Difference between revisions of "Main Page"

From Eva Weinmayr Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(→‎State of the art in this domain/survey of the field)
(→‎State of the art in this domain/survey of the field)
Line 102: Line 102:
 
===Publishing as pedagogical, dialogical process===
 
===Publishing as pedagogical, dialogical process===
  
−
In the 60s and 70s political and feminist groups in a politicised climate of counter-information radical print-shops and collective screen print workshops (See Red) in London, feminist magazines (Spare Rib), and a vivid feminist zine culture (Riot girrrls) developed in many cities across Europe and the US in order to raise awareness against inequality and discrimination. Rejecting the role of the artist these activists participated in a network of campaign groups, radical publishers and distributors. One could argue, that the focus here was less on concepts of format or material qualities of a publication, instead the poster, magazine, book were a means to an end, to agitate, to activate, to get the message out, to give voice, create solidarity and work collectively towards change.
+
In the 60s and 70s political and feminist groups in a politicised climate of counter-information radical print-shops and collective screen print workshops (See Red) in London <ref name="Jess Baines" />, feminist magazines (Spare Rib), and a vivid feminist zine culture (Riot girrrls) developed in many cities across Europe and the US in order to raise awareness against inequality and discrimination. Rejecting the role of the artist these activists participated in a network of campaign groups, radical publishers and distributors. One could argue, that the focus here was less on concepts of format or material qualities of a publication, instead the poster, magazine, book were a means to an end, to agitate, to activate, to get the message out, to give voice, create solidarity and work collectively towards change.
  
 
For the See Red feminist silkscreen poster collective, for example, which started in London in 1974 working collectively was central. “In the early days the posters were mainly produced about our own personal experiences as women, about the oppression of housework, childcare and the negative image of women. An idea for a poster would be discussed in the group, a member would work on a design, bring it back for comment, someone else might make changes and so on until the collective was satisfied with the end result; no one individually took the credit. This was a concept many in the art world found hard to accept: ‘who holds the pencil? Someone must hold the pencil!’” The collective of women got together to combat the negative image of the women in advertising and the media. Suzy Mackie and Pru Stevenson, founding members of the See Red Women’s Workshop stressed in a public talk at The Showroom in London how important it was to gather in person and generate ideas about how to visualise a particular issue that was important to them. It was the activity of articulating experiences and collective brainstorming and the discussion of ideas that led to sharp slogans and imagery for the posters.
 
For the See Red feminist silkscreen poster collective, for example, which started in London in 1974 working collectively was central. “In the early days the posters were mainly produced about our own personal experiences as women, about the oppression of housework, childcare and the negative image of women. An idea for a poster would be discussed in the group, a member would work on a design, bring it back for comment, someone else might make changes and so on until the collective was satisfied with the end result; no one individually took the credit. This was a concept many in the art world found hard to accept: ‘who holds the pencil? Someone must hold the pencil!’” The collective of women got together to combat the negative image of the women in advertising and the media. Suzy Mackie and Pru Stevenson, founding members of the See Red Women’s Workshop stressed in a public talk at The Showroom in London how important it was to gather in person and generate ideas about how to visualise a particular issue that was important to them. It was the activity of articulating experiences and collective brainstorming and the discussion of ideas that led to sharp slogans and imagery for the posters.
Line 115: Line 115:
 
===Notes===
 
===Notes===
 
<references>
 
<references>
 +
<ref name="Jess Baines">See Jess Baines’ text “Free Radicals” about radical Print shops emerging in London in 1968, as DiY sites of political and community activism. Afterall, 28.1.2010
 +
http://www.afterall.org/online/radical.printmaking#.V8iDdmUWw20</ref>
 +
or the Atelier Populaire, set up in the École des Beaux Arts in Paris in May 1968.
 
<ref name="YesMen">New York Times Special Edition. See documentation New York Times Hoax - The Yes Men Fix The World https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YoZQNgAnvqs. Interview with Steve Lambert in Fillip Magazine winter 2009: https://fillip.ca/content/best-case-scenario, and Steve Lambert website https://visitsteve.com/made/the-ny-times-special-edition/</ref>
 
<ref name="YesMen">New York Times Special Edition. See documentation New York Times Hoax - The Yes Men Fix The World https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YoZQNgAnvqs. Interview with Steve Lambert in Fillip Magazine winter 2009: https://fillip.ca/content/best-case-scenario, and Steve Lambert website https://visitsteve.com/made/the-ny-times-special-edition/</ref>
 
<ref name="Perrault1">John Perrault, Some Thoughts on Books as Art, in Artists Books (1973: 15–21) quoted by Tony White in Book 2.0 in Volume 3 Number 2, 2013, page 168. doi: 10.1386/btwo.3.2.163_1</ref>
 
<ref name="Perrault1">John Perrault, Some Thoughts on Books as Art, in Artists Books (1973: 15–21) quoted by Tony White in Book 2.0 in Volume 3 Number 2, 2013, page 168. doi: 10.1386/btwo.3.2.163_1</ref>

Revision as of 17:14, 26 October 2018

Contents

about this wiki

This wiki is a method to develop, map, share and communicate the writing of my PhD in artistic practice at Valand Academy, University of Gothenburg. The wiki maps a tentative process of structuring, writing, thinking and discovering, discarding and restructuring – all the messy decision making processes which differentiates "a practice" from a finished output. This wiki is also a strategy to depart from the solitary word document being saved over and over again on my hard disk, at times being sent to supervisors in order to get an annotated version, which then again is saved on my disk. Endless versions of half-finished text fragments are populating my disk. Instead this wiki with its varied page structures allows me organise topics and fragments and most importantly make these moments of "taking shape" comprehensible and transparent. Finding ways to share and communicate my research in practice has been an ongoing and at times difficult negotiation between a set of forces pulling in different directions: academia, institutional policies, feminist and activist practice, the arts and education. Using a wiki as part of my research allows me to make transparent what is usually developed and discussed behind closed doors: the learning process, the struggle in articulating, the arguments, the agreements and disagreements.

