Difference between revisions of "2 Setting"

From Eva Weinmayr Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(→‎Notes Settings)
(→‎Roadmap)
 
(209 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
  
−
=Multiple sites=
+
==Multiple sites==
  
−
This wiki provides an overview account of a doctoral research project, provisionally entitled "xxxx". The inquiry explores the social and political agency of publishing by investigating the micro-politics of making, articulating, and sharing knowledges from an intersectional feminist and decolonial perspective.  
+
This wiki provides an overview of a doctoral research project, entitled "Noun to Verb: an investigation of the micro-politics of publishing through artistic practice." The project explores the social and political agency of publishing, investigating the micro-politics of making, articulating, and sharing knowledges from an intersectional feminist perspective.  
  
−
In practical terms, the research process comprises a range of event-based or discursive activities, (art-making, workshopping, publishing, editorial work, collaborative practices, conferencing, organizing, pedagogical interventions, etc.) and a range of stabilizations (publications, chapters, essays, posters, ephemera, archives, reading rooms, exhibitions, etc.). Both the practice and outcomes are developed collaboratively with different actors and constellations.
+
In practical terms, the research process comprises (i) a range of activities, (art-making, workshopping, publishing, editorial work, collaborative practices, conferencing, organizing, pedagogical interventions, discursive events, etc.) and (ii) a range of "stabilizations" (publications, chapters, essays, posters, ephemera, archives, reading rooms, exhibitions, etc.). Both (i) and (ii) are developed collaboratively.
  
−
Publication (in print or code) may be understood as a means of sharing, of disclosing, of passing on, or of 'making public' texts, images, ideas, or what we may summarily call "knowledges". One way of understanding the act of publishing is as an instance of temporarily stabilizing knowledge by fixing it into an object material form (paper, ink, screen, code). As a medium, detached from the makers (person), moment (time) and ecologies (context) of its production it can circulate and spread into different regions, contexts, and epochs or in Florian Cramer's words, "the idea of the book is one that can be read in 1, 5, and 100 years time." <ref name= "Florian Cramer 1"/>It develops a social and intellectual life of its own.  
+
Publishing may be understood as a means of sharing, of disclosing, of passing on, or as an act of 'making public' that includes texts, images, ideas, and what we may summarily call "knowledges". Publishing may also be understood as a temporary stabilization of knowledge, fixing the act of making-public into a material and mobile form (paper, ink, screen, code) – fixing it into an object. As an object, detached from the makers (person), moment (time) and ecologies (context) of its production, a publication can circulate and spread across regions, contexts, and epochs – in Florian Cramer's (2012) words, "the idea of the book is one that can be read in one, five, and one hundred years' time." It develops a social and intellectual life of its own.  
  
−
While publication can enable the one to speak to the many, and as such be seen as a mode of address that constructs patterns of dominance (footnote maybe insert reference st ideas of print culture as part of homogenizing and creating the nation, etc.)  the act of publication can also be seen as a tool to give voice and recognition to bodies and experiences, which are not yet acknowledged or articulated within the range of existing knowledges. Therefore publication can be seen as a process that invites both assent and dissent, and that produces countervailing views and alternative readings, something that has fuelled much debate on "the public sphere". These are themes that have been widely discussed for the rise of print culture (Eisenstein, 1982; Johns, 1998). However, the specific focus of this research is not the global or historical claims for the impact of print culture but rather the micro-politics of publishing practices at the intersection of contemporary art, radical education, and institutional analysis. <ref name="contemporary art"/>
+
While publication can enable the one to speak to the many, and as such be seen as a mode of address that constructs patterns of dominance, the act of publication can also be seen as a tool to give voice and recognition to bodies and experiences that are not yet acknowledged, articulated or prioritized within the range of existing knowledges.<ref name= "knowledge"/>
 +
Therefore publication can be seen as a process that invites both assent and dissent, and that produces countervailing views and alternative readings, something that has fueled much debate on "the public sphere."<ref name= "public sphere"/>{{annotation|Footnote}} Such themes have been widely discussed in relation to the rise of European print culture (Eisenstein, 1982; Johns, 1998), but these debates are not the main focus here. Instead, the present research specifically addresses the micro-politics of publishing practices at the intersection of contemporary art, radical education, and institutional analysis.<ref name="contemporary art"/> Furthermore, publishing practices are not exclusively considered here in terms of print culture, but rather are understood as part of a wider multiplicity of modes and formats that operate as "stabilizations" of knowledges, as indicated above.
  
