonia Hirsch’s The Surplus Library on Affect & Economic Exchange instigates the lending of individually owned hardcopy books, mediated through an online platform, which indicates the location of the book to be lent from (mostly) private book collections.[17]
While this second set of platforms operate as accessible repositories built through generous acts of critical archiving, they are not user run and are in most cases tightly connected to an individual (artist). The question and problem which has been addressed in recent activist discourse is to find ways how such infrastructures could be collectivised in order to secure the accessibility and usability of decades of content digitising and archiving for future generations.
Historically libraries operated in two ways, as philanthropic institutions “providing access to knowledge for every member of the community” but equally as disciplinary institutions. Disciplinary, because only selected material has been validated as worthwhile being included and passed on. This creates a canon. It can be expanded and opened up to new entries and views, however a library serving a white middle class male readership gathers material for the white Western middle class readership. If no topics are included, that serves a newly arrived immigrant community or the queer, trans, lesbian community, these groups won’t count as patrons. So, the question arises whether the library shapes its readership or the readers the library. And how to escape this on-going self-reproducing mechanism?
All the above described practices share the concern how to provide access to material, which is not collected by institutional libraries or archives or is tucked away in private collections. Implicit in the question of access is the question of finding, and therefore of organising, indexing and cataloguing.
Topic Classification
Classifying, indexing, summarising or key-wording is always an act of interpretation. It is a framing procedure, controlling how content will be found and interpreted. Mevil Dewey’s classification system for example, which has become a standard organising system in many public libraries world wide has been criticised by his biographer as being based on “a patriarchal White Western (and, of course, Christian)” worldview. (Wiegand xxx) What is left out here is a whole range of alternative perspectives on humanity’s knowledge. (see detailed discussion: Weinmayr, Library Underground, p.166).
Problem 1: Universal Language The radical library movement in the 70 and 80s were looking at such biases. In particular Sanford Berman’s study “Prejudices and Antipathies-A Tract on the Library of Congress Subject Heads Concerning People” (Berman 1971) revealed that Library of Congress subject headings, particularly those that are used to identify groups of people, perpetuate “the exclusionary cultural supremacy of the mainstream patriarchal, Euro-settler culture” (Olson 2000). In a word, many subject headings exhibit “bias”: that is, they use language that shows a prejudice in favour of particular points of view, and against others. Berman’s study and critique actually resulted in changes in the LC catalogue: 64% of Berman’s suggested “remedies” have been implemented since the publication of his critique, but the 80 items, which remain unchanged show some patterns of thought pertaining to the Christian religion. (Knowlton, 2005) (Please watch the video Library Underground for a detailed discussion.)
However cataloguing is not only controlling how specific content is framed, it also deter-mines whether content will be found at all. Internet search engines, for example, are the front door to the www. Google’s search algorithm can be easily adjusted, and search results manipulated according to specific interests.
KvinnSam, the National Resource Library for Gender Studies at Gothenburg University
developed a response to biased cataloguing. In 1958 three librarians at Gothenburg University library started collecting and cataloguing women literature, material about women struggle for suffrage and got aware that within the existing holdings was plenty of material relevant to women and gender struggle, but it was not catalogued as such. The relevant keywords were missing and therefore hard to find. The librarian started to establish a parallel keyword catalogue, analog at the time, by indexing the already existing holdings of Gothenburg University library in order to make aspects of gender manifest and therefore searchable. Today, Kvinnsam is a digital keyword search catalog which operates parallel to the standard search catalogue. It can be browsed in order to find specific material, that would not show up in the standard catalog.
Feminist Search Tool
A similar activism to question the architecture and implicit biases in the organisation of knowledge drives a group of contemporary artists, who are affiliated with the Read-in collective in Utrecht. Collaborating with the librarians at Utrecht University library they developed a Feminist Search Tool, which starts from the question: “Why are the authors of the books I read so white, so male, so Eurocentric?” To answer this question they developed a digital interface, based on the library’s Marc21** fields, an international digital cataloguing standard (Machine-Readable Cataloguing), which aims to map the existing library records (from 2006-2016) applying different categories, such as race, gender, ethnicity, nationality, class. The digital interface invites the users to apply different categories to their search and maps the existing library records from 2006 – 2016 according to selected filters, such as language of publication, place of publication, type of publisher, gender of author. The search results then map how many female non-Western authors and female authors of colour are represented and therefore reveal inclusion and exclusion mechanisms of our knowledge institutes. In contrast to KvinnSam search engine developed in Gothenburg it is not a search engine for known-item search, delivery search, that is a search for a specific item for which either the authors or the title is known. Instead th Feminist search tool operates as an “awareness-raising tool to stir conversations about the inclusion and exclusion mechanisms that are inherent to our current Western knowledge economy and our own complicities in (re)producing what is considered as ‘knowledge’ (and what is not).” As such this intervention is not be seen as a replacement for the UU library catalogue, “but a supplementary tool for any inquiring person to approach one’s own biases and taken for granted truths that one is reproducing whilst studying and researching”.
Radical Librarianship / Teaching The Radical Catalog
A large body of research has documented biases of gender, sexuality, age, class, ethnicity, language and religion in the construction of an universal language in the naming of information for retrieval. This universal language uses a controlled vocabulary to represent documents. It limits diversity and has direct practical impact on the reader searching for materials outside of a traditional mainstream, materials crossing disciplines or marginalised topics. This controlled vocabulary appears unbiased and universally applicable - but it actually hides its exclusions under the guise of neutrality. According to library scholar and teacher Emily Drabinski “classification schemes are socially produced and embedded structures. They are products of human labor that carry traces of all the intentional and unintentional racism, sexism, and classism of the workers who create them. It is not possible to do classification objectively. It is the nature of subject analysis to be subjective.” (Drabinski, exact quote? 201x)
Problem 2: Hierarchical Structure, Fixity
Library activists such as Berman, whose suggested remedies to the LC subject headings, such as the elimination of the conspicuous racist “Yellow Peril” in 1989, has called attention to the hegemonic nature of classification. However, as Drabinski argues, while he is struggling to change the thesaurus he leaves the structural problems untouched. And according to Drabinski Berman’s approach actually presupposes, that there is some “right” language, that could be universally understood and applied.” But the politics of language is virtually always contested. “And the struggle for a universal “correct” language does not account for the ways in which language is inherently political and contextual.” Language and descriptors are also in motion, when it comes to shifting identities….
[indigenous classifications….]
Therefore critical feminist libraries developed contextual, local classifications, which are user-centred for particular collections, or put effort, funds and energy in developing a user centred classification for particular collections, such as the Glasgow Women Library and The Feminist Library in London. It is the critical engaging with the catalogue and its architecture, which is at stake. Not uncritically taking the classification for granted “as though it were a natural landscape rather than a well-manicured lawn that is the product of intellectual labor”. (Olson)
>>>> Drabinski Teaching the Radical Catalog: Alongside revising the library catalogue: teaching its implicit contestations and biases.
These contestations around subject classification relate mainly to physical libraries. In online repositories, the introduction of full text search and keywords help to a certain extent to overcome the problem. To a certain extent, because the interfaces provide a limited structure for Metadata, as we will see further below.
Dissemination: Digital Turn / Open Access
Can current academic publishing ecosystem learn from experimental artistic and feminist publishing practices? How can these experimental interventions potentially reform inequalities, streamlining and metrication of academic publishing? The call for publicly funded research at universities to be published open access shifts the major part of research outputs into the digital realm.
- radical open access as potential to transform the structures of institutional authority and legitimacy?.
- building of commons-based open access publishing infrastructures for promoting a more diverse, not-for-profit eco-system of scholarly communication
- values that underpin many of the radical open access community’s experiments in open publishing
- Problem: OA complicit with neoliberalism’s audit culture of evaluation, measurement, impact and accountability. Open Access arguably has become a “mandate”, a top-down requirement rather than a bottom-up scholar-led movement for change.
- experiments reclaiming open access from corporate take over (APC - Gold Model, Elsevier & co)
- exploring how an ethics of care can help to counter the calculative logic (metrification) that permeates academic publishing. (Mattering Press)
- alt metrics - gaming the system (Marina Frantzen & Punctum Press)
- “Higher education has a culture problem that is at once historical, structural, and interpersonal”– To confront the toxic culture of higher education HuMetricsHSS Initiative propose a value-based “metric” framework around values such as equity, openness, collegiality, quality, and community, which not only functions as a checkpoint for self-reflection, but also as a starting point for better academic practices and outputs. (Christopher Long, HuMetricsHSS Initiative Michigan State University)
- Making publishing more diverse and equitable – geographically, but also with respect to issues of class, race, ethnicity, gender and sexuality
- Nurturing new and historically under-represented cultures of knowledge – those associated with early career, precariously employed and para-academics, or located outside the global North and West?
- ethical academic publishing: how to ensure everyone is able to have a voice – particularly those writing on niche or avant-garde topics or who are conducting hybrid, multimodal, post-literary forms of research, and who are currently underserved by our profit-focused commercial publishing system.
- understanding publishing very much as a complex, multi-agential, relational practice
- What is the potential of new forms of “open cooperativism” in which organisations commit themselves “structurally and legally to the production of common goods (the common good, the commons)”? (Bauwens 2016)
- Coventry University’s Centre for Disruptive Media (CDM) and the Disruptive Media Learning Lab (DMLL): How is media practice disruptive of and re-performing the way we do scholarly communication and education? How can the Journal of Media Practice reconfigure (the politics of) its own practice? What should a disruptive ‘journal’ of media practice look / sound / feel like?
- Can open access and open source transform the institution of the university itself?
Notes
- ↑ John Perrault, Some Thoughts on Books as Art, in Artists Books (1973: 15–21) quoted by Tony White in Book 2.0 in Volume 3 Number 2, 2013, page 168. doi: 10.1386/btwo.3.2.163_1
- ↑ John Baldessari for example writes in 1975: “I enjoy giving books I have made to others. Art seems pure for a moment and disconnected from money. And since a lot of people can own the book, nobody owns it. Every artist should have a cheap line. It keeps art ordinary and away from being overblown.” in Art-Rite (Anon. 1976/1977: 6)
- ↑ Kostelanetz, originally published in “Exhaustive Parallel Intervals”, Future Press, 1979, reprinted in Joan s (ed), Artists’ Books: a Critical Anthology and Sourcebook, Rochester, New York, Visual Studies Workshop Press, 1993, p.13.
- ↑ Lucy R. Lippard, ‘The Artist’s Book Goes Public’, in Joan s (ed), Artists’ Books: a Critical Anthology and Sourcebook, Rochester, New York, Visual Studies Workshop Press, 1993, p.45.
- ↑ ART RITE Magazine 11/12, winter/spring 1975/1976, p.3
- ↑ Joan Lyons (ed), “Artists’ Books: a Critical Anthology and Sourcebook”, Rochester, New York, Visual Studies Workshop Press, 1993, p8.
- ↑ Printed Matter founded by Lucy Lippard, Sol Lewitt and… in xxxx, Franklin Furnace, Ulisses Carrion started “Other Books” in Amsterdam, AA Bronson started Art Metropole in Toronto in xxx.