In a few months time, once this draft has enough substance, I will invite peers to be in dialogue, to comment, to work it over, to debate and improve it. My doctoral research is a practice-led and is (and has been) supervised by Jyoti Mistry and Mick Wilson, Dave Beech and Andrea Phillips.

Please be aware that what you are reading now is a draft. It is kind of self-explaining, that citing from a wiki, which is in flux can be problematic. When you're going to cite from it, please do reference this fact or just get in touch: eva.weinmayr(at)akademinvaland.gu.se. Thank you.


Introduction

The format of my dissertation is a compilation thesis, comprising a distinct set of practices / practical experiments and a "kappa" (Swedish, translated as "coat") The kappa provides the context, entagles the methods, lists and to a certain degree reflects on the practice experiments (although this happens in more depth in published articles), and closes with an analysis and outlook.

The decision that a kappa is more generative, than a traditional monograph is based on several arguments:

1. My artistic practice consists of long-term projects. There is not one distinct ‘work / outcome / result’, which can be circulated, exhibited and audited, but a growing string of practices.

2. Most of these long-term practices are collaborations with people inside and outside academia. Two points here: Things/practices feeding back into this range of communities, requiring a variety of outcomes, formats, languages and terminologies, in order to make meaning. (see Charlotte Cooper Research Justice Diagram... rev) While this working method has clearly a political implications by attempting to resist systems of subjectivation and individualisation, it also poses a distinct set of problems, when collective practice is being audited – in the framework of a PhD for example. The syllabus for doctoral education at GU requests, that roles in teamwork can be defined and specific accomplishments credited [1]. However, all collective work, as I will argue, is based on a dialogical process where ideas flow freely back and forth. And more, sometimes it is impossible or even counterproductive to assess “who did what?” trying to separate distinct roles in collaborations. (needs reference? Deleuze/Parnett "Dialogues" or "See Red" Feminist Collective?)

3. Questions of dissemination are therefore crucial, and an integral part of my research. Both characteristics of my work – that it is (1) long-term and (2) collaborative – mean, that the format of the individually authored monograph is not suitable. I publish and communicate “on the go” and in many different contexts. That implies, that I expand our understanding of the word “publishing”: Publishing as a time-based and contextual practice. To understand publishing as a “verb” (a process) instead of a “noun” (verb). Here I wonder whether I can make the case for practice itself as a form of publishing, and ask how much public and which “publics” a process of publishing requires. So for example: Is a teaching situation a form of publishing? A workshop, where knowledge is collectively produced and disseminated at the same time? When we think of the collaborative as a situation, scene, process, dynamic, method, or mode? Can we frame a situation as “publishing”? What is ‘contextual publishing?’ Is publishing necessarily based on a document? What IS a document? The French librarian and documentalist Suzanne Briet (Bibliothèque Nationale de France) proposed in Qu’est- ce que la documantation? (1951), that an antelope running wild is regarded as an animal, however the antelope caged and exhibited in the zoo is arguably turned into document, analysed, described, categorised, classified, framed and exhibited. This thought seems relevant for my inquiry and needs more exploration.

–––––

The overall inquiry investigates publication as a social and pedagogical – and as such a political – process. The over-over-over-over arching topic of this inquiry is to explore the politics and infrastructures of publishing.

Artists have used publication to further their ideas since the turn of the last century, and in recent years there has been a sharp increase in this practice. While the current academic drive to publish for Research Excellence Framework (UK) might be considered part of this expansion, arguably this institutional pressure erodes artistic practice based on agency, creativity, criticality, experimentation and collective knowledge making. Publishing (and writing) in such contexts has been arguably reduced from a process of discovery and exploration, a process of communication, to a system for the assembly of more and more new products. (Fitzpatrick, 2011) What are possible publishing strategies of artists, academic and activists that contest these dominant paradigms of creation and dissemination of knowledge? I will ask what is the relationship between “making” and “making public”? Between experience and articulation? How does the “outside space” (distribution) shapes the “inside space” of publication (content). How can publishing create spaces, in the figurative and physical sense, for better mutual understanding and rethinking relations between people? How can publishing develop our capacities to establish the grounds for more lasting and emancipated forms of cultural production, education, and research? The starting point is my own artistic practice which investigates the politics of production and dissemination based on concepts found in feminist theory, feminist pedagogy, social science, philosophy, media theory and radical pedagogy. ____________________

The inquiry is located at the intersection of contemporary art, radical education and institutional analysis. It is based on my long-term individual and collective publishing practice. Publication as an artistic means became early on a main field of my practice. Partly because I could set the terms and conditions of production and distribution myself and could act without being authorised or dependent on galleries, curators, collectors, etc.), Secondly publications were a useful means to capture ephemeral processes into a document, that could be circulated and read by others. I took the first two publications, Lery - a story of facts and faxes (1998) and Mexico (with Vera Büchlmann and Joachim Melf, 1997) with me to my first trip to New York, walked into Printed Matter art book shop and sold them 10 copies each on consignment. What an empowering moment, which superseded by far any exhibition opportunity I ever had.

Ten years later after having published with big mainstream commercial publishing houses as well as small independent presses I got more and more interested setting up own publishing infrastructures and co-founded (with American artist Lynn Harris) AND publishing in London. And explored the social and and creative possibilities of print-on-demand at the time. Today AND is run together with Rosalie Schweiker and the agenda has become more political asking why, how, and for whom to publish.

So while until recently I would have said - without hesitation, that publishing, that ‘making public’ is an outright positive and constructive act, a tool of giving voice and developing emancipatory agency, I am much more cautious today, because as will argue, publishing has become an asset in the knowledge and cultural capital industry. As I will argue in the following, we are facing an growing imperative to ‘publish or perish’, which has problematic consequences on many different levels.

To articulate these problems and their implications on emancipatory, political art practice is one strand of my research. To experiment with and develop social, emancipatory, critical, feminist models of knowledge making and disseminating is another.


>>>authorship, authorisation and authority >>> key challenge: how to get out of this triangulation?