−
Publishing practices are, in this inquiry, not limited to the printed book. They extend to networked digital media technologies with their promise to replace "the fixity and the static (and, by implication, limiting) linearity of print by adding multimedia features, interactivity, hyperstructure and virtually limitless possibilities for non-verbal, interactive, reading and communication for the reader" <ref name= "Anne Mangen 1"/>
+
I use the word "knowledges" in plural to problematize the idea of singular, disembodied and universal knowledge that is associated with modern Western epistemologies.<ref name="Modern Project"/> Knowledges in this inquiry are understood in Donna Haraway's sense as "ruled by partial sight and limited voice – not partiality for its own sake but, rather, for the sake of the connections and unexpected openings situated knowledges make possible." (Haraway 1988, 590). Therefore knowledges in my view are fundamentally contingent and interactive. "Situated knowledges are about communities, not about isolated individuals. The only way to find a larger vision is to be somewhere in particular." (Haraway 1988, 590). To be somewhere in particular means also to be response-able. Here, knowing is understood as a fundamental relational act. Take the "streetwalker theorist" invoked by Maria Lugones, for example, who "cultivates a multiplicity and depth of perception and connection and 'hangs out'." The streetwalker theorist's "knowing is necessarily dialogical; it does not lie in her". (Lugones, 2003, chapter 10 “Tactical Strategies of the Streetwalker”, "Streetwalker Theorizing").<ref name= "Lugones Pilgrimages 648"/>
−
It is the "unbound" character of the digital that unsettles "conceptual systems founded upon ideas of center, margin, hierarchy, and linearity and replaces them with ones of multi-linearity, modes, links, and networks." The unbound is a moment of recapitulation, and as George Landow claims, "a direct response to the strengths and weaknesses of the printed book." <ref name=" Landow 1"/>And Gary Hall notes that
 
−
the defamiliarizing effects of these new conceptions "offer us a chance to raise the kind of questions regarding our ideas of the book (but also of the unified, sovereign, proprietorial subject; the individualized author, the signature, the proper name; originality, fixity, the finished object; the canon, the discipline, tradition, intellectual property; the Commons, community, and so on), we should have been raising all along." <ref name="Gary Hall Unbound Book"/>  
 
  
−
Whether "bound" or "unbound", we observe much discussion of the political agency of the book, however, what arguably constructs "the political nature of the book" is not necessarily the book as a discrete container for radical content alone. Instead, what is of interest in this particular inquiry is the book's assumed capacity as a conceptual and material means to practically intervene, disrupt and change existing systems of production, distribution, and consumption of knowledge. (Adema and Hall, 2014; Thoburn, 2014; Constant, ongoing)<ref name="Constant ongoing"/>
+
The emphasis here is on a dialogical process – "knowing with". The use of the verb "knowing", an active form, stands in contrast to "knowledge", an objectifying noun implying that knowledge can be appropriated and owned. In this sense, "knowing with" (rather than "having knowledge" or "knowing about") runs counter to the prevailing Western assumptions of authorship and ownership<ref name= "Santos Cognitive page 54"/> that I discuss in the book chapter "Confronting Authorship, Constructing Practices" (Weinmayr 2019). The "knowing with" is foregrounding knowledge as a "situated conversation at every level of its articulation" (Haraway 1988, 594) as I will argue throughout this research project – including, but not limited to, articulations in the form of publishing.  
  
−
The inquiry is based on my long-term individual and collective publishing practice. Publication as an artistic means became early on the main field of my practice. Partly because as a student I spend the significant time of my studies next to the photocopy machines in the art academy and secondly because I could shape the terms and conditions of production and distribution and could act without authorization by galleries, curators, collectors, etc.).<ref name=" Printed Matter"/>
+
Of course, publishing practices extend far beyond the printed page. A core concern of this inquiry is to expand and test the normative criteria of what constitutes a publication. One question that emerged was whether publishing may be seen as a verb, a process, rather than a noun (i.e. the finished object) – analogous to the above distinction between "knowing" and "knowledge". Could practice itself be understood as a form of publishing? A teaching situation, for example – a workshop, seminar, or group dialogue, where knowledge is collectively created and shared at the same time – could this also be considered as publishing? What kinds of publics are necessary or relevant to a publication process? A collaboration, a collective, a scene, a process, a dynamic, a method – can we frame any such situation or process as "publishing"? How fixed or stable does a transmission of knowledges need to be in order to be called a "publication"? And what is the function and effect of such stability?
−
However, while this research is embedded in my longterm artistic practice using the form of publication as a carrier for ideas<ref name= "my publications"/>, this inquiry is not focusing on artists' books in particular. The descriptor artists' books seems too narrow and would limit the investigation to publications made by artists. The questions I will ask are more fundamental and directed towards the processes and agencies of publishing across disciplines and fields.
 