- ↑ Ed Ruscha letter to John Wilcock, 25 February 1966, The Piracy Collection, London, the archives of Giorno Poetry Systems. Ed Ruscha’s 26 Gasoline Stations book is today traded for 20,000$. >Reference Abebooks:xx
- ↑ New York Times Special Edition. See documentation New York Times Hoax - The Yes Men Fix The World https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YoZQNgAnvqs. Interview with Steve Lambert in Fillip Magazine winter 2009: https://fillip.ca/content/best-case-scenario, and Steve Lambert website https://visitsteve.com/made/the-ny-times-special-edition/
- ↑ See Jess Baines’ text “Free Radicals” about radical Print shops emerging in London in 1968, as DiY sites of political and community activism. Afterall, 28.1.2010 http://www.afterall.org/online/radical.printmaking#.V8iDdmUWw20
- ↑ Suzy Mackie and Pru Stevenson, founding members of See Red in a blog post http://www.seeredwomensworkshop.wordpress.com
- ↑ See also Eva Weinmayr, Library Underground - A reading list for a coming community, in Publishing as Artistic Practice, ed by Annette Gilbert, Sternberg Press 2016.
- ↑ Marcell Mars, Manar Zarroug, and Tomislav Medak, End-to-End Catalog: Memory of the World, November 26, 2012, https:// www.memoryoftheworld.org/ end-to-end-catalog/.
- ↑ “The Public School was initiated in 2007 in Los Angeles in the basement of Telic Arts Exchange. The Public School is a school with no curriculum. It is not accredited, it does not give out degrees, and it has no affiliation with the public school system. It is a framework that supports autodidactic activities, operating under the assumption that everything is in everything.” See http://thepublicschool.org/la.
- ↑ See interview conducted by German artist Cornelia Sollfrank with Sean Dockray and Marcell Mars as part of her research project “Giving what you don’t have”, Postmedialab, Leuphana University, Lüneburg, 2012. http://artwarez.org/projects/GWYDH/.
- ↑ Self-description: “Public Collectors is founded upon the concern that there are many types of cultural artifacts that public libraries, museums and other institutions and archives either do not collect or do not make freely accessible. Public Collectors asks individuals that have had the luxury to amass, organize, and inventory these materials to help reverse this lack by making their collections public. Public Collectors features informal agreements where collectors allow the contents of their collection to be published or exhibited, and permit those who are curious to directly experience the objects in person. Collectors can be based in any geographic location.” http://www.publiccollectors.org/
- ↑ Self-description: “In redefining the concept of a physical library, the Surplus Library on Affect & Economic Exchange operates on the basic assumption that its specific collection of books already exists in the material world: in the homes and private collections of countless individuals. Some of the holdings of this vast and distributed library can become known and accessible through The Surplus Library site. The site develops as the library’s holdings and locations are registered by users.” [1].
What are the experiments that I have carried out?
The just described activities and theorisations in the wider field of publishing and the formation of knowledge serve as a backdrop for a string of related practical experiments I carried out during my own artistic career between 1998 and 2018. They are practice examples where acts of publication, distribution and consumption have been rethought in order to firstly articulate enclosures, exclusions and oppressions originated by dominant power structures and secondly to experiment with and develop different models, that facilitate an emancipatory, intersectional, de-colonial feminist knowledge formation. As such they can be described as counter-political projects that are held against dominant approaches to the topic.
One characteristic of these experiments is that most of them are collaborations. They developed responses to specific problems, which I identified with other artists in order to create an alternative. These greatly differing instances cannot be understood within a conventional publishing framework, rather they fall into the expanded category and loosened definition of “creating a public”.
A pivotal common aim and approach of these experiments is that they don't intend to make works 'about politics'. Instead they aim at finding operational models to work counter-politically – through the actual practice itself. Hence my artistic concern is not to illustrate a political position, but to actively engage in political experiments in publishing yielding impact and results.
The experiments discussed below fall in a wide range of contexts. What they have in common though is that they can all be seen in relation to institutions – with some just being commissioned by institutions, others being located within institutions, with and without official mandate, and yet a third group deliberately instituted outside institutions in order to create a transversal collective space often inoperable within mainstream institutions.
Lastly, most of these experiments are projected long-term. They develop over time in order to test out various agile approaches. If one approach is not working it is adapted and applied again from a different angle. That is the reason, why the following list is so comprehensive.
Summary of projects and submitted material
AND Publishing –– with Rosalie Schweiker, multiple collaborators
(2009 - ongoing)
AND is a collaborative publishing activity, based in London. Initiated in 2009, it seeks to develop infrastructures of publishing starting from three questions: Why publish, how and for whom? Observing that the existing institutional infrastructures keep replicating the exclusionary mechanisms and hierarchies dominating the university, AND started, without mandate [1], at Byam Shaw School of Art in London as an indy-university press, publishing works of students, staff and alumni in an equitable and non-hierarchical manner.[2] Next to exploring the immediacy and social possibilities of print on demand and new modes of distribution, AND also explores the social agency of cultural piracy. AND is also invested in feminist radical pedagogy, builds informal support structures by sharing a studio, providing resources and advice, as well as access to skills, means of production and distribution. AND re-distributes budgets, commissions work, and (re-)publishes material which is difficult to find. The members of AND are part of a divers network of critical, feminist, de-colonial publishing activities and campaigns.[3]
Website andpublishing.org Visit
The long list of equal "ands" on the website indicates, that we are less concerned with developing a focused brand or a unified face. Rather it is about building a network of mutual alliances by working with people as well as institutions. The range of publications we produce, help produce or distribute can be seen here.here.
Published text 'One publishes to find comrades'
>> Eva Weinmayr in "Publishing Manifestos", edited by Michalis Pichler, Yaiza Camps, Moritz Grünke, Cambridge Massachusetts: MIT, 2018. It was originally published in “The Visual Event, an education in appearances”, edited by Oliver Klimpel, Spector Books, Leipzig, 2014 Download
The text investigates feminist practices of publishing as a way to initiate a social process or build a social space wherein meaning is generated via the co-created publications. The text discusses publishing practices, where printed publications, posters or zines are not necessarily an end product trying to convince someone of something, but rather a method of “working towards establishing conditions for the co-production of meaning".[4]
Published interview: 'AND not OR, the Anatomy of AND'
>>Conversation between Anette Gilbert, Eva Weinmayr and Rosalie Schweiker about AND's collective feminist practice in "Publish! Publizieren als künstlerische Praxis", Kunstforum International issue 256, September 2018 (in German). 'AND not OR, the Anatomy of AND' Visit
The interview, itself being published in an anthology about contemporary artist publishing, is an interesting case of intellectual streamlining and simplification of a messy and multilayered practice. The crucial point is here to draw the fine line between promotion or advertising and the "telling about".
Library of Inclusions and Omissions
(2016–ongoing)
The Library of Inclusions and Omissions (LIO) is a practice-based experiment to set up a reference library that is curated by the community using it. So far roughly 100 contributions are on shelf. The collection is available to the public via temporary reading rooms. The library gathers feminist, intersectional, postcolonial materials which are not, or only sparsely available in institutional collections or databases, too flimsy in format or otherwise not validated by publishing houses or institutions such as libraries. Can such a curatorial concept help to give voice to undiscovered, suppressed or otherwise not acknowledged material? Can this turn a library from a repository of knowledge into a space of social and intellectual encounter?
Library of Omissions and Inclusions: The open call
Download Open Call English Swedish, Arabic
In order to receive contributions from a range of different cultural backgrounds and communities, the open call was published in Swedish, English and Arabic and distributed in community centres, libraries, universities, art spaces in and around Gothenburg (including suburbs such as Angered).
Library of Omissions and Inclusions: The index card catalogue
The practice of this library challenges the concept of neutrality and universality in standard cataloguing systems. Instead of using the 'controlled vocabulary' and classifications of institutional libraries, the LIO asks contributors for a short written rationale, why this book is important to them and why they want to share it with others. Through this the emphasis shifts from trying to frame the actual content of the book in an arguably objective manner towards describing the readers' personal making of meaning and the publications agency for the reader. The short statements are printed on the LIO´s index cards thus serving as an entry point and framing device for the library users. This subjective catalogue approach can be understood as an experiment to connect people through their readings, discoveries, desires, struggles and hopes.
Library of Omissions and Inclusions: Temporary Reading Rooms installed in different contexts.
- Reading room at 'Meaning Making Meaning', A-venue Gothenburg, 16 March-2 April 2016
Visit webpage
- The platform 'Meaning Making Meaning' was a three-part project convened by Gabo Camnitzer and consisted of an exhibition, a series of workshops and the LOI´s reading room. In the exhibition and related workshops, 37 artists and educators responded to two questions: “How do you bring a classroom to life as if it were a work of art?” (Felix Guattari, Chaosmosis) and its reformulation: “How do you bring a work of art to life as if it were a classroom?” [5]
- Reading room at 'Meaning Making Meaning', A-venue Gothenburg, 16 March-2 April 2016
- Reading room at 'The Research Show', A-venue Gothenburg, April 2016
- 'The Research Show' was an informal work in progress exhibition from doctoral researchers based in the artistic faculty of the University of Gothenburg, where it was convened by Cora Hillebrand, Ram Krishna Ranjan, and Mick Wilson.[6]
- Reading room at 'Let’s Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?', Valand Academy, 12-14 Oct 2016
- The Library of Omissions and Inclusions was installed during the three-day international mobilisation dealing with queer and feminist pedagogies. Participants of the event came from seven European countries. They were asked to bring material to add to the library. 'Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?' was organised by the Feminist Pedagogy working group at Valand Academy. [7] (see detailed project description below).
- Reading room at 'Utopia of Access', Pavilion for Artistic Research, Venice Biennale, 11 May - 2 July 2017
- Curators Jan Kaila (Uniarts Helsinki) and Henk Slager (Utrecht University) invited ten researchers from different Nordic doctoral programs to articulate new modes of artistic thinking regarding the notion of access. My approach to install a reading room in Venice was led by questions such as: Can a collectively owned resource be exhibited at an international art show such as the Venice Biennale? What are the underlying politics of 'exhibiting' a collectively owned resource, based in a local community in Sweden, in the context of such a worldwide show? Can I exhibit 1:1 scale photographic representation of the books on the shelves? How can I 'tell' about this practice? Can I exhibit its method as a proposal to create and sustain a non-normative knowledge commons? I presented a 1:1 scale photographic representation of the books on their shelves accompanied by a printed pamphlet discussing the politics of exhibition making as an act of taking rooted things out of original contexts and as a step of artistic co-option. (see text 'Dear Hannah')
- Reading Room at AND Publishing Research Residency – 'Boxing and Unboxing', Marabouparken Konsthall, 21 April – 26 August 2018
- A similar analysis was applied when selected publications from the Library of Omissions and Inclusion were installed at MarabouParken Konsthall in Stockholm in summer 2018. Playing with the pun 'Boxing and Unboxing', we planned to display cardboard boxes, shipped from London to Stockholm, containing materials we were working on at the time and to invite visitors to 'unbox' its contents,[8] In order to escape the limiting exhibition framing and to create a more conducive environment for this intended process of discovery, we decided to move out of the designated exhibition hall and to go 'backstage'. We negotiated with the institution to take over a spare room between the kitchen and the administrative offices on the first floor of MarabouParken Konsthall. The spatial proximity of the artists' Unboxing Room to the usually not accessible admin offices allowed us and the visitors to work in daylight and it made the else hidden work taking place in the offices visible to visitors.
Published text: 'Dear Hannah'. On the occasion of 'Utopia of Access', Pavilion of Artistic Research, Venice Biennale 2017
The text reflects on issues of co-option and the dilemma of 'exhibiting' a collective resource, which is based in a local community, within the context of an international art biennale. It is written in epistolary form addressing an undisclosed peer artist named Hannah. It has been published via email using my professional and personal email lists and was also available as printed pamphlet and element of my work in the exhibition 'Utopia of Access', Venice Biennale 2017. Download text
Published chapter 'Library Underground – a reading list for a coming community
>>in: "Publishing as Artistic Practice", edited Annette Gilbert, Berlin/New York: Sternberg, 2016.