Thinking through the entanglement of the three concepts authorship, authorisation and authority. I am authorised to become an author by the institution, which is funding me, in order to become an authority in the field. What if I don't want to become an author or an authority? What if I don't want to become an institutionally authorised author authority? Who authorises whom?


Footnotes Introduction

  1. ↑ The syllabus for doctoral education at Gothenburg University states: ’In certain cases, dissertation work can be pursued as team work. This shall then be organised in such a way that the individual efforts can be specified and assessed on the same grounds as for individual pieces of work.’


State of the art in this domain/survey of the field

The examples and practices I will describe in the following are widely spread across geographies and histories as well as disciplinary framings. This is not ignorance or oversight, but a key methodological element of my trans-disciplinary approach. What we can observe is that one consistent feature these diverse practices seem to share is that they are discrete instances, where the dominant paradigms of publishing has been in some way adjusted – explicitly in the service of a counter-political project. The following examples could be summarised as practices, which adjust or disrupt dominant systems of publishing, and therefore contest power. They interfere, all in different ways, with discrete moments of authorship, editorial, design and production, as well as distribution, such as organising, classifying, archiving, and reading.

Early conceptual artist books 60s and 70s.

The situation: What did they do: What did it achieve:

Artists' books at the time were arguably a means to circumvent established institutions and perhaps to a certain degree an attempt to reform the art system by: “(1) the use of inexpensive printing and production methods allowed anyone to be a publisher, (2) alternative distribution networks were ‘aiding in the decentralization of the art system …’, (3) this form of art was portable and disposable and (4) these works were, or could be, ‘democratic objects’”.[1] [2]

These artistic practices criticised the paradigms of the art market by avoiding the aura of preciousness, uniqueness by using mass production technology such as commercial litho printing. In contrast to traditional, unique art objects “a book’s text is infinitely replicable, the number of copies that can be printed is theoretically limitless.”[3]

Art theorist Lucy Lippard argues that the main reason the book has proved to be so attractive as an artistic medium has to do with the fact that artists’ books are ‘considered by many the easiest way out of the art world and into the heart of a broader audience’.[4] Lippard describes here the fundamental political potential of the artists book as a conceptual and material means to question, intervene in and disturb existing practices and institutions.

Setting up infrastructures of production and distribution

The challenge however was the setting up production and distribution systems, that provided an alternative way to circulate the books without falling back to exclusionary market mechanisms of the art system. Investigating whether artists could set up independent systems of circulation the editors of Art-Rite magazine put out a call:

“Artists’ Books – We are investigating the possibilities of a publishing and distribution system for artists’ books. (This does not mean catalogues.) Do you have: a) already published books that we can distribute or sell on consignment? b) Completely planned, unpublished books with or without dummies? c) names of other artists who have either one? Let us know. Please send information to: PRINTED MATTER, 164 Mulberry St., NYC 10013.”[5]

Due to their perceived potential to subvert the (commercial, profit-driven) gallery system and to politicise artistic practice - artist books according to Joan Lyons played an important part in the rise of independent art structures.[6] Artists started to set up their own distribution infrastructures by founding independent artist book shops[7], in an attempt to counter the hegemonic art gallery market –to a certain extend. This disclaimer is necessary, as history has shown, that artists books were prone to be easily recaptured by the system. Firstly because many artist at the time were relying on gallery representation and gallery distribution. And secondly, because the descriptor “artist book” implies, that we deal with an object, which can easily be recaptured by the market as a collectible. Ed Ruscha for example writes in a letter to John Wilcock, the founder of Village Voice in New York: “I made a terrible mistake by numbering my “26 Gasoline Stations” books, because then the books became a limited edition rather than just another book, which is what I am after”.[8]


Terminologies and identity politics - this discussion needs perhaps to go elsewhere

The term artist book is still widely in use, as the names of New York Art Book Fair (founded by A.A. Bronson/Printed Matter in 2004[fact check]), London Art Book Fair (Whitechapel Art Gallery, London) evidence. However for my inquiry into the social agency of publishing the term “publishing” seems more useful. This new terminology suggests to shift the focus from the finished object to the process. … XXXX more here.

However while the term “artists’ publishing” opens up the practice it limits its applicability to authors, who define themselves as artists. Richard Kostelanetz writes in 1979 “One trouble with the current term artists’ books is that it defines a work of art by the initial profession (or education) of its author, rather than by qualities of the work itself. Since genuine critical categories are meant to define art of a particular kind, it is a false term. The art at hand is books no matter who did them; and it is differences among them, rather than in their authorship, that should comprise the stuff of critical discourse.”

This observation of authorship assigned to specific identities, professions or disciplines is very relevant for my inquiry and has been discussed and experimented with in a variety of forms.

Due to the problematic of the author question in “artist’s publishing” the term ‘independent publishing’ and self-publishing has been introduced. Both terms are seeking to distance the practice from institutional or mainstream commercial publishing practices.


Making Public: “Insertions into Ideological Circuits”

The situation:
What did they do:
What did it achieve:
In his series of works “Insertions into Ideological Circuits” (1970) the Brazilian artist Cildo Mereiles infiltrated already existing infrastructures of circulation by screen printing anti war slogans on recyclable Coca Cola bottles, or rubber stamped critical questions about the dictatorship on one dollar bills to circulate them through many hands. Here the artist merely “piggy-bagged” on already existing infrastructures of circulation as carrier for his messages. In the same vein in November 2008 activists around the US prankster collective The Yes Men “hacked” the New York Times by printing a “special edition” of 80,000 copies, which was distributed for free to passers-by on the streets of several US cities. This special edition was a perfect replica of The New York Times. The activists co-opted the authority and visual appearance of the New York Times in order to circulate a visionary “best case scenario” with hypothetical headlines and articles, such as “Iraq War Ends”, “Minimum Wage Law Passes Congress”, USA Patriot Act Repealed”, All Public Universities to Be Free”. [9]

Publishing as pedagogical, dialogical process

In the 60s and 70s political and feminist groups in a politicised climate of counter-information radical print-shops and collective screen print workshops (See Red) in London [10], feminist magazines (Spare Rib), and a vivid feminist zine culture (Riot girrrls) developed in many cities across Europe and the US in order to raise awareness against inequality and discrimination. Rejecting the role of the artist these activists participated in a network of campaign groups, radical publishers and distributors. One could argue, that the focus here was less on concepts of format or material qualities of a publication, instead the poster, magazine, book were a means to an end, to agitate, to activate, to get the message out, to give voice, create solidarity and work collectively towards change.