  
−
Take, for example, the early conceptual artists' books in the context of the 1960s and 1970s in the US. They have been described as "a means of democratizing and subverting existing institutions by distributing an increasingly cheap and accessible medium (the book),[...] in order to reimagine what art is and how it can be accessed and viewed.' <ref name=" Adema1"/> As such they expanded the limits of what was commonly perceived (and traded) as art, "and" they challenged existing hierarchies and institutions.{{Interlink|Survey_of_the_field#Early_conceptual_artist_books:_Setting_up_infrastructures_of_production_and_distribution_.28the_60s_and_70s.29|see Survey of the field: Survey_of_the_field#Setting_up_alternative_infrastructures}} This critical agency in its initial phase, as I would claim, has watered down over the years since making "artists books" has become an almost mainstream artistic practice. This is evidenced by hundreds of newly emerging artist book fairs across the globe, sometimes hosted by the most prestigious and mainstream museums, such as MoMA PS1 in New York, Tate Modern, or Whitechapel Gallery in London. Florian Cramer provokingly declares that artists' books today tend to be "a genre of graphic design". In printed form, "they strive to become coffee table books, often with warm, fuzzy and unbound characteristics," and therefore turn into "boutique collectibles for rich people." <ref name="Florian Cramer 1"/>
+
Networked digital media technologies also replace "the fixity and the static (and, by implication, limiting) linearity of print by adding multimedia features, interactivity, hyperstructure and virtually limitless possibilities for non-verbal, interactive, reading and communication for the reader" (Mangen 2012). It is the "unbound" character of the digital that unsettles "conceptual systems founded upon ideas of center, margin, hierarchy, and linearity and replaces them with ones of multi-linearity, modes, links, and networks." (Landow 1992, 2). The unbound is a moment of recapitulation, and, according to  George Landow (1992, 3), "a direct response to the strengths and weaknesses of the printed book." And Gary Hall (2016, 158) notes that the defamiliarizing effects of these new conceptions
 +
::offer us a chance to raise the kind of questions regarding our ideas of the book (but also of the unified, sovereign, proprietorial subject; the individualized author, the signature, the proper name; originality, fixity, the finished object; the canon, the discipline, tradition, intellectual property; the Commons, community, and so on), we should have been raising all along.  
  
−
For the field of feminist publishing, open-source, and Free Software exemplified, for example, through the work of Constant, a feminist technology collective based in Brussels, we observe a very different critical energy. Software for Femke Snelting is a cultural object. "Free Software culture takes care of sharing the recipes of how this technology (in a cultural sense, not a technocentric) has been developed. [...] And this produces many different other tools, ways of working, ways of speaking, vocabularies because it changes radically the way we make and the way we produce hierarchies. So that means, if you produce a graphic design artifact, for example, you share all the source files that were necessary to make it. But you also share, as much as you can, descriptions and narrations of how it came to be, which does include, maybe, how much was paid for it, what difficulties were in negotiating with the printer, what elements were included, [...] what software was used to make it and where it might have resisted. [...] You care about all these different layers of the work, all the different conditions that actually make the work happen." <ref name= "Femke GWYDH"/>Open Software culture, therefore, investigates how technologies and its protocols disrupt economies of authorship and ownership, and implicitly redefines hierarchies and enclosures commonly attached to a publication. 
+
Whether "bound" or "unbound," there has been much discussion of the political agency of the book, and it is often assumed that the book's political potential extends only as far as its 'content'. Yet what is of interest in the present inquiry is the book's capacity as a conceptual and material means to practically intervene, disrupt, and change existing systems of production, distribution, and consumption of knowledge. (Adema and Hall, 2014; Thoburn, 2014; Constant, ongoing)<ref name="Constant ongoing"/>
  
−
This is also to a certain extent true for the current field of scholarly publishing where new material conditions of academic book production, organization and consumption allow for experiments with forms and concepts of academic publishing.<ref name= "variability monograph"/> Here digital publishing and open access place in question, in Janneke Adema's words, "the very print-based system of scholarly communication - complete with its ideas of quality, stability, and authority - on which so much of the academic institution rests." <ref name= "Adema2"/> But open access also poses a challenge since we can observe tendencies of corporate take over. Since national and international policies demanded that publicly funded research is to be made freely available, commercial academic presses merely shifted the costs from the reader (who used to pay for an article) towards the author, researcher, or their institution. By imposing "author or article processing charges" (APC) <ref name=" open access models"/> they maintain their income-generating model (profit) whereby creating a range of new enclosures and inequalities, that are discussed in more detail in the interview "Thinking where the thinking happens" with the director of Goldsmiths Press Sarah Kember.{{Interlink|Summary_of_projects_and_submitted_material#Rethinking_where_the_thinking_happens_.28public_interview.29|see Summary of material: Rethinking where the thinking happens, interview with Sarah Kember}}
+
This inquiry is grounded in my individual and collective publishing practice, which has been a long-term part of my work as an artist. Publication became a main mode of my practice early on: perhaps because as a student I spent a significant part of my studies working next to the photocopy machines in the art academy; and perhaps because through publishing it appeared that I could shape the terms and conditions of production and distribution and could act without the authorization of galleries, curators, collectors, etc.<ref name=" Printed Matter"/>  
 +
However, while this research is embedded in my long-term artistic practice using the form of publication as a carrier for ideas,<ref name= "my publications"/> this inquiry is not focusing on artists' books in particular. The descriptor "artists' books" is too narrow, in limiting the investigation to publications made by artists. The questions I will ask are more fundamental: directed towards the processes and agencies of publishing that operate across disciplines and fields, rather than limiting these to the specific commodity genre of the artists' book.
  