This chapter, written in the form of a dialogue between Eva Weinmayr and her inner voice, discusses modes of knowledge dissemination. The text reflects on libraries as spaces where private knowledge is turned into public goods. It discusses the radical librarian movements of the 70s and 80s and deals with the topic from three fundamental angles: (i) who is a library for (the status quo at the time was a male, white, western and middle-class user community), (ii) what material is missing in libraries in order to "serve every member of the community"(American Library Bill of Rights, 1930x) and (iii) what implicit biases in the organisation and classification of knowledge can be found in libraries (Berman 1985x). The text also discusses a range of contemporary practices of radical librarianship - such as aaaaarg.fail, memoryofthe world, the Piracy Project - as well as practices which respond to the problems of marketisation and monopolisation of knowledge. Download chapter
Performative reading of chapter 'Library Underground' at 'Miss Read', Akademie der Künste Berlin, 2016
Miss Read Artist Book Festival and conference, organised by Michalis Pichler, Yaiza Camps, Moritz Grünke. The panel 'Publishing as Artistic Practice' was convened by Annette Gilbert. The performative reading of a revised and updated script of the original text 'Library Underground' was performed by Eva Weinmayr as Eva Weinmayr and Eleanor Vonne Brown as Inner Voice.
Filmed performative reading of chapter 'Library Underground- welcome to my tent' at symposium 'Photography in Print and Circulation', Valand Academy Gothenburg, 2016
Convened by Louise Wolthers (Hasselblad Foundation and Niclas Östlind, Valand Academy).
The text has been performed from inside a trekking tent installed on the stage of Valand's main lecture hall with a video camera transmitting what happens inside the tent onto the lecture hall screen. With Eva Weinmayr as Eva Weinmayr and Rose Borthwick as Inner Voice. Filmed and edited by Camilla Topuntoli. Video 32 min. Library Underground - watch video
Published presentation: 'Radical publishing practices ask for radical librarianship' at: 'Artists as Publishers as Artists', University of Media Arts Cologne
During this presentation I published my manuscript live on Twitter, providing links to images and references I used. It was an attempt to share and publish the bibliography of my manuscript with the audience in order to be revisited after the talk.[9] Read the presentation
Alternative cataloguing workshop: 'Reading Gendered Words'
at: Symposium "Library Interventions", Leeds College of Art, April 2017 with Rosalie Schweiker. The workshop was convened by Rosa Nussbaum and included a conversation between Maria Fusco and Wendy Kirk (Glasgow Women Library) around cataloguing practices at the Glasgow Women Library. Its aim was to develop unorthodox approaches to cataloguing selected titles from the Library of Omissions and Inclusions in order to experiment with alternatives to the normative “controlled vocabulary” used in the standardised library classification systems.
The Piracy Project – with Andrea Francke and multiple collaborators (2010–ongoing)
I began The Piracy Project in 2010 together with artist Andrea Francke. Through an open call for pirated books and by researching pirate book markets in Peru, China and Turkey, The Piracy Project gathered a collection of around 150 copied, emulated, appropriated and modified books from across the world. Their copying approaches vary widely, from playful strategies of reproduction, modification and reinterpretation of existing works to circumventing enclosures such as censorship or market monopolies, to acts of piracy generated by commercial interests. This collection of books serves as the starting point to explore the common understanding of authorship, originality and the implications policy and legal developments have had on intellectual property and copyright. Through temporary reading rooms, workshops, lectures, discussions and debates The Piracy Project explores the philosophical, legal and social implications of cultural piracy and creative modes of dissemination.
| Searchable online catalogue Searchable online catalogue |
Discursive events organised between 2010 – 2015 include
For a full list please visit xxxxx. |
Forthcoming chapter 'The Piracy Project', in “Archives of the Commons II - the Anomic Archive”, Red Conceptualismo del Sur, Museo Nacional Reina Sofia Madrid, 2018
The chapter is a revised manuscript of my presentation in the seminar "Socialising Archives" hold during the symposium "Archives of the Commons II" at Reina Sofia in Madrid, which was chaired by Mabel Tapia. I took this invitation and its distinct question to share experiences and methods, the operational strategies to turn the archive into a space of social and intellectual encounter as opportunity to reflect the curatorial and operational strategies we employed while working on The Piracy Project.
[read here the draft version]
Forthcoming chapter 'What Matter who’s speaking' in “Whose Book is it anyway - an anthology”, Cambridge: Open Book Publishers, 2019
The anthology is edited by Sarah Kember and Janis Jeffries, Goldsmiths University London, and CREATe (RCUK Centre for Copyright and New Business Models in the Creative Economy, University of Glasgow). I took this text as an opportunity to investigate the relationship between authorship and copyright, as it is presented to us from a legal, economic and institutional perspective. I do this by three means: I investigate through literary review how artists have arguably challenged the close ties between authorship and copyright looking at cases, such as Richard Prince and Cady Noland. Secondly I reflect how the question of authorship plays out in the collective practice 'The Piracy Project'. Thirdly I turn this essay itself into a practice-based experiment by asking how it would live and circulate and be validated in institutional research economies, if I didn't assign my name and therefore authorship to the text.
Published interview 'The Piracy Project' at 'Giving What you don’t have', 2013
Cornelia Sollfrank interviews Andrea Francke and Eva Weinmayr in the context of 'Giving What you don’t have', an artistic research project by Cornelia Sollfrank exploring the relationship between art and the commons at Postdigital Publishing Lab, Leuphana University, Lüneburg Watch the interview or read the transcript
Transcript of interview 'The Piracy Project' – Abigail de Kossnik (Berkeley Media studies) interviews Andrea Francke and Eva Weinmayr, 2016
Published text 'The Impermanent Book', co-authored with Andrea Francke, Rhizome, 2012
The text was included as print edition in 'Best of Rhizome 2012' edited by Joanne McNeil, Brescia: LINK Editions, 2013 The text looks at the desire of dealing with a stable book, an permanent object, which is resolved and fixed in print. It argues, that it is the technical advances of the analogue printing press combined with mass production that constructs the contemporary idea of books as fixed objects. A concept where immutability is a key factor that allows for mass and consistent reproduction. What are the consequences for the book as the authoritative object, to which one can always come back to, when digital technology facilitates mass production and mutability at the same time? Digital print and print-on demand have become widespread and allow for continuous changes, adaptions and revisions. The text discusses the assumed unease and fundamental challenge this kind of versioning exerts on the reader. What happens when books become unreliable objects, when one copy of the book potentially tells a different story than the other? Read text on Rhizome.org
Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy? three-day mobilization and workbook – with Feminist Pedagogy working group at Valand Academy, University of Gothenburg (2015–2016)
'Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?' is a long-term investigation into queer and feminist pedagogies, that led to the collective organising of a three-day international mobilisation at Valand Academy in October 2016. The Feminist pedagogies working group consisted of students and staff at the academy (names). Its aim was twofold: Firstly the bi-weekly gatherings which were open to the whole academy provided a space to reflect on our own learning and teaching experiences, to read together and discuss relevant texts as well as to share infos and news, which were not officially communicated. The second and related aim was to organise an international conference, which developed alternatives to the dominant norms of conference organisation by fundamentally rethinking the terms and conditions of how knowledge is created and disseminated. Accompanying the event, a workbook was published, which tested the agency of publishing in terms of rethinking the processes of production and distribution.
Working group 2015-2016
How we worked. Why it was created. The shared readings. The format of the meetings.
Published Workbook: 'Let's Mobilize What is Feminist Pedagogy?'
Download workbook
Rethinking the production and dissemination of a book.
- How to invite others in the conversation? Make your own copy: Collective collating and binding. The distribution. Hanging poster-pages in the academy=turning the academy in a walkable book. Contextual distribution. Has been used as course reading in courses at the academy. Is beeing downloaded online. Circulates through indy bookshops.
- Collective editing process. Analogue editing. Scan as binding method.(Michael Murtaugh)
The organising of the mobilisation - administrative creativity
Struggling with university procurement. How rules and regulations shape what can be done and how it's been done.
Subsequent invitations to workshops and talks
The different experiences of 'telling about' (a presentation at Exploiting Justice, Symposium, Centre for Interdisciplinary Gender Research, University of Gothenburg, 2016) and 'doing together' (workshop with students at Cologne University, Institute of Art and Art History: Feminist Arts Education series)
Forthcoming chapter 'Outside the Page' in issue "The Filmic Page", On Curating ZHdK Zürich
Forthcoming chapter 'Make your own adventure' (working title) in "Decolonialism after the educational turn"
The working group took the invitation to contribute a chapter to this book as an opportunity to revisit the collectively authored "glossary" in the 'Let's Mobilize workbook' in which we explained the reasons and the aims for the mobilisation. This act of revisiting the original text allowed us to reflect with hindsight on our working together. By using the method of layered commenting, we preserved each authors voice instead of streamlining the writing into observations and statements each member could agree with. Here the collective writing of a text becomes a place for dialogue and disagreements. It builds on experiments of non linear writing done by Arno Schmidt 'Zettel's Dream'(1979) and Pierre Bayles 'Historical and Critical Dictionary'(ca 1690).
| Published documents |
Unboxing, AND Research Residency, MarabouParken Konsthall, Stockholm – with Rosalie Schweiker April – August 2018
During the three-months research residency at MarabouParken in Stockholm AND Publishing organised together with curator Jenny Richards boxing training for self-defining women, installed an "Unboxing Room" with the boxes of materials they brought from their UK based practice and held three public talks.
MarabouParken Konsthall's evolving strand of research residencies aims to collaborate with artists groups and collectives in order to support their practice by developing "new lines of inquiry over a 3 month period and share these with a public through workshop and events.[10] The overarching strand called "Acts of Self-ruin" was based on Leela Ghandi's book "The Common Cause" inviting collectives to explore the struggle for collectivity and equality in an age of individualism. .[11]
Terms and Conditions of working with institution
In order to reach clarity about the mutual expectations concerning the five months research residency AND, together with MarabouParkens curator Jenny Richards, developed a document titled 'terms and conditions' and a related contract between the artists and the institution. That document was regularly revised and adapted over the course of the residency. Selected points discussed in this document referred to "visibility on our own terms" (images, announcements, framing), public engagement, transparent budget.
Set of posters [see posters]
A set of four posters were printed and circulated in the imminent neighbourhood and across Stockholm. Translated into Swedish, English, Arabic and Tigrinya (the two biggest ethnic groups in the area of the Konsthall), they announced two weeks of boxing training for women, girls, trans and non-binary people in order to learn more about non-verbal negotiation, care, anger, dialogue, transgressions and defence. The boxing classes were free and open for all abilities, ages (16+), shapes and religions and were an experiment to learn to relate to each other and to negotiate the many conflicts and contradictions which shape our living and working together.
Boxing classes
For the boxing classes Stockholm based boxers Sofia Thorne and Airin Fardipour have been invited to develop a two week intense course for beginners. The boxing classes took place at 'Project Playground', an after school club for immigrants in Hallonbergen. The course taught lets of technique, the basic moves and punches, as well as extensive sparring and body contact work and finished with a one-round fight competition.
'Unboxing Calendar', published by AND Publishing London / MarabouParken Konsthall, Stockholm, 2018
A calendar with 52 weekly pages containing collectively with the boxers' produced visuals. The collages result from a one-day workshop, where we tried to revisit the spirit and adventures during the boxing classes and to articulate visually the experiences, that could not easily be verbalised. The visuals in the calendar are accompanied by a text written by Ar Parmacek, at the time intern at MarabouParken Konsthall, which reflects some of the concerns of the project from her perspective of an co-organiser and observant. Choosing the form of a calendar as publication genre aims to embed its issues and contents into everyday life. A year of daily boxing and unboxing.