For the See Red feminist silkscreen poster collective, for example, which started in London in 1974 working collectively was central. “In the early days the posters were mainly produced about our own personal experiences as women, about the oppression of housework, childcare and the negative image of women. An idea for a poster would be discussed in the group, a member would work on a design, bring it back for comment, someone else might make changes and so on until the collective was satisfied with the end result; no one individually took the credit. This was a concept many in the art world found hard to accept: ‘who holds the pencil? Someone must hold the pencil!’” The collective of women got together to combat the negative image of the women in advertising and the media. Suzy Mackie and Pru Stevenson, founding members of the See Red Women’s Workshop stressed in a public talk at The Showroom in London how important it was to gather in person and generate ideas about how to visualise a particular issue that was important to them. It was the activity of articulating experiences and collective brainstorming and the discussion of ideas that led to sharp slogans and imagery for the posters.

I understand from these self-descriptions, that the collective work on developing a slogan, an image for a poster was a collective process of discovery, a dialogical process which was facilitated through collective making. So when does the making public start? Around the working table?


Example 2: Elise and Celestin Freinet purchase of a printing press for the classroom, elementary school in France (1926) to work in the classroom with students to produce own teaching material and textbooks. collective editing, peer review, school journal to be exchanged with other schools. Contextual publishing. School archive own classification system. (see Eva Weinmayr PRINT, in der Fahrende Raum, Munich, 2015)


Notes

  1. ↑ John Perrault, Some Thoughts on Books as Art, in Artists Books (1973: 15–21) quoted by Tony White in Book 2.0 in Volume 3 Number 2, 2013, page 168. doi: 10.1386/btwo.3.2.163_1
  2. ↑ John Baldessari for example writes in 1975: “I enjoy giving books I have made to others. Art seems pure for a moment and disconnected from money. And since a lot of people can own the book, nobody owns it. Every artist should have a cheap line. It keeps art ordinary and away from being overblown.” in Art-Rite (Anon. 1976/1977: 6)
  3. ↑ Kostelanetz, originally published in “Exhaustive Parallel Intervals”, Future Press, 1979, reprinted in Joan s (ed), Artists’ Books: a Critical Anthology and Sourcebook, Rochester, New York, Visual Studies Workshop Press, 1993, p.13.
  4. ↑ Lucy R. Lippard, ‘The Artist’s Book Goes Public’, in Joan s (ed), Artists’ Books: a Critical Anthology and Sourcebook, Rochester, New York, Visual Studies Workshop Press, 1993, p.45.
  5. ↑ ART RITE Magazine 11/12, winter/spring 1975/1976, p.3
  6. ↑ Joan Lyons (ed), “Artists’ Books: a Critical Anthology and Sourcebook”, Rochester, New York, Visual Studies Workshop Press, 1993, p8.
  7. ↑ Printed Matter founded by Lucy Lippard, Sol Lewitt and… in xxxx, Franklin Furnace, Ulisses Carrion started “Other Books” in Amsterdam, AA Bronson started Art Metropole in Toronto in xxx.
  8. ↑ Ed Ruscha letter to John Wilcock, 25 February 1966, The Piracy Collection, London, the archives of Giorno Poetry Systems. Ed Ruscha’s 26 Gasoline Stations book is today traded for 20,000$. >Reference Abebooks:xx
  9. ↑ New York Times Special Edition. See documentation New York Times Hoax - The Yes Men Fix The World https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YoZQNgAnvqs. Interview with Steve Lambert in Fillip Magazine winter 2009: https://fillip.ca/content/best-case-scenario, and Steve Lambert website https://visitsteve.com/made/the-ny-times-special-edition/
  10. ↑ See Jess Baines’ text “Free Radicals” about radical Print shops emerging in London in 1968, as DiY sites of political and community activism. Afterall, 28.1.2010 http://www.afterall.org/online/radical.printmaking#.V8iDdmUWw20

What are the experiments that I have carried out?

Against this backdrop of existing activities and theorisations in the expanded field of publishing and the formation of knowledge I have carried out a set of experiments and practices. A common aim and approach of these experiments is that I don't want to make work 'about politics', but instead find operational models to work politically – in the actual publishing practice itself. My concern is not to illustrate a political position, but actually engage in experiments in publishing practice with an explicit politics where these politics are to be materialised in the actual publishing practice itself.

They are distributed over a wide range of contexts, however what they have in common is that they can be seen as in relation to institutions and instituting. Some are institutional commissioned, others are located within institutions (with and without official mandate) and others develop outside institutions in order to create a transversal and collective space, that arguably cannot operate within institutional practices.

A further shared characteristic of the experiments described below is that they are collaborations, and thirdly they most are long-term projects, which developed conditionally, as a response to "a problem", or attempt to develop a strategy, which intervenes or counters specific patriarchal, oppressive, unequal politics in my direct environment.