−
Many academic activists, such as the Radical Open Access Collective address these counterproductive tendencies of high profile academic journals charging "exorbitant, unaffordable and unsustainable publishing fees" and campaign instead for "new forms of communality, designed to support the building of commons-based open access publishing infrastructures, and promote a more diverse, not-for-profit eco-system of scholarly communication.' <ref name= "Radical Open Access"/> Gary Hall laid some strategies out in his "Inhumanist Manifesto" <ref name=" Inhumanist Manifesto"/> and Mayfly Books sums the current situation up as "it seems today that scholarly publishing is drawn in two directions: On the one hand, this is a time of the most exciting theoretical, political and artistic projects that respond to and seek to move beyond global administered society. On the other hand, the publishing industries are vying for total control of the ever-lucrative arena of scholarly publication, creating a situation in which the means of distribution of books grounded in research and in radical interrogation of the present are increasingly restricted." <ref name="mayflybooks"/>
+
Take, for example, the early conceptual artists' books in the context of the 1960s and 1970s in the US. They have been described as "a means of democratizing and subverting existing institutions by distributing an increasingly cheap and accessible medium (the book) [...] in order to reimagine what art is and how it can be accessed and viewed." (Adema and Hall 2013, 140). As such they expanded the limits of what was commonly perceived (and traded) as art, and they challenged existing hierarchies and institutions.{{Interlink|3_Survey_of_the_field#Setting_up_alternative_infrastructures|see chapter 03*Survey of the field: Setting up alternative infrastructures}} My understanding is that the critical agency of the artist’s book, as elaborated in this initial phase of experimentation, has become watered down over the years – the making of "artists' books" has become a mainstream artistic practice and market. This is evidenced by hundreds of newly emerging artist book fairs across the globe, sometimes hosted by the most prestigious mainstream museums, such as MoMA PS1 in New York, or Tate Modern and Whitechapel Gallery in London. Florian Cramer (2012) provocatively declares that artists' books today tend to be "a genre of graphic design." In printed form, "they strive to become coffee table books, often with warm, fuzzy and unbound characteristics," and therefore turn into "boutique collectibles for rich people."
  
−
This very summarily mapping of the sites indicates that my practice is situated across art, academia and activism. The five practice projects, most of them long term and collaborative, have each explored a range of specific questions and have done so in a way that is both layered and complex. They are not discrete single-issue, single-question experiments but rather complex tangles of issues unfolding in real-world situations and "live" fields of operation. They often developed as responses to specific problems or questions. As such, they don't intend to make works "about politics". Instead, they aim at finding operational models to work counter-politically – through the actual practice itself. Hence my artistic concern is not to illustrate a political position, but to actively engage in political experiments in publishing and ecologies of knowledge.
+
In the field of open-source and free software, and feminist approaches in particular – exemplified by Constant, a feminist technology collective based in Brussels – we observe a very different critical energy. As Femke Snelting (2014) argues, software is a cultural object:
 +
::Free Software culture takes care of sharing the recipes of how this technology (in a cultural sense, not a technocentric) has been developed. [...] And this produces many different other tools, ways of working, ways of speaking, vocabularies, because it changes radically the way we make and the way we produce hierarchies. So that means, if you produce a graphic design artifact, for example, you share all the source files that were necessary to make it. But you also share, as much as you can, descriptions and narrations of how it came to be, which does include, maybe, how much was paid for it, what difficulties were in negotiating with the printer, what elements were included, [...] what software was used to make it and where it might have resisted. [...] You care about all these different layers of the work, all the different conditions that actually make the work happen.  
 +
Free software culture, therefore, investigates how technologies and their protocols disrupt economies of authorship and ownership, and implicitly redefines the hierarchies and enclosures that are embedded in more mainstream publishing practices.  
  
−
=More verb, less noun: the practices=
+
This is also true of certain emerging tendencies within academic publishing, where new material conditions of book production, organization and consumption allow for experiments with forms and concepts of scholarly publishing.<ref name= "variability monograph"/> Here digital publishing and open access place in question, in Janneke Adema's words, "the very print-based system of scholarly communication – complete with its ideas of quality, stability, and authority – on which so much of the academic institution rests." (Adema and Hall 2013, 139). Open access policies, which demand that publicly funded research must be made freely available, are based on the argument that the public has already funded the research which should be consequently be made publicly available at no cost. Yet the implementation of these policies may also carry the threat of corporate take-over. In many cases commercial academic presses have merely shifted the costs from the reader (who would previously be required to pay for articles directly) back to the author, researcher, or their institution. By imposing "author or article processing charges" (APC),<ref name=" open access models"/> academic presses maintain their income-generating model, thereby creating a range of new enclosures and inequalities that are discussed in more detail in the interview "Thinking where the thinking happens" with the director of Goldsmiths Press Sarah Kember.{{Interlink|4_Summary_of_projects_and_submitted_material#Rethinking_where_the_thinking_happens_.28public_interview.29|see chapter 04*Summary of projects and submitted material: Rethinking where the thinking happens, interview with Sarah Kember}}
  