Topic Co-option
Published book 'Downing Street', New Documents, Los Angeles, 2015
The Downing St. or Help! David Cameron Likes My Art is a play script, using, as a starting point, a real circumstance: Eva Weinmayr’s work 'Today Questions' was borrowed from the UK Government Art Collection by David and Samantha Cameron for their private residence at Downing St. when they first moved in. Weinmayr’s attempt to contact The Prime Minister and his wife to discuss this was ignored, so she, in collaboration with writer John Moseley and journalist Titus Kroder, scripted the meeting that had been denied. The play imagines that the Camerons invite the Eva Weinmayr to visit them and while the artist Eva has tea with Samantha Cameron a rather unexpected set of events starts to unfold. The play acts as a catalyst for debate: The audience, which is scripted as a persona in the play, repeatedly interrupts the narrative in order to suggest a different strategy how to resolve Eva’s dilemma. The script has been premiered as Twitter broadcast, where each character tweeted their lines from the character's specially for this purpose set-up Twitter account (David Cameron, Samantha Cameron, Eva Weinmayr, Uzbek Ambassador,Horse Guard etc.) Subsequently it has been performed live in private and public venues, such as Edinburgh Festival, a pub, a friend’s living room, as well as a rehearsed performance at the Showroom in London directed by Hester Chillingworth of company GETBACKINTHEVAN.
Published chapter: Help! David Cameron Likes my Art, in "Distributed", Open Editions 2017
edited David Blamey and xxxx.
The invitation to contribute to "Distributed" allowed me to reflect on the complexities around the process of co-option, which happened when David and Samantha Cameron borrowed my work for their private residence in London in 2010. More....
chapter to be written: Eva Weinmayr/Heiner Müller, Keep it Complex/Wolfgang Tillmans
Notes
- ↑ Support included colleagues's offer to share office and equipment, including publishing classes in their courses inviting AND to develop publishing projects with students, facilitating work-based learning internships with AND. The management quickly realised the critical and socially generative potential of our activity and provided small funds and semi-official support
- ↑ AND was co-founded by Lynn Harris and Eva Weinmayr. Andrea Francke worked temporarily with AND. Today it is run by Rosalie Schweiker and Eva Weinmayr.
- ↑ OOMK, X Marks the Bökship, Keep it Complex in London
- ↑ Stevphen Shukaitis, Toward an Insurrection of the Published? Ten Thoughts on Ticks & Comrades, eicp transversal, June 2014 [2]
- ↑ It included work by Alina Tenser, Andrea Phillips, Ann-Charlotte Glasberg Blomqvist, Annette Krauss, Anton Vidokle, Barnfilmskolan, Bronwyn Bailey-Charteris, Cara Tolmie and Kimberley O’Neill, Doa Aly, Elizabeth Ellsworth and Jamie Kruse (Smudge Studio), Emanuel Almborg, Eva Weinmayr, Felicity Allen, Gert Biesta and Carl Anders Säfström, Glenn Loughran, Harrell Fletcher, Henry Giroux, Irit Rogoff, Janna Graham, Jaroslav Andel, Jason E. Bowman, Jenny Richards, Jessica Hamlin, Jeuno JE Kim and Ewa Einhorn, Katrin Ingelstedt, Lisa Nyberg, Lovisa Gustafsson, Maj Hasager, Maria Acaso and Jordi Ferreiro, Monica Sand, Olav Westphalen, Olivia Plender, Pedro Lasch, Stephan Dillemuth, Stephen Duncombe, Sunshine Socialist Cinema, and Tyson E. Lewis.
- ↑ Participating artists were André Alves, Eva la Cour, Kerstin Hamilton, Annelies Vaneycken, Arne Kjell Vikhagen, and Eva Weinmayr.
- ↑ The core working group's members were Andreas Engman, Eva Weinmayr, Gabo Cammnitzer, Kanchan Burathoki, Mary Coble, and Rose Borthwick.
- ↑ for example The Piracy Project, Teaching for people who prefer not to teach, The Library of Omissions and Inclusions, Let’s Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?, https://www.artsadmin.co.uk/events/3850 a selection of good and bad sports bras (D cup and upwards)], Keep It Complex, as well as our terms and conditions, emails and other miscellaneous items.
- ↑ Organised by Agustina Andreoletti, Lilian Haberer, Karin Lingnau, Konstantin Butz. Supported by Birgit Trogemann See programme
- ↑ Invitation email from curator Jenny Richards, 7 August 2017
- ↑ MarabouParken website
Reflection, theorisation of projects and submitted material
I will in the following systematically unpick the questions underlying the various practices and experiments I carried out and have chosen to be considered in this PhD. As a general introductory remark, artistic practices are always multilayered and driven by a range of questions and desires. It would therefore be limiting to reduce such complex input to one singular root question, rather a broad spectrum of questions needs to be evaluated.
However what can be highlighted as one of the most burning questions is the seemingly coercive reciprocity between "authorship, authorisation and authority". The question what and who is validated as author, by whom and for what reason is one of the most crucial ones in my artistic practice. Here is a selection of these questions: I am authorised to become an author by the institution, which is funding me, in order to become an authority in the field. What is at stake in this reciprocity? What if I don't want to become an institutionally authorised authority? And who authorises whom?
In a doctoral seminar during the first year of my PhD studies my colleagues and I had been asked: "Which material do you access for your research? What or who do you consult? And where do you find things?" In a slightly buccaneering way one of my colleagues responded: "In a phone call with my mum". It made us burst with laughter, because of the obvious discrepancy between formalised and established academic knowledge formation versus informal and unpredictable learning methods rooted in friends, allies and family.
Shortly after this episode - during the "Critical Practice" conference held at Valand Academy to mark the 150 years anniversary of art education in Gothenburg - the keynote speaker referenced in his contribution exclusively well-known and acknowledged white Western male authors, artists and theorists.
These two poles, represented by the informal knowledge stock of "my mum" and the institutionally authorised canon of in many ways patriarchal, white Western academia, constitutes the field of tension I am exploring.
As an academic you can hardly afford to avoid the latter approach - or at least bits of it. It can be described in mere practical terms like this: You first map the academic field, you demonstrate that you are knowledgeable about the established authorities in the discipline and then you craft your contribution in relation to them. You inherit and reproduce this tradition, you reference, you cite in order to be taken seriously or in Sara Ahmed's words "you cite yourself into an academic existence". [1] Citing is according to Ahmed "a rather successful reproductive technology, a way of reproducing the world around certain bodies."[2] [2]
In order to make your point, you need to start from within the established canon. This established canon is legitimised by academic institutions. My colleague and friend Andrea Francke, who started a PhD in art history at a UK based University, had been advised by her supervisors to omit a major part of her references and replace them with sources from recognised “high-profile” journals published by high-ranking universities in order to guarantee academic rigour and not corrupt the validity of her own writing. The consequences of this cycle is widely known, a canon is created which excludes the voices which are not institutionally legitimised.
It is a laborious, longterm project to counterbalance and open up this self-replicating, often patriarchal knowledge hegemony. The mechanism is simple and tempting. You put yourself in relation to and into proximity to validated voices, hoping that your own writing gets similar mainstay recognition. In the published interview "Rethinking where the thinking happens", which I conducted with Sarah Kember in public, she calls this a "boys' citation club". Consequently she started a new experimental academic press at Goldsmiths College in London, which tries to address and fix these issues as its declared mission. [3]
These hegemonic and exclusionary practices dominating the academic world, have been decried often but also empirically tested and found confirmed. In a recent study called "Publication, Power, Patronage", for instance, Chad Wellmon and Andrew Piper reveal the inequalities of scholarly publishing in terms of institutional diversity and gender equality. Conducting quantitative analysis, they studied five leading US-based humanities journals between 1970 and 2015. They found out, that gender equality had only slightly improved during this great time span (42% of articles published by female authors in comparison to xx before 1970). However, shockingly the concentration of power in the hands of prestige universities had even increased: authors with PhDs from just two elite universities alone, Yale and Harvard, accounted for twenty percent of all articles published in the studied journals.[4]
It is important to understand that university reformers – from the eighteenth up to the twenty-first century – have celebrated the act of publication as a measure to correct bulging concentrations of power and unsustainable systems of patronage that were prevailing in the early modern university. They simply saw publication as an efficient vehicle to bring more transparency and objectivity into systems and networks of power patronage based on familial status, inheritance or personal connections.[5] "In the light of being published, the value of a scholar’s work was visible to all because it was subject to more public and, therefore, so went the reasoning, more rational standards. Published writing could be accounted for, whereas charismatic teaching or speaking was more difficult to evaluate and compare."[4] Published texts, according to Simon Shaffer and Steve Shapin, constituted “a virtual witness that was agreed to be reliable”[6] They go on: "The authority of printed writing lay in its capacity to circulate more freely, unencumbered by the idiosyncrasies of the local and peculiar."
I will discuss the complexities of this shift from the local, peculiar, subjective and elitist knowledge standards to rational, objective and democratic knowledge availability and benchmarking, including the audit culture coming with it further down in the chapter about "Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?". There I will also analyse a most interesting development, namely that a dilemma arises when charismatic teaching is institutionally less valued than authoring texts. But for now it is important to register, that while historically publishing was first welcomed as a measure to create more public accountability and to contest the power imbalance within networks of patronage, the current systems of production, circulation and consumption of scholarly publishing in Europe and North America seem not to have achieved this goal – at least in the humanities in the US as the study and the above referenced keynote demonstrate.
Perspectives and Framing under the disguise of neutrality
In the following I will reflect on two practice examples, which try to tackle the hegemonic patriarchal self-replicating system described. They are my experiment of setting up the "Library of Inclusions and Omissions" (LIO), a reference library affiliated with Valand Academy which collects material that is being left out from institutional knowledge. And, second, a policy experiment conducted by a group of staff and students at the École de Récherche Graphique in Brussels.
"Library of Inclusions and Omissions"
The LIO is an inquiry into the politics of access, cataloguing practices, and standardisation. It is a practice-based long-term project initiated through an open call and the operation of temporary reading rooms. The growing stock of books of the library is curated by the community using it. It brings together forgotten histories, intersectional practices, material that is still missing in established libraries and databases, does not conform with the canon of Western, white, patriarchal academia, main-stream publishing, or finds itself marginalised for other reasons. This project is an attempt to find out in which way such a resource is fundamentally different to institutional libraries. Can it turn a library from being a repository of knowledge into spaces of social and intellectual encounter? (Samek 2003, Springer 2015). Can such a library even help building a community or connect different communities? Yes it can!
Traditionally it is the acquisition librarian’s task, informed through library newsletters and other professional library sources to decide what is been purchased to go onto the library shelves. This powerful job involves to ascertain and decide which narratives enter the library and how they are catalogued and classified. In the last decade - related to the merger of art academies into large universities - we observe the outsourcing of library services to large distributors selling libraries bundled subscription packages. According to the Fine Art Head librarian at Central Saint Martins, the University of the Arts' London subscription package contains all exhibition catalogues of major international museums, such as MoMA New York and Tate London. These subscription packages tend to absorb most of the budget leaving only marginal funds for bespoke and contextual teaching or research material, that goes beyond mainstream art literature covering exhibitions.