Summary of projects and submitted material


AND Publishing –– with Rosalie Schweiker, multiple collaborators
(2009 - ongoing)

AND is a collaborative publishing activity based in London, which was initiated in 2009. It seeks to develop infrastructures of publishing asking: Why publish, how and for whom? AND was initiated at Byam Shaw School of Art in London. Observing that the existing institutional infrastructures keep replicating the exclusionary mechanisms and hierarchies dominating the university, we [1] started – without official mandate – however with the informal support of several colleagues [2] – a kind of indy-university press, which published works by students, staff and alumni in an equitable and non-hierarchical manner. Having started out to explore the immediacy and social possibilities of print on demand and new modes of distribution AND explores the social agency of cultural piracy (see 'The Piracy Project'), is invested in feminist radical pedagogy, and builds informal support structures, re-distribute budgets, commission work, and (re-)publish material which is difficult to find. We create temporary reading rooms (see Library of Omissions and Inclusions), share a studio, provide resources and advice, as well as access to skills, means of production and distribution. AND is part of a wider network of critical, feminist, de-colonial publishing activities (OOMK, X Marks the Bokship)investing much care and energy into the actual facilitating function of being a publisher, i.e to give voice, to enable, intervene, create a discourse and educate. Building such support structures and investing much care about the operational politics could be described as an attempt to act politically rather than making works 'about politics'.

Website andpublishing.org Visit

The long list of equal "ands" on the websites indicates, that we are less concerned to develop a focused brand or unified face, but a network of mutual alliances by working with people as well as institutions. The range of publications we produce, help produce or distribute can be seen here.

Published text 'One publishes to find comrades

Eva Weinmayr in "Publishing Manifestos", edited by Michalis Pichler, Yaiza Camps, Moritz Grünke, Cambridge Massachusetts: MIT, 2018. It was originally published in “The Visual Event, an education in appearances”, edited by Oliver Klimpel, Spector Books, Leipzig, 2014 Download

The text investigates feminist practices of publishing as a way to initiate a social process, a social space, where meaning is collectively established in the collaborative creation of a publication. The text discusses publishing practices, where printed publications, posters or zines are not necessarily the end product trying to convince anyone of anything, but rather a method of “working towards establishing conditions for the co-production of meaning".[3]

Published interview: 'AND not OR, the Anatomy of AND

Conversation between Anette Gilbert, Eva Weinmayr and Rosalie Schweiker about AND's collective feminist practice in "Publish! Publizieren als künstlerische Praxis", Kunstforum International issue 256, September 2018 (in German). 'AND not OR, the Anatomy of AND' Visit

Library of Inclusions and Omissions
(2016–ongoing)

The Library of Inclusions and Omissions is a practice based experiment to set up a reference library that is curated by the community who is using it. Can such a radical curatorial concept help to give voice to hidden, suppressed or not acknowledged material and subsequently turn a library from being a repository of knowledge (Samek 2003, Springer 2015) into spaces of social and intellectual encounter? Can it in turn help building a community or connecting different communities? The library is an attempt to gather feminist, intersectional, postcolonial materials which are not, or only sparsely available in institutional collections or databases, are not necessarily validated by publishing houses or institutions, are marginalised because deemed too radical, not mainstream or too flimsy in format. This collection consists at the moment of roughly 100 contributions, which are accessible to the public in temporary reading rooms installed in a range of contexts or by appointment at Valand Academy, Gothenburg.

Library of Omissions and Inclusions: The open call

Download Open Call English Swedish, Arabic
In order to receive contributions from a range of different cultural backgrounds and communities the open call was published in Swedish, English and Arabic and distributed in community centres, libraries, universities, art spaces in and around Gothenburg (suburbs such as Angered).

Library of Omissions and Inclusions: The index card catalogue

Visit

The cataloguing practice in this library attempts to challenge standard cataloguing practices. Instead of using the 'controlled vocabulary' and classifications of standardised institutional library catalogs, this library asks contributors for a short written rationale, why this book has been important to them and why they want to share this book with others. Here the emphasis in this library shifts from trying to describe and frame the actual content of the book in an objective and neutral manner to the readers' process of making meaning and the book's agency on the reader. This openly subjective library catalogue, which names desires, struggles and hopes takes its starting point from library scholar's research into the biases of the standardised classification. (Drabinski, Olson, Berman) It pays attention to the fact that “classification schemes are socially produced and embedded structures. They are products of human labor that carry traces of all the intentional and unintentional racism, sexism, and classism of the workers who create them. It is not possible to do classification objectively. It is the nature of subject analysis to be subjective.” (Drabinski, 201x) Therefore the openly articulated subjectivity in this collective resource can be described as an experiment to connect people through their readings, desires, struggles and hopes.

Library of Omissions and Inclusions: Temporary reading rooms installed in different contexts.

  • Reading room at 'Meaning Making Meaning', A-venue Gothenburg, 16 March-2 April 2016
    Visit webpage

The platform 'Meaning Making Meaning' was a three-part project convened by Gabo Camnitzer and consisted of an exhibition, a series of workshops and the Library of Omissions and Inclusions' reading room. In the exhibition and related workshops 37 artists and educators responded to two questions: “How do you bring a classroom to life as if it were a work of art?” (Felix Guattari, Chaosmosis) and its reformulation: “How do you bring a work of art to life as if it were a classroom?” [4]
  • Reading room at 'The Research Show', A-venue Gothenburg, April 2016
'The Research Show' was an informal exhibition of work in progress from doctoral researchers based in the artistic faculty of the University of Gothenburg and was convened by Cora Hillebrand, Ram Krishna Ranjan, and Mick Wilson.[5] In order to extend the duration and therefore accessibility of the Library of Omissions and Inclusions' reading room I proposed for it to stay on during the Research Show, which followed immediately the Meaning Making Meaning exhibition at A-Venue. One work spreading two exhibitions in the same venue.
  • Reading room at 'Let’s Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?', Valand Academy, 12-14 Oct 2016
The Library of Omissions and Inclusions was installed during the three-day international mobilisation around queer and feminist pedagogies, and participants of the event coming from seven European countries were asked to bring material to add to the library. 'Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?' was organised by the Feminist Pedagogy working group at Valand Academy. [6] (see detailed project description below).
  • Reading room at 'Utopia of Access', Pavilion for Artistic Research, Venice Biennale, 11 May - 2 July 2017
Curators Jan Kaila (Uniarts Helsinki) and Henk Slager (Utrecht University) invited ten researchers from different Nordic doctoral programs articulate new modes of artistic thinking concerning the notion of access. My approach to install a reading room in Venice was led by two questions: Can a collectively owned resource be exhibited in an international art biennale? What are the politics of 'exhibiting' a collectively owned resource based in a local community in Sweden in the context of an international Art Biennale? Can I present, exhibit a a 1:1 scale photographic representation of the books on the shelves. How can I 'tell about' this practice? Can I exhibit its method as a proposal to create and sustain a non-normative knowledge commons? By presenting a 1:1 scale photographic representation of the books on the shelves accompanied by a printed pamphlet, which discusses the politics of exhibition making as taking out of context and circulation and artistic co-option. (see text 'Dear Hannah')
  • Reading Room at AND Publishing Research Residency – 'Boxing and Unboxing', Marabouparken Konsthall, 21 April – 26 August 2018
Similar problematics around the politics of the exhibit were at stake when selected publications from the Library of Omissions and Inclusion were installed at MarabouParken Konsthall in Stockholm. Under the title 'Boxing and Unboxing' we shipped boxes to Stockholm containing materials we were working on at the time.[7] By displaying the materials in the cardboard boxes they were shipped in from London we invited visitors to 'unbox' its contents. In order to create a conducive environment for this process of discovery, we moved out of the designated exhibition hall 'backstage' and took over one of the office spaces between the kitchen and the offices on the first floor of MarabouParken Konsthall. The spatial proximity of the artists' Unboxing Room to the otherwise not accessible admin offices, allowed us to work in daylight and made the hidden work in the offices visible to visitors. The museum staff patiently coped with the situation.