−
{{Interlink|Library of Inclusions and Omissions|see Project: Library of Inclusions and Omissions}}
+
Universities and academic activists have addressed the "exorbitant, unaffordable and unsustainable publishing fees" charged by many scholarly journals by campaigning for "new forms of communality, designed to support the building of commons-based open access publishing infrastructures, and promote a more diverse, not-for-profit ecosystem of scholarly communication." (Adema 2018)<ref name= "Radical Open Access"/> Gary Hall laid some strategies out in his "Inhumanist Manifesto"<ref name=" Inhumanist Manifesto"/> and Mayfly Books have summed up the current situation up as follows:
−
The '''Library of Inclusions and Omissions''' (2016) is a practice-based experiment in critical knowledge infrastructures. Setting up a community-run reading room around intersectional feminist and post-colonial materials, the project explores the politics (potentials and limitations) of libraries, online and physical, for accessing, activating, and disseminating knowledge. Defining the library as a knowledge infrastructure (Mattern, 2014), I practically test dominant policies of validation (access) and classification (organization) and ask in which way such a community-run resource is fundamentally different from institutional libraries with their respective instituted selection and validation processes. With the Library of Inclusions and Omissions, I seek to develop a curatorial concept to give voice to hidden, suppressed, or not acknowledged materials. In which way could such a curatorial strategy help to share un-acknowledged struggles, and subsequently turn a library from being a repository of knowledge (Samek 2003, Springer 2015) into a space of social and intellectual encounter and action? Can such a library project help building a community or connecting different communities?
+
::it seems today that scholarly publishing is drawn in two directions: On the one hand, this is a time of the most exciting theoretical, political and artistic projects that respond to and seek to move beyond global administered society. On the other hand, the publishing industries are vying for total control of the ever-lucrative arena of scholarly publication, creating a situation in which the means of distribution of books grounded in research and in radical interrogation of the present are increasingly restricted.<ref name="mayflybooks"/>
  
−
{{Interlink|The Piracy Project|see Project: The Piracy Project}}
+
This brief mapping of developments in different fields of publishing practice also reflects the fact that my practice is situated across art, academia, and activism. The five projects I will present, typically of a long term and collaborative nature, each explore a range of specific questions in a way that is layered and complex. They are not discrete single-issue, single-question experiments but rather complex tangles of issues unfolding in real-world situations and "live" fields of operation. They often developed as responses to specific situations and to emergent problems or questions in concrete locations. As such, they don't intend to operate as works "about politics." Instead, these projects aim at finding operational models to work counter-politically – through the actual practice itself.<ref name="counter-politically"/> Hence my artistic concern is not to illustrate a political position but to actively engage in political experiments in publishing and ecologies of knowledge.
−
'''The Piracy Project''' (2010-15), based in London, is a long-term collaboration with Peruvian artist Andrea Francke exploring the dominant understanding of authorship, originality, and the implications of intellectual property and copyright policies has on knowledge practices. Through an open call for pirated books and our research into pirate book markets in Peru, China, and Turkey, The Piracy Project gathered a collection of around 150 copied, emulated, appropriated and modified books from across the world. Their copying approaches vary widely, from playful strategies of reproduction, modification, and reinterpretation of existing works to circumventing enclosures such as censorship or market monopolies, to acts of piracy generated by commercial interests. Through temporary reading rooms, workshops, lectures, discussions, and debates, The Piracy Project explores the philosophical, legal, and social implications of cultural piracy. I will examine in which ways the pirated, modified, emulated books in the collection transgress the normative concept of authorization, challenge the idea of individual authorship, and the assumed authority of the printed book. In the theorization of this project, I will show in which way the project's unauthorized interventions into "stable" and authoritative knowledge aims to reveal and undo the reciprocity between authorship, originality and intellectual property, a triangulation that, as I will demonstrate, constitutes one of the main blockages for collective knowledge practices.
+
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
  
−
{{Interlink|Let%27s_Mobilize:_What_is_Feminist_Pedagogy%3F|see Project: Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?}}
+
==More verb, less noun: the practices==
−
'''Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?''' (2015/16) is a long-term collective investigation into intersectional, feminist, and de-colonial pedagogies, that led to (I) the organization of a three-day international mobilization at HDK-Valand Art Academy, University of Gothenburg and (II) the publishing of a workbook with the same title. A working group developed at the Academy consisting of students, staff, and administrators (Kanchan Burathoki, Rose Borthwick, MC Coble, Andreas Engman, Gabo Camnitzer, Eva Weinmayr). Its aim was twofold: Firstly, to provide a space to discuss the highs and lows in our own learning and teaching and to study and review university policies and institutional habits. Secondly, the group worked towards organizing an international conference (mobilization) that fundamentally rethinks how knowledge is produced, transmitted, and disseminated. We were keen to find strategies to adjust the Euro-centric canon and its exclusions, to question institutional habits and procedures, and to create an understanding of equality that is not blind to difference. The mobilization itself was a practice-based investigation experimenting with non-normative use of the classroom, time and temporalities, languages, and paying attention to the empirical body.
 