In a similar vein the formerly decentralised cataloguing units at CSM have been moved from the campus libraries to a centralised data hub, which by policy excludes any format not conforming with commercial publishing formats. Even when produced in-house, self-published material by students or material resulting from teaching projects can not enter the library as valuable and highly contextual references within the art college. This kind of exclusion is not so much created by political censorship or ignorance. It rather stems from an institutional drive to centralise and streamline procedures and infrastructures.
The curatorial concept of the LIO, by contrast, builds on the info shops or community archives that arose in the 70s and 80s in the UK as part of self-organised social movements. These collectively run libraries were not affiliated to institutions, for example councils, and they were catering explicitly for the information, social and cultural needs of their users (Atton 1999). This community library movement seems to be revived in recent years, as austerity kicked in in the UK. Confronted with public library closures throughout the country, communities self-organise and create vivid, experimental and independent community libraries. Quite closely related, the LIO's curatorial strategy is open and focused at the same time. Open to anyone, who is interested to contribute. Focused, because it is theme-based — asking for forgotten histories, intersectional practices, for feminist and de-colonial knowledge.
A personal letter, which I circulated in form of printed posters in three languages (Arabic, Swedish and English) as invitation to contribute to the LIO has not triggered many contributions from Gothenburg and its suburbs. The posters had been put up in public spaces, schools and universities, museums, independent cultural spaces and community centres in order to reach a maximally diverse public in terms of age, gender, ethnic background and class. But the hope to connect different communities via a call to submission for LIO has not been fulfilled.
By stark contrast, the printed posters and their online versions, circulated in my own immediate environment at Valand Academy triggered much interest and contributions. That means to me that the context of the Art Academy was critical as a vehicle for bonding trust as well as a natural habitat of shared interests. People who already knew me or knew about me, because I was institutionally affiliated, contributed to LIO. And although I was clear to contributors that this is not meant to be an institutionally affiliated library, it seemed that my links to the institution, such as being a doctoral student gave me some degree of respect or authority, which people felt they could trust and rely on. A big number of contributions also arrived from people who already knew my involvement with AND Publishing and The Piracy Project, which apparently gave me some sort of recognition or legitimisation or just made people curious to be part of LIO.
Very different from institutional libraries, the books contributed to LIO map and share the struggles, discoveries, desires, concerns and strategies of their contributors. This collection does not claim to provide "neutral" knowledge, the founding assumption of institutional libraries. Quite the opposite: LIO provides personal and subjective narratives. As such it is an attempt to deconstruct the assumption of neutrality and objectivity underlying "any grand narrative of modernity". According to Gayatri Spivak narrative is an important tool to ... do Wha`? Deconstruction is a practice that insistently critiques the grand narratives of modernity, such as scientific rationality, progress, or emancipation of humanity (Spivak 1990, 17–18) and reminds us again and again that “when a narrative is constructed, something is left out” (18).
The function of the catalogue is in the case of LIO not merely a technical act of organisation, it is also an act of telling. As in “telling, there is a desire — a desire to speak, a desire to share, to articulate an experience to an/other (Roysdon, 2009).” The LIO's catalogue makes transparent the range of subjectivities and perspectives, rather than relying on perceptions of neutrality, as discussed in the chapter "Libraries as a space of dissemination – Questions of access and organisation, classification and validation" above. Instead of using the 'controlled vocabulary' and classification terms of standardised library practice, LIO´s cataloguing focuses on advocacy and the agency of the books on their readers. LIO asks contributors for a short written rationale, why this book is important to them and why they want to share it with others. Through this the emphasis shifts from trying to frame the actual content of the book in an arguably objective manner towards describing the readers' personal making of meaning. The short statements are printed on index cards, which accompany each book and serve as an entry point and framing device for the library users. This subjective approach can be understood as an experiment to connect people through their readings, discoveries, desires, struggles and hopes.
Jyoti, Mick: Please read this draft text about classification.[7] I don't know, whether I should go into such detail and history of classification. It seems necessary in order to understand the point?
– talk about cataloguing workshops, at Leeds, Kunstverein Munich, Grand Union Birmingham.
– accountability for the daily habits (Bateson, Spivak), situatedness (Haraway), power relations. Imagining (Spivak)
Performative Propositions: Policy Document at ERG
In a similar attempt, in early 2018, a group of students and staff at École de Récherche Graphique in Brussels circulated a policy document "Proposals for amendment to be made regarding the study rules".[7] Article 2 in this document refers to library policies:
- "When the author identifies himself as the cis-type, heterosexual and white man, the books will be moved within the archives to recall, on the one hand, that this is one point of view among others. On the other hand, that the latter is hegemonic. A warning page will have to be included in each book when the readers will wish to consult the said works. Strict quotas will be put in place regarding the selection of the books represented. Attention will be paid to both subjects, the writing context and the authors." The topics under quota to be represented list: gender issues, queer issues, feminism, afro-feminism, trans-feminism, xeno-feminism, intersectional feminism, ecofeminism, eco-sexualite, LGBT, LGBTQQ I2SPAA+."
This policy document, sounding radical and almost utopian in its dramatic propositions, makes us pay attention to the fact, that authors who became part of the published canon speak from particular vantage points. The differences of authorial perspective need to be acknowledged and not swept under the carpet of universality and neutrality.
In an even bolder step article 3 in the same document proposes therefore to relate the payment of tuition fees to privilege. For this, a catalogue of ten criteria is drawn up: male, heterosexual, cis-gender, white, standard body, valid (valide), well-read, middle-class and bourgeois, carnivorous, human. If a student's profile, for instance, ticks three out of ten boxes (3/10), this coefficient will be applied in two ways: The percentage - in the example 30 percent - is added to tuition fees and other expenses, such as prices at the coffee machine, for photocopies and other materials. But the percentage will also be deducted as "penalty" from achieved points in academic evaluation and jury assessments. Apparently the policies described are so far only proposed, as its implementation in reality would amount to negative discrimination which is illegal in most European countries.
However such propositions can be performative: When I travelled to Brussels, visiting ERG in summer 2018, to talk to the document's authors, they explained – not without blurting out a giggle – how much this proposition already had stirred up day-to-day assumptions on privileges and social background at their art school. The document was pasted on the walls of the art school, as well as emailed to staff members and students. Taking in the suggested rules appealed to any staff member to consider, name, acknowledge and eventually unlearn their own privileges, I was told.
[link this to Spivak discussion of unlearning privilege? I need more time for this thought.]
[Spivak "unlearning privilege", "habits"; Krauss, "unlearning exercises", "privileges of a group in power". Krauss: If we understand unlearning one’s privilege as questioning and reworking one’s assumptions, prejudices, and histories, this includes as well “unlearning one’s privileged discourse” (Spivak 1990, 57).]
"What is crucial in habit formation for Spivak, is exactly what is missing in it. “A habit does not question. Habits lack the critical capacity to interrogate themselves”.(Spivak 2012, 8] In this context, critical writer Annette Krauss correctly analyses, that what is crucial in habit formation for Spivak, is exactly what is missing in it. “A habit does not question. Habits lack the critical capacity to interrogate themselves”, Spivak writes (Spivak 2012, 8), drawing on Gramsci who is interested in the prospect of democratic education and the possibilities of developing “new habits” (Gramsci 1971, 298). According to Gramsci, a democratic education necessarily demands that “the premises of an argument must indeed be ‘rediscoverable’, ‘re-examinable’, by the man of the masses as he is educated to be a citizen” (Gramsci 2000, 318).
However, Spivak claims that it is not enough that an argument’s premises are re-examined, which is a common scientific and academic exercise. Spivak suggests that philosophical – I add rational – argumentation is powerless when it comes to intervening in thinking and doing habits. She demands further effort within the “training of the imagination” that in the best case entails a certain “aesthetic” that “short-circuits the task of shaking up this habit of not examining them [the premises]” (Spivak 2012, 6), Krauss.]
In my view the proposed intervention to reformulate the study rules at ERG, can be described as such a "aesthetic short-circuit". Because even if it is apparent, that its implementation is not possible due to legal limits, the mere circulation of the document was performative in questioning the long-established habit framework of the institution and its members and this alone is able to adjust the normalised positions of authority in Western education.
Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy? (Collective Organising: Who authorises whom?)
"How is knowledge transmitted and validated? * What is the power of citation practices? * When do we learn? What kind of resources are we accessing to learn? * How can we broaden our understanding of feminist and non-Eurocentric knowledge? How can we understand justice, equality and diversity that is not blind to difference such as gender, sexual orientation, race, class and dis/ability? * Can management be thought in terms of care rather than administration? And what about the range of knowledge, that is not institutionally legitimised?"
In order to explore these questions, a work group at Valand Academy in Gothenburg was formed in 2015, in reaction and responding to the problematic keynote contribution, encapsulating a Western, white and male mantra at the aforementioned conference. The work group was set up by the desire to articulate and create space for a queer and feminist perspective on learning and teaching inside and outside of Valand Academy. And the aim was set to organise a conference, which fundamentally rethinks how knowledge can be formed from a feminist, queer and de-colonial perspective.
All students and staff at Valand Academy were invited to join this open work group. Over the past year we held lunchtime meetings, had dinners at homes, met in bars or communicated over Skype. We met in our studios and offices, went for walks and field trips, held daylong sessions and invited guests to brainstorm with and to learn from. We read texts, shared experiences, raised doubts and concerns. In a nutshell, we just followed our desires not to struggle forward and chew on these questions as individuals. Rather we got together to acknowledge the importance of queer and feminist issues in education as a group.
Our work can be described in two phases. The first six months we held bi-weekly lunchtime meetings in order to meet and share our teaching experiences, conflicts with students or management, as well as to read and discuss texts. What is more, we started an online text archive, where a wide range of material was uploaded from different historical periods, territories, backgrounds – material generated inside and outside of academia. These meetings offered also a space to share information about what happened under the surface of the institution, things that were not officially circulated but crucial for understanding the social fabric of the people working together at Valand Academy.
The second phase was more focused on planning and organising a "conference" that practically tests and redefines the format and style of coming together to create and transmit knowledge. The quotation marks around the term conference already give a hint on how we attempted to rethink the traditional terms and related roles, functions and hierarchies at the Valand Academy by crucially redefining the nomenclature.[8] The term conference, for example, was replaced by the word mobilisation, because we aimed at a more practical, dynamic, activist and generative outcome, rather than just conducting a static sharing of papers exercise.
It took us a while to implement this shift in terminology into common use at Valand Academy. Getting initial traction within the working group, then the administration and then the lecturer's and student's public, the new nomenclature eventually turned into daily use across the organisation. At this point, working towards a defined goal – the mobilisation was conceived to mark the closing of Valand Academy's 150th anniversary events – the group had shrunk to only six people, consisting of students, teachers and one administrator. [9]
The analysis of the mobilisation experiment is best structured and discussed in three aspects. A first angle is that the mobilisation experimented with non-normative teaching and conference formats. It tested new roles, language, non-normative uses of building and classrooms, as well as non-normative timing, budgeting, catering and hosting of participants. Secondly I will discuss the experimental, but often neglected and "un-authored" practice of organising and care for such an event. Thirdly I will discuss the complexities and challenges of collectivity within in the working group, who, when put under considerable pressure towards the end, did not always manage to apply the same principles, we set out for the mobilisation, to the actual working processes within the group.
Non-normative Approaches
For example roles: We fundamentally defined three roles. An "instigator" is a person or group invited to prepare a contribution that will activate each of the mobilisation´s forums and their topics. An "invited participant" is a practitioner and theoretician invited to attend and participate in the mobilisation, because he or she were inspiring to us, had no particular role or task but contributed through their knowledge and experience informally. And thirdly, "participants" are mobilisation attendees helping to work through the event´s questions – active and vocal, or active and quiet.