Published text: 'Dear Hannah' on the occasion of 'Utopia of Access', Pavilion of Artistic Research, Venice Biennale 2017

The text is written in epistolary form addressed to an undisclosed peer named Hannah and has been published via email to my professional and personal email list, and was available as printed pamphlet in the exhibition 'Utopia of Access'. The text reflects on issues of co-option and the dilemma to 'exhibit' a collective resource, which is based in a local community, within the context of an international art biennale. Download text

Published chapter 'Library Underground – a reading list for a coming community

in "Publishing as Artistic Practice", edited Annette Gilbert, Berlin/New York: Sternberg, 2016 This chapter, written in form of a dialogue between Eva Weinmayr and her inner voice, discusses modes of dissemination. The text reflects on libraries as space of dissemination by turning private goods into public goods. It discusses the radical librarian movement in the 70s and 80s asking (i) who is the library for (status quo at the time was male, white Western middle class readership), (ii) what material is missing in order to "serve every member of the community" (American Library Bill of Rights, 1930x) and (iii) revealed the implicit biases in the organisation and classification of knowledge (Berman 1985x). The text then discusses a range contemporary practices of radical librarianship, such as aaaaarg.fail, memoryofthe world, the Piracy Project, practices which respond to the slightly shifted problematics of marketisation and monopolisation of knowledge. Download chapter

Performative reading of chapter 'Library Underground' at 'Miss Read, Akademie der Künste Berlin, 2016

Miss Read Artist Book Festival and conference, organised by Michalis Pichler, Yaiza Camps, Moritz Grünke. The panel 'Publishing as Artistic Practice' was convened by Annette Gilbert. Performative reading of a revised and updated script of the original text 'Library Underground' was performed by Eva Weinmayr as Eva Weinmayr and Eleanor Vonne Brown as Inner Voice.

Filmed performative reading of chapter 'Library Underground- welcome to my tent' at symposium 'Photography in Print and Circulation', Valand Academy Gothenburg, 2016

Convened by Louise Wolthers (Hasselblad Foundation and Niclas Östlind, Valand Academy. The text has been performed from inside a tent installed in the lecture hall with a video camera transmitting the filmed image outside the tent on the screen in the lecture hall. With Eva Weinmayr as Eva Weinmayr and Rose Borthwick as Inner Voice. Filmed and edited by Camilla Topuntoli. Video 32 min. Library Underground - watch video

Published presentation: 'Radical publishing practices ask for radical librarianship' at 'Artists as Publishers as Artists', University of Media Arts Cologne

During this presentation I published my manuscript live on Twitter providing links to used images and references. It was an attempt to share and publish the bibliography of my manuscript with the audience in order to be revisited after the talk.[8] Read the presentation

Alternative cataloguing workshop: 'Reading Gendered Words'

at symposium "Library Interventions", Leeds College of Art, April 2017 with Rosalie Schweiker The workshop was convened by Rosa Nussbaum and included a conversation between Maria Fusco and Wendy Kirk (Glasgow Women Library) around cataloguing practices at Glasgow Women Library. Developing unorthodox approaches to catalogue selected titles from the Library of Omissions and Inclusions in order to experiment with alternatives to the normative “controlled vocabulary” used in the standardised library classification systems.

The Piracy Project – with Andrea Francke and multiple collaborators (2010–ongoing)

The Piracy Project was initiated in 2010 together with artist Andrea Francke as one attempt amongst others to fight the closure of the library at Byam Shaw School of Art in London. In a joint effort students and staff turned Byam Shaw’s art college library, supported by its acting principal, into a self-organised library that remained public, and intellectually and socially generative. Through an open call for pirated books – as well as our research into pirate book markets in Peru, China and Turkey The Piracy Project gathered a collection of roughly 150 copied, emulated, appropriated and modified books from across the world. Their approaches to copying vary widely, from (1) playful strategies of reproduction, modification and reinterpretation of already existing works to (2) acts of civil disobedience circumventing enclosures such as censorship or market monopolies to, (3), acts of piracy generated by commercial interests. This is a vast and contradictory spectrum of cases, from politically motivated bravery, as well as artistic statements, to cases of hard-edge commercial exploitation. This collection of books serves as the starting point to explore the common understanding of authorship, originality and the implications policy development has had on intellectual property and copyright. Through temporary reading rooms, workshops, lectures, discussions and debates The Piracy Project explores the philosophical, legal and social implications of cultural piracy and creative modes of dissemination.