−
The published workbook is understood as an "input" rather than an "output." It aims at redefining the dominant understanding of "impact" in our current systems of evaluation that is often based merely on a logic of calculation. The project proposes to reassess the instituted taxonomy of values within learning and teaching and research at the art academy. It asks what would happen if we valued and gave formal merit to the processes and ways of how we publish. The project inquires how open, enabling, and diverse are our knowledge practices, how inclusive are our tools and protocols by practically examining the moments, formats, and temporalities when knowledge is "practiced" at the art academy.  More broadly, this experiment scrutinizes how institutional habits, such as formats of how we meet, the terminologies we use, the procurement procedures we are asked to follow, and the forms of "outcomes" that are expected, enable or hinder collective and inclusive critical knowledge practices.
 
  
−
{{Interlink|Boxing_and_Unboxing|see Project: Boxing and Unboxing}}
+
{{Interlink|Project_2_*_Library_of_Inclusions_and_Omissions|see project 2*Library of Inclusions and Omissions}}
−
'''Boxing and Unboxing''', a collaboration with artist Rosalie Schweiker, took place in the course of AND Publishing's six-month research residency at Marabouparken Konsthall in Stockholm and consisted of learning how to box and unbox. It deals, therefore, again with questions of categorization and cutting up boxes, as Rhani Lee Remedes suggests in the "Manifesto for cutting up boxes." (Rhani Lee Remedes, 'Society for cutting up boxes', The SCUB Manifesto, 2002) Together with curator Jenny Richards AND organized a boxing club for self-defining women. The question was whether sparring, when defined as physical play and not as competition, might allow us to rehearse ways to relate to each other in other areas. The experiment conceived boxing not as a concept of masculinity and violence or the survival of the fittest, but as a moment of intense negotiation of border space, contagion, and border linking (Ettinger 2006). The boxing renders permeable the borderlines of our "proper" subjects (an "individual" conceived as founded in the sole ownership of oneself). As a nonverbal bodily dialogue, it transgresses the very boundaries that we elsewhere seek to protect. During sparring, I deliberately forgo this established immunity – my contours become vulnerable through the mutuality of the touch: My fist touches and is being touched at the same time. In the reflection, I will connect thoughts about immunity and community (Esposito, 2010; Lorey, 2013) to the exhilarating, troubling, and demanding experiences that the sparring during the boxing sessions produced. I will reflect in which way sparring as a radical bodily dialogue could be a method to learn to compete without needing to win and to disagree with respect.
+
The <b>Library of Inclusions and Omissions</b> (2016) is a practice-based experiment in critical knowledge infrastructures. Setting up a community-run reading room around intersectional feminist and decolonial materials, the project explores the politics (potentials and limitations) of libraries, online and physical, for accessing, activating, and disseminating knowledge. Defining the library as a knowledge infrastructure (Mattern, 2014), the project tests dominant policies of validation (access) and classification (organization). Furthermore, it investigates the difference between a community-run resource such as this and more institutional libraries, in terms of their selection and validation processes. With the Library of Inclusions and Omissions, I seek to develop a curatorial concept to give voice to hidden, suppressed, or unacknowledged materials and struggles. In what ways could such a curatorial strategy thereby turn the library from a repository of knowledge (Samek 2003, Springer 2015) into a space of social and intellectual encounter and action? Can such a library project help build a community or connect different communities?
 +
<br/><br/>
 +
{{Interlink|Project_3_*_The_Piracy_Project|see project 3*The Piracy Project}}
 +
The <b>Piracy Project</b> (2010–15), based in London, is a long-term collaboration with Peruvian artist Andrea Francke. It explores dominant understandings of authorship, originality, and the implications of intellectual property and copyright policies for knowledge practices. Through an open call for pirated books and our research into pirate book markets in Peru, China, and Turkey, The Piracy Project gathered a collection of around 150 copied, emulated, appropriated and modified books from across the world. Their copying approaches vary widely, from playful strategies of reproduction, modification, and reinterpretation of existing works, to circumventing enclosures such as censorship or market monopolies, to acts of piracy generated by commercial interests. Through temporary reading rooms, workshops, lectures, discussions, and debates, The Piracy Project explores the philosophical, legal, and social implications of cultural piracy. In this project, Andrea and I examine the ways in which the pirated, modified, emulated books in the collection transgress normative concepts of authorization, challenging the idea of individual authorship and the assumed authority of the printed book. In the theorization of this project, I will show how the project's unauthorized interventions into "stable" and authoritative knowledge reveal and undo the reciprocity between authorship, originality and intellectual property – a triangulation that, as I will demonstrate, constitutes one of the main blockages for collective knowledge practices.
 +
<br/><br/>
 +
{{Interlink|Project_4_*_Let%27s_Mobilize:_What_is_Feminist_Pedagogy%3F|see project 4*Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?}}
 +
<b>Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?</b> (2015–16) is a collective investigation into intersectional feminist pedagogies, that led to (i) the organization of a three-day international mobilization at HDK-Valand Academy of Art and Design (at the time Valand Art Academy), University of Gothenburg<ref name="Valand change of name" /> and (ii) the publishing of a workbook with the same title. It began from a working group that formed at the Academy consisting of students, staff, and administrators (Kanchan Burathoki, Rose Borthwick, MC Coble, Andreas Engman, Gabo Camnitzer, Eva Weinmayr). The group’s aim was twofold. Firstly, to provide a space to discuss the highs and lows in our own learning and teaching and to study and review university policies and institutional habits. Secondly, to organize an international conference (mobilization) to fundamentally rethink how knowledge is produced, transmitted, and disseminated. We were keen to find strategies to address the Eurocentric canon and its exclusions, to question institutional habits and procedures, and to create an understanding of equality that is not blind to difference. The mobilization itself was a practice-based investigation experimenting with non-normative uses of the classroom, paying attention to time and temporalities, languages, and the empirical body.
 +
The published workbook is understood as an "input" rather than an "output." It aims at a redefinition of the dominant understanding of "impact" in current systems of academic evaluation – an understanding often based on a reductive logic of calculation. The project proposes to reassess the instituted taxonomy of values within learning, teaching and research at the art academy. It asks what would happen if we valued and gave formal credit to all the knowledges and processes involved in how we publish. The project asks how open, enabling, and diverse our knowledge practices are; and how inclusive are our tools and protocols? It does so by practically examining the moments, formats, and temporalities of how knowledge is "practiced" within the art academy.  More broadly, this experiment scrutinizes how institutional habits – how we meet, the terminologies we use, the procurement procedures we are asked to follow, the forms of "outcomes" that are expected – enable or hinder collective and inclusive critical knowledge practices.
 +
<br/><br/>
 +
{{Interlink|Project_5_*_Boxing_and_Unboxing|see project 5*Boxing and Unboxing}}
 +
<b>Boxing and Unboxing</b>, a collaboration with artist Rosalie Schweiker, took place during the course of AND Publishing's six-month research residency at Marabouparken konsthall in Stockholm. It consisted of learning how to "box" and "unbox", and cutting up boxes – dealing with questions of categorization inspired by Rhani Lee Remedes's (2002) "SCUB Manifesto: Society for cutting up boxes". Together with curator Jenny Richards, AND organized a boxing club for self-identifying women. The question was whether sparring, when defined as physical play and not as competition, might allow us to rehearse ways to relate to each other in other areas. The experiment conceived of boxing not in terms of masculinity and violence or the survival of the fittest, but as a moment of intense negotiation of border space, contagion, and border linking (Ettinger 2006). In this sense, boxing renders permeable the borderlines of our "proper" subjects (an "individual" conceived as founded in the sole ownership of oneself). As a nonverbal bodily dialogue, it transgresses boundaries that we elsewhere seek to protect. During sparring, I deliberately forgo this established immunity – my contours become vulnerable through the mutuality of the touch: my fist touches and is being touched at the same time. In the reflection on this project, I connect thoughts about immunity and community (Esposito, 2010; Lorey, 2013) to the exhilarating, troubling, and demanding experiences that the sparring sessions produced. I will reflect on sparring as a radical bodily dialogue, considering its potential for learning how to compete without needing to win, and how to practice respectful disagreement.
  