For example language: We face a constant standoff at Valand Academy in that some staff members call the use of English, and not Swedish, in our daily work "a colonial project". The reluctance to speak English might be a gesture directed towards the institution´s leadership, which is to a great part native English speaking. But it is also routed of course in a lack of confidence to discuss and debate complex issues in a foreign language. The language issue got pretty polarised at times. It turned more into a passive-aggressive stalemate rather than a playful bilingual communication practice. To take into account this dilemma and to find a way out during the mobilisation – which had many international participants from eight European countries – we commissioned two live translators, who were taking notes and translated and wrote them down in real time into an online writing pad projected into the room. Attendee Zarah Bayrati, who spoke in Forum 2 "What is the thing about diversity?", even demonstrated how the sometimes oppressive dynamics connected to language can be dissolved by holding her class switching between Swedish, English and Farsi.
For example the seminar room: When the roles of speakers change, the traditional furniture set up and layout of standard seminar rooms or lecture halls don't work anymore. Therefore we invited queer architect Katarina Bonnevier for a workshop to investigate the existing rooms at the Academy and how they could be queered and opened up for uses, that go beyond round table discussions (glasshouse), frontal lectures (aula) or presentations (screen). Rachel Barron, a just graduated MA student developed a decoration with translucent fabric, which brought colour into the main assembly room, the “glasshouse”, and divided the room into several visually and spatially connected layers. For our seven Forums, we used the staircase in the main building for the “Sextalks MTG”, the aula for a play reading of “Strike while the iron is hot” on the stage and between the rows of chairs in the audience, the four kitchens for “When do we learn? Collectively preparing and eating food”, the glasshouse for “How do we start?”, “What is this thing about diversity?”, “Rethinking where the thinking happens” and the closing session “Where to go from here?”. With Forum 4, “When do we learn?”, a sleep-over in the glasshouse, we experimented with informal learning outside scheduled structures. See the full programme here [8].
"The Un-authored" Practices of Organising and Caring
Because we rethought all these processes, formats and interactions in a fundamental way, we had to invent or understand and tweak the existing procedures prescribed by the university procurement. This would not have been possible without the inventive support of the management and the administration of the academy becoming part of this. Think of the aforementioned sleep over in the main assembly room. Staying overnight in the academy building is officially not permitted. Only through negotiations and with the creative support of the acting Prefect the sleep over could become part of the programme as Forum 6: "When do we learn? Non-normative uses of the seminar room".[10] In the following I will give selected examples of how intricate negotiations and dealings with the Academy personnel were, whose day-to-day job was to follow, interpret and execute the rules and regulations.
For example catering Gothenburg University has, for example, a limited list of approved caterers for conferences or symposia. Any attempt to order food from less established, experimental or informal food projects are not envisaged or permitted. Only by the inventive work of our administrators, and the trick to declare it to be to a conceptual part of the mobilisation, we were able to order food from the local women's food collective Hoppet to prepare food for the first dinner of the mobilisation on Wednesday 12 October 2016. Hoppet (Hoppet för kropp och själ - The Hope for Body and Soul) is an Arabic, Iraqi, Kurdish and Persian women collective based in Gothenburg’s suburb Hammarkullen. Hoppet started a catering business to gain financial independence from husbands, to support women in the community and to donate money to kids with blood diseases in Iraq. By ordering food from Hoppet we want to both support the women’s collective fight for a safe space and promote care and hospitality through the food we were eating together. [11]
For example hosting In a similar manner we had to come up with ideas how to deal with the restrictive university policies regarding the hosting of guests. Only a small exclusive list of big and anonymous hotels in Gothenburg have accreditation with the university. In an effort to offer more friendly accommodation and create more inspiring social encounters, we found for most of the mobilisation´s participants a spare room, bed or sofa in offered by colleagues or friends in their Gothenburg homes. This hospitality not only allowed many students and freelancers living and working on small budgets to join the mobilisation. It also made the mobilisation a distributed effort of solidarity and responsibility across the art school.
Administrators as co-authors "This variety of ‘doing things differently’ from standard university procedures, generated a lot of work, stress and frustration for us. It was difficult to receive consistent information on what could and could not be done within the remit of the various academic policies. The bits of information provided were fairly vague, leaving us in a state of uncertainty and constant guessing and relying on hearsay, which created tension within the group as well as between us and the art school. In order to deal with policies in a creative and productive way one must know them well and fully, whereas we were always hoping, but never really knowing. While being aware of some administrators’ support, we found ourselves also affected by anxiety that “this will not be possible” as the inflexibility of the administrative apparatus will not allow it to happen. [12] Current critiques of administration refer to the administration of the body and the way bureaucracy is used to control the flows of our everyday life: "From passport control to binary gender categories on job application forms, administration gently pushes us into ideologically assigned roles and positions and then traps us there."[13] According to queer activist and legal scholar Dean Spade "policy and administrative systems are the invisible disciplinary forces that generate our experiences as subjects." [14] Andrea Francke and Ross Jardine argue in their paper "Bureaucracy's Labour" that current critiques of administration are conceived from the angle of the administered body and ask "But what of the administrator?" They argue that in order “to be deemed successful in their task the administrator must adhere to a range of standards and style guides that masks their identity with that of the institution through policies of best practice and standardisation, [...] actions become attached to roles instead to individuals [...] and therefore the administrator's position as subject is being erased." [13] But exactly because administrators are the anonymous subjects, that generate and enforce those systems, they are vital for enacting political transformation, as Francke and Jardine argue. I agree with this argument, as it was the very reason for the underlying tension of collaborating with individual administrators, being governed and governing at the same time and with regards to the mobilisation, I wished we had worked even more closely with the administrators and made them even more co-authors and allies in the process.
Collectivity: Desires and Complications
This is a quote from a collectively authored reflection on the working process of the group organising the mobilisation: "Trust, care and confidences were broken. Feelings of unworthiness surfaced and created fractions. Collective and collaborative practice involves negotiation and communication. A lot of focus was on creating a transparent structure with regards to the mobilisation economy, a clear glossary with intentions etc. However we would have benefitted from a clear audit of ourselves, our ability to commit, our expectations and our insecurities. Easier to say with hindsight." [15] The extract summarises the contestations and conflicts within the working group, once the mobilisation date came closer and the pressure had risen. We only understood after the event, that while we invested so much time and effort to define and achieve transparency, roles and care in relation to the event, we fell short of achieving this sufficiently within the group. In "Do the right thing - a manual" Johanna Gustavsson and Lisa Nyberg report how important accountability and transparency is for working collectively. They list of priorities goes like this: "(1) Talk openly about money. (2) Talk openly about commitment and time. (3) Make room for economy and time planning already from the start. Ask each other how much time you are able to, and want to invest in the joint project. This way the collaboration can function even though one person invests 10% and the others 100%. It is important to be prepared that someone might be less involved in periods, so it’s good to have those discussions early on."[16]
We learned early on from the collective reading of Jo Freeman’s “The Tyranny of Structurelessness” that we need transparency on decisions we take.[17] Hence it became a guiding principle in our communication with each other to take notes in every working group meeting, which were uploaded to a shared online “black board” information box. Still our collective summary says, that "our care for the participants pre-empted the care for the working group”, and that in the hot phase approaching the event "we did not initiate moments of rest, time to check in with each other. This created problems personally and interpersonally." [15] It was the imbalance of priorities within the group and commitment to other projects, which caused imbalance and frustration overall. We had read together the experiences in the MFK manual about being clear and outspoken on priorities and availability, but we did not strictly check in on this during the process. The consequence was that those regularly attending the decision-making meetings inevitably developed more responsibility and therefore group and project power than others, who came only sporadically. That was not the flat structure we imagined and led to frustrations on all sides – with some complaining about the lack of commitment and others about being silenced. Due to immense pressure to deliver, this imbalance was not addressed properly, as we just wanted to get on. Another structural problem was, that I personally could afford focusing on planning the event and editing the workbook, because it was part of my (paid) research. Other group members faced a growing workload having to juggle teaching, their studies as well as day jobs with the organising work. Despite being aware of my privilege, I assumed similar commitment from all others. I was frustrated, when things did not move forward on project ends others had taken responsibility for.
"How to practice care throughout the process of organizing a feminist gathering: care for the investment in the ideas themselves, for the participants, for the host institution, for each other in the organizing group and self care?" [15]
Questions of economy and efficiency and unmeasurable labour
We also observed, that within the existing institutional setting our effort to do things differently and to find an alternative to the imposed order was positively acknowledged and to a certain degree enthusiastically welcomed by Valand Academy´s leadership. But it caused also friction with and drew critique by the upper echelons, because of the apparent extra labour, effort and time our project created for administrators – and therefore costs.
The question of the right economical balance became obvious, when our extensive creative work of detailed organising and care turned into self-exploitation and for some even into states of burn-out.[18] The working group had not been given extra hours for this work and when we, towards the end of the process, tentatively asked to be (partially) paid the reply was blunt: We had a distinct budget and we should work with this budget, we had been told. While this argument is reasonable it results in a dilemma: people going back to a 'working to rule' practice within the established standard procedures. They do this as acts of self-care, because they cannot carry the extra work, which they are committed to that supersedes the efficiency rules of the institution. Efficiency is a measurable concept – quantitatively determined by the ratio of useful output to total input.
My argument here goes like this: These partly invisible practices of care are not related to regimes of authorship and therefore not distinctly measurable. They are invisible in the current regime of authorship and ownership. They constitute affective labour, which is sometimes valued and recognised by the direct recipients and beneficiaries, however the current systems of evaluation fall short to acknowledge them formally. They are seen as the “fuzzy extra”, which is nice to have, but not seen as fundamentally necessary to keep the machine going. They are not connected to authorship and therefore not recognised "as work". [19]
[Talk about "Invisible labour, Wages for Housework, Silvia Federici etc...."]
[Talk about unauthored admin documents: Lisa Gitelman: Paper Knowledge]
The Piracy Project
The Piracy Project (TPP), is a collaboration with artist Andrea Francke. It deals with questions of authorship, authorisation and authority in a hands-on way. By prompting people to "pirate" a book that is important to them – that is to make copies and manually reproduce books – The Piracy Project challenges a traditional understanding of books as finite resources and stable and authoritative objects. Through the unauthorised interventions and alterations of the books' textual and visual content, TPP transgresses the construction of authorship, as we commonly understand it and deals with the complexities of authorisation on many different levels, as I will explain in the following.
These conceptualisations were not clear-cut at the beginning of TPP. The project's richness, energies and complexities unfolded during the collaborative practice as well as through the interaction with contributors and institutions, which hosted TPP and the related workshops, lectures and debates over the span of five years. There was not a clear-cut question triggering TPP at the beginning. It was rather a political situation and the desire to organise against it, as well as the puzzling discovery of specific book piracy cases in Peru, where pirates had started to anonymously alter and amend the plot of some fiction books.
The Piracy Project was initiated in 2010. Its immediate trigger was the attempt to fight the closure of the library at Byam Shaw School of Art in London. In a joint effort students and staff turned Byam Shaw’s art college library, supported by its acting principal, into a self-governed library that remained public – and thus intellectually and socially generative. As I explain in the text "What matter who's speaking" this was not without antagonism, because right at that time, the British Prime Minister of the day, David Cameron, launched his perfidious ‘The Big Society’ concept, which proposed that members of the community should volunteer at public institutions, such as local libraries, which were deemed to be closed due to government cuts. They were also voices saying that, rather than turning this into a project, time and energies should be invested into campaigning to keep the library as an institutional resource. [Figures of library cuts in UK?] However, shifting an institutionally run library to one organised by students and staff, opened up many possibilities to experiment and rethink what a library could be. By taking collective ownership over the art school library and its books, the space opened up from being a resource, that was controlled and validated by institutional policies – critically on the question of its offering on the shelves – to a self-steering knowledge assemblage, able to include potentially obscure, self-published, not institutionally validated materials.