Searchable online catalogue Searchable online catalogue
Discursive events organised between 2010 – 2015 include
  • 'A day at the courtroom', The Showroom London, 15 June 2013. With Lionel Bently (Professor of Intellectual Property at the University Cambridge), Sergio Muñoz Sarmiento (Art and Law, New York), Prodromos Tsiavos (Creative Commons, England, Wales and Greece). Courtroom drawing by Thandiwe Stephanie Johnstone, 2013
  • 'The Piracy Project', panel discussion, Printed Matter, New York, with David Senior (bibliographer at MoMA), Anthony Huberman, (director of CCA Wattis Los Angeles), Joanne Mc Neil, (editor of Rhizome, NY), Munoz Sarmiento, (Art and Law), 2012
  • 'Poaching', workshop with Stephen Wright, The Showroom London, 18 May 2013
  • The Piracy Project/ One publishes to find comrades, Kunstverein Munich, 2013

For a full list please visit xxxxx.


Forthcoming chapter 'The Piracy Project', in “Archives of the Commons II - the Anomic Archive”, Red Conceptualismo del Sur, Museo Nacional Reina Sofia Madrid, 2018

The chapter is a revised manuscript of my presentation in the seminar "Socialising Archives" hold during the symposium "Archives of the Commons II" at Reina Sofia in Madrid, which was chaired by Mabel Tapia. I took this invitation and its distinct question to share experiences and methods, the operational strategies to turn the archive into a space of social and intellectual encounter as opportunity to reflect the curatorial and operational strategies we employed while working on The Piracy Project.

[read here the draft version]

Forthcoming chapter 'What Matter who’s speaking' in “Whose Book is it anyway - an anthology”, Cambridge: Open Book Publishers, 2019

The anthology is edited by Sarah Kember and Janis Jeffries, Goldsmiths University London, and CREATe (RCUK Centre for Copyright and New Business Models in the Creative Economy, University of Glasgow). I took this text as an opportunity to investigate the relationship between authorship and copyright, as it is presented to us from a legal, economic and institutional perspective. I do this by three means: I investigate through literary review how artists have arguably challenged the close ties between authorship and copyright looking at cases, such as Richard Prince and Cady Noland. Secondly I reflect how the question of authorship plays out in the collective practice 'The Piracy Project'. Thirdly I turn this essay itself into a practice-based experiment by asking how it would live and circulate and be validated in institutional research economies, if I didn't assign my name and therefore authorship to the text.

Published interview 'The Piracy Project' at 'Giving What you don’t have', 2013

Cornelia Sollfrank interviews Andrea Francke and Eva Weinmayr in the context of 'Giving What you don’t have', an artistic research project by Cornelia Sollfrank exploring the relationship between art and the commons at Postdigital Publishing Lab, Leuphana University, Lüneburg Watch the interview or read the transcript

Transcript of interview 'The Piracy Project' – Abigail de Kossnik (Berkeley Media studies) interviews Andrea Francke and Eva Weinmayr, 2016

Published text 'The Impermanent Book', co-authored with Andrea Francke, Rhizome, 2012

The text was included as print edition in 'Best of Rhizome 2012' edited by Joanne McNeil, Brescia: LINK Editions, 2013 The text looks at the desire of dealing with a stable book, an permanent object, which is resolved and fixed in print. It argues, that it is the technical advances of the analogue printing press combined with mass production that constructs the contemporary idea of books as fixed objects. A concept where immutability is a key factor that allows for mass and consistent reproduction. What are the consequences for the book as the authoritative object, to which one can always come back to, when digital technology facilitates mass production and mutability at the same time? Digital print and print-on demand have become widespread and allow for continuous changes, adaptions and revisions. The text discusses the assumed unease and fundamental challenge this kind of versioning exerts on the reader. What happens when books become unreliable objects, when one copy of the book potentially tells a different story than the other? Read text on Rhizome.org

Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy? three-day mobilization and workbook – with Feminist Pedagogy working group at Valand Academy, University of Gothenburg (2015–2016)

'Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy' is a long-term investigation into queer and feminist pedagogies, that led to the collective organising of an three-day international mobilisation at Valand Academy in October 2016. The Feminist pedagogies working group consisted of students and staff at the academy (names) and it's aim was twofold: Firstly the bi-weekly gatherings which were open to the whole academy provided a space to reflect on our own learning and teaching experiences, to read together and discuss relevant texts as well as to share infos and news, which were not officially communicated. The second and related aim was to organise an international conference, which developed alternatives to the dominant norms of conference organisation by fundamentally rethinking the terms and conditions of how knowledge is created and disseminated. Accompanying the event a workbook was published, which tested the agency of publishing in terms of rethinking the processes of production and distribution.

Working group 2015-2016

How we worked. Why it was craeted. The shared readings. The format of the meetings.

Published Workbook: 'Let's Mobilize What is Feminist Pedagogy?'

Download workbook Rethinking the production and dissemination of a book.
- How to invite others in the conversation? Make your own copy: Collective collating and binding. The distribution. Hanging poster-pages in the academy=turning the academy in a walkable book. Contextual distribution. Has been used as course reading in courses at the academy. Is beeing downloaded online. Circulates through indy bookshops.

- Collective editing process. Analogue editing. Scan as binding method.(Michael Murtaugh)

The organising of the mobilisation - administrative creativity

Subsequent invitations to workshops and talks

Forthcoming chapter 'Outside the Page' in issue "The Filmic Page", On Curating ZHdK Zürich

Forthcoming chapter 'Make your own adventure' (working title) in "Decolonialism after the educational turn"

Published documents
  • Programme of mobilisation (14 - 16 October 2016)Download
  • Online blog (2015-16)Visit

Unboxing, AND Research Residency, MarabouParken Konsthall, Stockholm – with Rosalie Schweiker April – August 2018

During the three-months research residency at MarabouParken in Stockholm AND Publishing organised together with curator Jenny Richards boxing training for self-defining women, installed an "Unboxing Room" with the boxes of materials they brought from their UK based practice and held three public talks.