−
This variety of projects, with their diversity of sites and strategies, might seem incoherent. But as Chantal Mouffe already noted, the fact that "the globalized space is 'striated', with a diversity of sites where relations of power are articulated in specific local, regional and national configurations" means that it requires a variety of strategies. (On the Political" p.114). Mouffe describes this as "a counter-hegemonic struggle", "a process involving a multiplicity of ruptures". (Mouffe, in Errejón and Mouffe, Podemos, 40). I am cautious with the term "counter-hegemonic", since the binary implicit in "counter" simplifies (i) the multi-layered infra-actions at play in the practice itself (collective, transversal), and (ii) the complexities of the contexts in which they operate. But Mouffe helps to argue for the plurality of forms and approaches in my practice that respond to specific issues across a number of different sites: art, education, activism, institutions, culture, business, politics, technology, and media.  
+
This variety of projects, sites and strategies is important as part of a wider strategy of feminist publishing that operates in different arenas and reaches beyond traditional notions of publication. As Chantal Mouffe (2005, 114) has noted, "the globalized space is 'striated', with a diversity of sites where relations of power are articulated in specific local, regional and national configurations," highlighting the need for a variety of strategies. Mouffe describes this as "a counter-hegemonic struggle", "a process involving a multiplicity of ruptures" (Errejón and Mouffe 2016, 40).
 +
I am cautious to use the term "counter-hegemonic" since the binary implicit in "counter" simplifies (i) the multi-layered infra-actions at play in the practice itself (collective, transversal), and (ii) the complexities of the contexts in which they operate. But Mouffe helps to argue for the plurality of forms and approaches in my practice that respond to specific issues across a number of different sites: art, education, activism, institutions, culture, business, politics, technology, and media.  
  