Queering the authority of the printed book
The Piracy Project shares similar concerns with practices of radical online libraries such as aaaarg.fail or Memory of the World (discussed in the above chapter "Libraries as a space of dissemination – Questions of access and organisation, classification and validation"), which are setting up distribution platforms in order to fight enclosures by commercial monopolies. However TPP operates differently. It asks people to make printed copies of books, and while doing that, rethink, how they relate to the authored and already authorised material they are pirating. As such it is a material practice as well as a conceptual and political practice. The call, published internationally through an art-agenda newsletter and locally through posters states: "The Piracy Project is not about stealing or forgery. It is about creating a platform to innovatively explore the spectrum of copying / re-editing / translating / paraphrasing / imitating / re-organising / manipulating of already existing works.[20]
These manipulations could be described as queering of the authority of the printed book, as we know it. Since the introduction of the industrial printing press we tend to simply assume, that one copy of a book we are reading to be identical to the other copies of the same title circulating. The co-authored text "The Impermanent Book" published in Rhizome magazine [9] discusses the instability of the book, especially since the commercial availability of print-on-demand services. In the chapter "The Piracy Project" of the article "What Matter who's speaking", I reflect on the anxieties the invention of the Xerox photocopy machine in the 60s injected into mainstream publishing. This becomes clearer, when we consider that digital print technologies such as print-on-demand and desktop publishing allow for a constant re-printing and re-editing of existing files. The advent and widespread accessibility of the photocopy machine in the late 1960s in the US, for example, allowed the reader to photocopy books and collate selected chapters, pages or images in new and customised compilations.[21] These new reproduction technologies undermine to an extent the concept of the printed book as a stable and authoritative work, which had prevailed since the mass production of books on industrial printing presses came into being some 400 years ago. History of information scholar Eva Hemmungs-Wirtén describes in what way the general availability of the photocopier has been perceived as a threat to the authority of the text and cites Marshall McLuhan’s address at the Vision 65 congress in 1965: 'Xerography is bringing a reign of terror into the world of publishing because it means that every reader can become both author and publisher. [….] Authorship and readership alike can become production-oriented under xerography. Anyone can take a book apart, insert parts of other books and other materials of his own interest, and make his own book in a relatively fast time. Any teacher can take any ten textbooks on any subject and custom-make a different one by simply xeroxing a chapter from this one and from that one.’[22]
The queering of the authorial voice
Beside these material aspects, some contributions to The Piracy Project undermine the authority of the authorial voice. See for example the case of the pirated version of "No se lo diga a nadie" (Don't tell anyone), where the pirate secretly and anonymously added two extra chapters to a famous auto-biographical novel by Peruvian journalist and TV presenter Jaime Baily. [reference to catalogue entry] Somebody had borrowed the official author’s voice and sneaked in two fictionalised extra chapters about the author’s life. (This and several other cases are in more detail discussed in the texts "What matter who is speaking"(Whose book is it anyway),"The Piracy Project" (Archives of the commons II) "The Impermanent Book" (Rhizome).
The assumed authority of the author is for example turned inside out in the Piracy Project index catalog, which is written in collaboration with writer John Moseley, which is searchable online. Here the pirate is listed as author; the original author as source material.See online catalogue Could such re-editing practices be understood as expanded reference practice, such as quotation, citation, homage? In order to explore the different relationalities we developed over the course of the project a growing list of terms, such as borrowing, poaching, plagiarising, pirating, stealing, gleaning, referencing, leaking, copying, imitating, adapting, faking, paraphrasing, quoting, reproducing, using, counterfeiting, repeating, cloning, translating? All verbs (active words) that describe the range of relationships we build to somebody else's work. This list is also the title of a publication, the TPP edited and published in 2014 exploring each of these terms from different perspectives and fields of knowledge.[23]
Who has the right to be an author, copyright and IP
None of the cases contributed to TPP asked for authorisation from the author or publisher and we sometimes describe them as "unsolicited collaborations". The term collaboration refers to a relational activity and re-imagines authorship not as proprietary and stable, but as a dialogical and generative process – very much in the view framed by feminist legal scholar Carys Craig. She claims that ‘authorship is not originative but participative; it is not internal but interactive; it is not independent but interdependent. In short, a dialogic account of authorship is equipped to appreciate the derivative, collaborative, and communicative nature of authorial activity in a way that the Romantic (individual genius) account never can.’ [24] But there are limits to this dialogical approach, and Craig as a legal scholar refers to the complexities of intellectual property law. The law limits intertextual, relational practices , which I discuss in "What matter who's speaking". And the law also aims to protect against predatory practices. The debate on the complexities of this binary conducted between legal scholars, Open Culture activists is fierce and ongoing and can not be discussed here in detail.
To define authorial originality in a derivative work, for example, has been the task of many court cases. And because copyright is case law, the verdicts are informed by many different factors. So this messiness and blurriness of the legal framework can create a climate of anxiety and subsequently self-censorship. You don’t do stuff, because you don’t know whether it might be interpreted as copyright infringement. This self-limiting instinct is documented well in "Copyright, Permissions, and Fair Use among Visual Artists and the Academic and Museum Visual Arts Communities: An Issues Report", commissioned by the College Art Association in USA in 2014 [25], which I discuss in detail in the text "What matter who's speaking".
To follow up on this really crucial point, we we organised a performative debate entitled "A Day at the Courtroom". It has been hosted by The Showroom in London during our one-year residency at the art space in 2013. For the debate we invited three critical copyright lawyers from different cultural and legal backgrounds to assess selected cases of TPP collection items in the eyes of the law. The advising scholars and lawyers were Lionel Bently (Professor of Intellectual Property at the University of Cambridge), Sergio Muñoz Sarmiento (Art and Law, New York), Prodromos Tsiavos (Head of Digital Development at the Onassis Cultural Centre Athens, at the time Legal Project Lead for Creative Commons, England, Wales and Greece). We were curious about this debate, in which each lawyer argued their legal perspective after which it was on the audience to speak the verdict. For the debate, we also replaced the “infringing” – “non infringing” binary with a colour scale from red (for illegal) to blue (for legal) and, again the audience was asked to pick the right spot and legal status of each discussed case.
The lawyers demonstrated, that for example one selected case would be regarded as Fair Use exception in Europe, but not in the United States. Lot’s of effort went into the discussion how “originality” is defined and what the criteria are for being granted the status of an “author”. In the case of "Suitcase Body is missing woman", one of the total of ten cases assessed in the debate, the lawyers raised the question, whether a person untrained in art could claim original artistic expression for their work. Another case, which discussed a clearly commercially motivated predatory publishing practice, by pulling content from a knowledge commons such as Wikipedia, was deemed legal. See the published debate here.[26]
Such events help us to collectively unpack the contested complexities within intellectual property law. But they also helped us to grasp the extent to which these policy debates, as well as the sheer use of the term “intellectual property”, has become so ubiquitous that it pervades our thinking and working and not least our social relationships.
The social agency of piracy
The media and communication scholar Ramon Lobato asks, whether the language of piracy used by the critical intellectual property discourse ‘should be embraced, rejected, recuperated or re-articulated’? He contends, that reducing ‘piracy’ to a mere legal category – a question of conforming or nonconforming with the law – tends to neglect the generative force of piracy practices, which ‘create (their) own economies, exemplify wider changes in social structure, and bring into being tense and unusual relationships between consumers, cultural producers and governments.’ [27]
Gary Hall discusses in his book "Pirate Philosophy, For a digital Posthumanities" the genealogy of the word pirate: "When the word pirate first appeared in ancient Greek texts, it was closely related to the noun ‘peira’ which means trial or attempt.[28] ‘The ‘pirate’ would then be the one who ‘tests’, ‘puts to proof', ‘contends with’, and ‘makes an attempt’. Further etymological research shows that from the same word root stems p i ra : experience, practice [πείρα], p i rama : experiment [πείραμα], p i ragma: teasing [πείραγμα] and pir a zo : tease, give trouble [πειράζω]. [29] This ‘contending with’, ’making an attempt’ and ‘teasing’ is at the core of The Piracy Project’s practice."
The power of framing and context
This "teasing, making an attempt contending with" happens firstly by asking people to make specific contributions to the piracy project and its context (library closure). It also happens through our own research into cases of book piracy elsewhere, and the understanding of their strategies and approaches and the (political) motivations for these acts. In so far as they fall into the category of of civil disobedience, these acts ask for careful discussion and framing, as any framing process is also a powerful meaning-making tool.
In the TPP reading rooms, which are open to the public, the books on the shelf need to be able to communicate on their own. Therefore we wrote for each book of the collection a “library card”. It functions partly as an index catalogue (which is also available online). But it foremost describes the books’ genesis. The card names the original source, the material properties of the pirate copy, what strategy has been used, who is the pirate, how it got into the collection. All in all it functions as an entry point to the book. At New York Art Book Fair, a librarian from Pratt institute stepped by our reading room every single day, because she was so fixed on the questions the books raise in respect to normative cataloguing and bibliography standards. Take Jaime Bayli’s “No se diga a nadie” for example. Who would be named as author? How can you pay justice to the complexity of the more than one “authorships” in this work?
The problem discussed earlier is that standard modes of classification use a controlled vocabulary. The most widespread standard classification systems (Dewey, Library of Congress) claim to be universal and neutral, so that everything can find its place within its structure. However we know that the organisation and framing of knowledge is not neutral and informs to a large degree, whether material is been found and if and how it is being read. To cut deeper into the questions around framing cases in our collection, we organised a workshop during the two-month reading room opened at Grand Union in Birmingham (6 December 2013 – 8 February 2014). Archivist Karen Di Franco helped us to collectively develop an alternative vocabulary by thinking through how selected cases operate. A set of useful new terms came up: “Unauthorised”, “Impersonated”, “Hijacked”, “Invisible/Ghost”, “Altruistic”, “Esoteric”, “Accidental”, “Communal”. [30]
On another instance, when a TPP reading room opened at Kunstverein Munich (7 – 28 November 2014), we looked for classification criteria, how to spatially organise the books. Parallel to the reading room we ran a two-week workshop visiting independent publishers, bookshops, archives and a copy shop in Munich, which all operated off mainstream practices and found alternative ways of distribution.[31] Correspondingly we organised the books on display in the Piracy Project Reading Room according to their modes of distribution:
• White Market
• Grey Market
• Black Market
• Archive as Distribution
• Print on demand
The White Market for books encompasses all legal and authorised distribution through traditional channels. The books in this selection have been produced through publishing houses, have ISBN numbers and are produced in higher quantities that allow for commercial distribution.
The Grey Market for books includes publications produced in higher edition numbers than the one circulating through specific, non-official networks. We included fanzines and artists’ books that are sold only at specialized shops in this section.
The Black Market for books encompasses distribution through illegal and unauthorised commercial channels. The books in this section were purchased at pirate markets and copy shops.
Archive As Distribution are examples of pirated books that are produced for archival reasons. They are out of circulation and were sent to us in order to remain accessible. We also gather here books that are one–offs, produced specifically for the Piracy Collection in response to our open call.