MarabouParken Konsthall's evolving strand of research residencies aims to collaborate with artists groups and collectives in order to support their practice by developing "new lines of inquiry over a 3 month period and share these with a public through workshop and events.[9] The overarching strand called "Acts of Self-ruin" was based on Leela Ghandi's book "The Common Cause" inviting collectives to explore the struggle for collectivity and equality in an age of individualism. The boxing classes were advertised through a set of posters with visuals and text in Swedish, English, Arabic and Tigrinya (the two biggest ethnic groups in the area of the Konsthall), which were circulated in the imminent neighbourhood and across Stockholm. The boxing classes were taught by professional boxing teacher Sofia Thorne and Airin Fardipour and were an experiment to learn how to relate to each other, to learn about non-verbal negotiation, anger, care, transgression and defence.[10]

Terms and Conditions of working with institution

Set of posters [see posters]

Boxing classes

'Unboxing Calendar', AND Publishing London/MarabouParken KonsthallStockholm, 2018

A calendar with 52 weekly pages containing collectively with the boxers' produced visuals. The collages result from a workshop, where we tried to reflect visually the spirit and experiences during the boxing classes to articulate experiences, that could not be verbalised. The text by Ar Parmacek, at the time intern at MarabouParken Konsthall captures verbally a selections of concerns of the project from her perspective of an co-organiser and observant. Choosing the form of a calendar as publication genre aims to embed its issues into everyday life. A year of daily boxing and unboxing.

Topic Co-option

Published book 'Downing Street', New Documents, Los Angeles, 2014

Published chapter: Help! David Cameron Likes my Art, in "Distributed",Open Editions 2017

edited David Blamey and xxxx.

chapter to be written: Eva Weinmayr/Heiner Müller, Keep it Complex/Wolfgang Tillmans

Reflection, theorisation of projects and submitted material

  • post-artistic art
  • unified face
  • autorship
  • assessment
  • classification
  • copyright
  • open source
  • open access

Notes

  1. ↑ AND was co-founded by Lynn Harris and Eva Weinmayr. Andrea Francke worked temporarily with AND. Today it is run by Rosalie Schweiker and Eva Weinmayr
  2. ↑ Support included the offer to share their office and equipment, including publishing classes in their courses inviting us to develop publishing projects with students, facilitating work-based learning internships with AND. The management quickly realised the critical and socially generative potential of our activity and provided small funds and semi-official support
  3. ↑ Stevphen Shukaitis, Toward an Insurrection of the Published? Ten Thoughts on Ticks & Comrades, eicp transversal, June 2014 [1]
  4. ↑ It included work by Alina Tenser, Andrea Phillips, Ann-Charlotte Glasberg Blomqvist, Annette Krauss, Anton Vidokle, Barnfilmskolan, Bronwyn Bailey-Charteris, Cara Tolmie and Kimberley O’Neill, Doa Aly, Elizabeth Ellsworth and Jamie Kruse (Smudge Studio), Emanuel Almborg, Eva Weinmayr, Felicity Allen, Gert Biesta and Carl Anders Säfström, Glenn Loughran, Harrell Fletcher, Henry Giroux, Irit Rogoff, Janna Graham, Jaroslav Andel, Jason E. Bowman, Jenny Richards, Jessica Hamlin, Jeuno JE Kim and Ewa Einhorn, Katrin Ingelstedt, Lisa Nyberg, Lovisa Gustafsson, Maj Hasager, Maria Acaso and Jordi Ferreiro, Monica Sand, Olav Westphalen, Olivia Plender, Pedro Lasch, Stephan Dillemuth, Stephen Duncombe, Sunshine Socialist Cinema, and Tyson E. Lewis.
  5. ↑ Participating artists were André Alves, Eva la Cour, Kerstin Hamilton, Annelies Vaneycken, Arne Kjell Vikhagen, and Eva Weinmayr.
  6. ↑ The core working group's members were Andreas Engman, Eva Weinmayr, Gabo Cammnitzer, Kanchan Burathoki, Mary Coble, and Rose Borthwick.
  7. ↑ for example The Piracy Project, Teaching for people who prefer not to teach, The Library of Omissions and Inclusions, Let’s Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?, https://www.artsadmin.co.uk/events/3850 a selection of good and bad sports bras (D cup and upwards)], Keep It Complex, as well as our terms and conditions, emails and other miscellaneous items.
  8. ↑ Organised by Agustina Andreoletti, Lilian Haberer, Karin Lingnau, Konstantin Butz. Supported by Birgit Trogemann See programme
  9. ↑ Invitation email from curator Jenny Richards, 7 August 2017
  10. ↑ MarabouParken website

to do

send authorship text to Nourbese Phillips.


method

bibliography references

Alperin, J.P., Muñoz Nieves, C., Schimanski, L., Fischman, G.E., Niles, M.T. & McKiernan, E.C. (2018). How significant are the public dimensions of faculty work in review, promotion, and tenure documents? Humanities Commons [preprint]. doi: Media:http://dx.doi.org/10.17613/M6W950N35

Genette, Gérard, Paratexts, Thresholds of interpretation (Cambridge University Press, 1997)

Hall, Gary, “Digitize this Book, The Politics of New Media, or Why We Need Open Access Now”, Minnesota University Press, 2008

Hayles, Katherine N. , "How We Think: Digital Media and Contemporary Technogenesis" (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2012)

Leigh Star, Susan

Olson, Hope A., “How we construct Subjects: Feminist Analysis”, in Library Trends, Johns Hopkins University Press, Volume 56, Number 2, Fall 2007, pp. 509-541


van Mourik Broekman, P. , Hall, G. , Byfield, T. , Hides, S. and Worthington, S. "Open education: A study in disruption" (London: Rowman & Littlefield International, 2014) Media:https://curve.coventry.ac.uk/open/file/c04530ce-d16a-46ca-b359-a905195a76cb/1/Open education.pdf














Getting started

Consult the User's Guide for information on using the wiki software.

This is the start This was a coment Comments are visible only in the edit zone. and them....

File:Cataloguing-glasgow-library 2.jpg

Facts about "Main Page"