Print On Demand points to a new type of market. It produces books with a professional finish and ISBN number in potentially unlimited quantities that can circulate in mainstream commercial distribution channels. A book, produced through lulu.com, for example, will be a one-off until a second copy is purchased. Only then the second copy will be printed and shipped. Distribution triggers production, it defines the market dynamically. It allows books to oscillate between grey and white market zones in a seamless way.
These experiments in organising the collection were interesting, because they show the power of naming and framing. Depending on organising criteria, the collection can be explored in many different ways. Because there are many questions to be asked we keep changing the classification criteria, when we display the collection in public. Each time the collection appears in a new light, holding different questions and answers depending on what aspect we focus on. Thus the catalogue itself turns into a meaning-making structure.
However over the years we got more and more hesitant towards invitations to exhibit The Piracy Project. The institutional framework of exhibitions turned the reading rooms, which were meant as a starting point for collaboration and exchange, more and more into static exhibits for demonstration purposes.
With hindsight I have to say that the most productive public iterations were long-term reading rooms, which allowed for a series of accompanying workshops, events and debates. And the most generative time the TPP experienced during the student-led occupation at the Byam Shaw library. See a detailed description of the consequences of this shift of context from the daily encounters at the Byam Shaw School of Art to “touring” the collection to different art venues, after the art college library was eventually shut down, in the published presentation held at the international seminar "Archives of the Commons II - the Anomic Archive”, organised by Red Conceptualismos del Sur and Museo Nacional Reina Sofia Madrid. [add link to text]
See a full list of lectures, workshops, debates and events here. [link]
Notes
- ↑ "Women too, people of colour too, might cite white men: to be you have to be in relation to white men (to twist a Fanonian point). Not to cite white men is not to exist; or at least not to exist within this or that field" Sara Ahmed, "White Men" [3]11.April 2014
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 Sara Ahmed, "Making Feminist points", [4], 13 September 2013
- ↑ For example one of the ideas during the planning period of the press was to introduce a female citation policy, that is a certain percentage of writings published references female authors, an idea which could legally not implemented as a policy, but is an underlying topic within the editorial board. Read the interview
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 Wellmon, Chad and Piper, Andrew "Publication, Power, Patronage: On Inequality and Academic Publishing" in Critical Inquiry, 21 July 2017,[accessed 30 July 2017].
- ↑ As Wellmon and Piper point out "universities were often closely associated with high status families that used their contacts with kings, princes, and government officials to exercise influence over appointments and advancements. Universities in Gießen, Marburg, and Tübingen remained under the influence of such familial networks well into the nineteenth century", passing on faculty chairs within familial or other personal networks.
- ↑ Steven Shapin and Simon Schaffer, "Leviathan and the Air-Pump: Hobbes, Boyle, and the Experimental Life"Princeton, N.J., 2011,p.60 (pp. 23–79)
- ↑ See proposed study rules [here]. École de Recherche Graphique, Brussles
- ↑ Download glossary here.
- ↑ Andreas Engman, Eva Weinmayr, Gabo Camnitzer, Kanchan Burathoki, Mary Coble and Rose Borthwick.
- ↑ We also discussed in a meeting with the prefect possible precedences, such as Serpentine Gallery Marathon in London in order to have arguments in the case the superordinate university procurement would ask questions.
- ↑ Read interview with Hajar Alsaidan, one of Hoppet’s founding sisters, about how Hoppet started, the foundations of the organisation and food, feminism, precarity and women’s liberation in Let's Mobilze: What is Feminist Pedagogy workbook [5]
- ↑ For example just three days before the event we received an email from an administrator stating that preparing food for 120 people in the academy building (iii) would breach Health and Safety regulations of the university. Two days later another administrator brought us – as a acknowledging and supportive gesture – a monstrous squash vegetable home-grown in her own garden to cook for the communal dinner.
- ↑ 13.0 13.1 Andrea Francke, Ross Jardine in "Bureaucracy’s Labour: The Administrator as Subject in 'Management', Parse issue 5
- ↑ Dean Spade, "Normal Life: Administrative Violence, Critical Trans Politics, and the Limits of Law", 2nd edition. Durham: Duke University Press Books. 2015.
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 In this text, written one year after the event, the working group reflected on the process, hopes, and results of the mobilisation by revisiting and commenting on the original text "Mapping the concepts and ways of working for Let's Mobilize." published in September 2016 in 'Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy workbook'. Download draft text.
- ↑ "MFK Manual", Johanna Gustavsson, Lisa Nyberg, Malmö Free University for Women, 2011
- ↑ Jo Freeman, „The Tyranny of Structurelessness, Why organisations need some structure to ensure they are democratic", 1972, http://struggle.ws/hist_texts/structurelessness.html.
- ↑ “I do always wonder how as hosts, undertaking so much care work and logistical preparations, we are able to engage with everyone and the discussions without burning out?” Frances Stacey, Collective Gallery Edinburgh, email 1.5.2017
- ↑ "First of all, I want to express my deep gratitude and joy for the Femped mobilization. Thank you for arranging this fantastic event! It was inviting, relaxed, intelligent, critical, playful, generous. It was also wonderful to meet all these people in this setting - I think it made everyone go off-guard. Even though the atmosphere was friendly and allowing, there was also room for criticality - especially during the Thursday session before lunch. That was very valuable! [...] If femped is to serve as a role model for the Academy - and in many regards it should - I cannot stress enough that the work required to arrange an event needs to be acknowledged by the institution as work. Anything else is unsustainable, unethical and excluding. To define what work is and how it is valued has occupied feminism for decades." Ann-Charlotte Glasberg Blomquist, Lecturer Valand Academy, email 15.11.2016
- ↑ https://www.art-agenda.com/shows/and-publishing-announces-the-piracy-lectures/
- ↑ It might be no coincidence that Roland Barthes’ seminal short essay 'Death of the Author’ is published in Aspen Magazine in 1967, the same time, when the Xerox photocopy machine have become widely used in libraries and offices. See Eva Hemmungs Wirtén "The Death of the Author and the Killing of Books: Assault by Machine", in "No Trespassing, Authorship, Intellectual Property Rights and the Boundaries of Globalization", pp.57-75, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2004
- ↑ Hemmungs-Wirten, Eva. "No Trespassing, Authorship, Intellectual Property Rights and the Boundaries of Globalization", Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2004 and Marshall McLuhan, ‘Address at Vision 65, New Challenges for Human Communications’, Southern Illinois University, 21-23 October 1965, in McLuhan, E. and Zingrone, F. (eds) 'Essential McLuhan', New York: BasicBooks, pp. 216, 1995.
- ↑ In an open-ended reader, published by AND publishing in 2014, each of these terms will be explored from different perspectives and fields of knowledge. "Borrowing, Poaching, Plagiarising, Pirating, Stealing, Gleaning, Referencing, Leaking, Copying, Imitating, Adapting, Faking, Paraphrasing, Quoting, Reproducing, Using, Counterfeiting, Repeating, Cloning, Translating" [6] is an open ended book, that develops as people buy shares in selected chapters exploring one of these terms. [Explain funding, production model]
- ↑ , p.246) Carys J. Craig, "Symposium: Reconstructing the Author-Self: Some Feminist Lessons for Copyright Law", American University Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law . 15, no. 2, 2007.
- ↑ Aufderheide, Patricia, Jaszi, Peter, Bello, Bryan. Milosevic, Tijana, Copyright, Permissions, and Fair Use among Visual Artists and the Academic and Museum Visual Arts Communities: An Issues Report (New York: College Art Association, 2014).
- ↑ See "A Day at the Courtroom", the published transcript of this debate in the reader "Borrowing, Poaching, Plagiarising, Pirating, Stealing, Gleaning, Referencing, Leaking, Copying, Imitating, Adapting, Faking, Paraphrasing, Quoting, Reproducing, Using, Counterfeiting, Repeating, Cloning, Translating", ed Andrea Francke & Eva Weinmayr, London: AND Publishing, pp.91-133, 2014. Download book
- ↑ Ramon Lobato, ‘The Paradoxes of Piracy’, in Lars Eckstein, Anja Schwarz (eds) Postcolonial Piracy: Media Distribution and Cultural Production in the Global South (London, New York: Bloomsbury, 2014) p.121,123.
- ↑ Daniel Heller-Roazen, The Enemy of All: Piracy and the Law of Nations, (New York: Zone Books, 2009) p.35.
- ↑ ‘Etymology of Pirate’, in English Words of (Unexpected) Greek Origin , 2 March 2012, <http://ewonago.wordpress.com/2009/02/18/etymology-of-pirate> [accessed 14 February 2018].
- ↑ 'Putting the Piracy Collection on the shelf' published in "Borrowing, Poaching, Plagiarising, Pirating, Stealing, Gleaning, Referencing, Leaking, Copying, Imitating, Adapting, Faking, Paraphrasing, Quoting, Reproducing, Using, Counterfeiting, Repeating, Cloning, Translating", ed Andrea Francke & Eva Weinmayr, London: AND Publishing, pp 77-90, 2014.
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; no text was provided for refs namedKunstverein Munich publication
Dissemination: The Piracy Project Reader is an open ended reader, which will develop as people buy shares in the book.....
Boxing and Unboxing
Analysis
Neither The Piracy Project, nor the Library of Omission, nor the boxing classes can thrive in the art world as collective projects. There agency is killed, the moment somebody claims authorship and ownership. Collectivity bashes against the demand for authorship.
method
Talk about the writing "about". Different experiments of co-authoring. Talk about the wiki as experiment.
to do
send authorship text to Nourbese Phillips.
bibliography references – (I'll do them at the very end)
Alperin, J.P., Muñoz Nieves, C., Schimanski, L., Fischman, G.E., Niles, M.T. & McKiernan, E.C. "How significant are the public dimensions of faculty work in review, promotion, and tenure documents?" Humanities Commons, 2018 [preprint]. download
Freeman, Jo, „The Tyranny of Structurelessness – Why organisations need some structure to ensure they are democratic", 1972, http://struggle.ws/hist_texts/structurelessness.html.
Genette, Gérard, "Paratexts, Thresholds of interpretation", Cambridge University Press, 1997
Ghandi, Leela, "The Common Cause – Postcolonial Ethics and the practice of democracy 1900-1955", Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2014.
Hall, Gary, “Digitize this Book, The Politics of New Media, or Why We Need Open Access Now”, Minnesota: Minnesota University Press, 2008.
Hayles, Katherine N. , "How We Think: Digital Media and Contemporary Technogenesis", Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2012.
Hemmungs-Wirten, Eva. "No Trespassing, Authorship, Intellectual Property Rights and the Boundaries of Globalization", Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2004.
Leigh Star, Susan
McLuhan Marshall, ‘Address at Vision 65, New Challenges for Human Communications’, Southern Illinois University, 21-23 October 1965, in McLuhan, E. and Zingrone, F. (eds) 'Essential McLuhan', New York: BasicBooks, pp. 208-221, 1995.
Olson, Hope A., “How we construct Subjects: Feminist Analysis”, in Library Trends, Johns Hopkins University Press, Volume 56, Number 2, Fall 2007, pp. 509-541.
van Mourik Broekman, P. , Hall, G. , Byfield, T. , Hides, S. and Worthington, S. "Open education: A study in disruption", London: Rowman & Littlefield International, 2014. [10]
Wellmon, Chad and Piper, Andrew "Publication, Power, Patronage: On Inequality and Academic Publishing" in Critical Inquiry, 21 July 2017. download [accessed 30 Juy 2017].
Getting started
- Configuration settings list
- MediaWiki FAQ
- MediaWiki release mailing list
- Localise MediaWiki for your language
- Learn how to combat spam on your wiki
Consult the User's Guide for information on using the wiki software.
This is the start This was a coment Comments are visible only in the edit zone.