−
This inquiry is situated in a Western context (modernity, possessive individualism, neo-liberal subject). As a White European female subject, I move between practices, institutions and discourses mostly across Europe and North America. It is here where I investigate the micropolitics of knowledge practices informed by concepts found in feminist theory, media theory, radical pedagogy, as well as social science and philosophy.  
+
This inquiry is situated within a Western context and – as will emerge in the analysis and theorization of the projects – it is situated with respect to such overarching constructs as colonial modernity, possessive individualism, and the neoliberal subject. As a White European female subject, I move between practices, institutions and discourses mostly within Europe and North America. It is from this position that I investigate the micro-politics of knowledge practices, informed by concepts found in feminist theory, media theory, radical pedagogy, as well as social science and philosophy.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
  
−
=Authorship, authorization, authority: the questions=
+
==Authorship, authorization, authority: the questions==
−
I started with a range of observations and questions that kept moving and changing during this research. Drawing upon Gabriel Tarde's proposition that knowledge is a mode of socialization and "social communication" (1928), I set out to investigate publication as a social and pedagogical – and as such a political process –  that catalyzes dialogue and generates proposals to intervene in social processes and structures. I asked what is the relationship between "making" and "making public"? Between experience and articulation? How does the "outside space" (distribution) shape the "inside space" of publication (content) and vice versa? How can publishing create spaces, in the figurative and physical sense, for better mutual understanding and rethinking relations between people? "Thinking with" Donna Haraway, I wondered what the ecologies of compost, the "feeding, digesting, excreting",  what "thinking with" rather than "thinking about" would entail for publishing practices. "Being populated" by Claire Parnet and Gilles Deleuze, I tried to figure out what "populate" and "being populated by others" could mean for authorial practices and systems of attribution.
 
  
−
I asked if I understood publishing as a verb (the process) instead as a noun (the finished object) could practice itself be seen as a form of publishing. What kind of "public" and which "publics" does a process of publishing require? So for example: Is a teaching situation a form of publishing? A workshop, where knowledge is collectively produced and disseminated at the same time? When we think of the collaborative as a situation, scene, process, dynamic, method, or mode, can we frame such a situation as "publishing"? What is contextual publishing? Is publishing necessarily always tied to a document, whether scriptural, a film, a drawing, a photograph? What is a document? I have been chewing on French librarian and documentalist Suzanne Briet (Bibliothèque Nationale de France) reply to this question. In her study "Qu'est-ce que la documentation?" (1951), she proposes that an antelope running wild in the Savannah is considered as an animal, yet a wild antelope captured, brought to Europe to be exhibited in the zoo, caged, described, measured, and classified is being turned into a document.<ref name=" Briet"/> It is analyzed, described, categorized, classified, and exhibited as a specimen, a process that constitutes a key paradigm to the colonial Modern Project.
+
I started this PhD research with a range of observations and questions based on my practice to date. These initial questions were refined through the internal logic of a multifaceted inquiry – they moved, opened up, got destabilized a little.{{Annotation|Delicious}} Through thinking embedded in practice, the multiple ways of doing things, and the different entry points I found, I came to reframe, re-describe, and refine the initial problems and assumptions of my inquiry.
  
−
In short, my initial presumption that publishing is an outright positive and constructive act, a tool of giving voice and developing emancipatory agency has been challenged. I am much more doubtful today. Institutional pressure (publish or perish) seems to erode practice based on agency, creativity, criticality, experimentation, and collective knowledge making. Publishing (and writing) in institutional or semi-institutional contexts has been arguably reduced from a process of communication, discovery, and exploration, to a system for the assembly of more and more new products, merely based on a logic of calculation. (Fitzpatrick, 2011) Rebekka Kiesewetter observes that "the significance of a publication is often reduced to a consumable or proof of excellence and a claim for authority; and publishing activities mostly are pursued within an output-led environment, in which the suggested formats and the institutional, economic and procedural frames tempt the interpretation of every outcome, every representation as vessels for contents, static, backward-looking, absolute, finalized, and set." <ref name="Rebekka 1"/> Several points are raised here. Firstly it points to systems of validation and audit culture, secondly to the staticity of the "finite" object and thirdly to the authority these discrete objects produce.
+
Drawing upon Gabriel Tarde's proposition that knowledge is a mode of socialization and social communication (1903)<ref name="Tarde"/>  I set out to investigate publication as a social, pedagogical, and political process. How can publishing create spaces for better mutual understanding and rethinking relations between people?  What is the relationship between "making" and "making public"? Between experience and articulation? How does the "outside space" (distribution) shape the "inside space" of publication (content) and vice versa? What is contextual publishing? Is publishing necessarily always tied to a document, whether it be the printed page or via other media such as film, drawing, or photography? What is a document?
 +
In her study <i>Qu'est-ce que la documentation?</i> (1951) the French librarian and pioneer of information science Suzanne Briet describes as follows: an antelope running wild in the Savannah is considered an animal, yet through being captured and brought to Europe to be exhibited in the zoo – through being caged, described, measured, and classified – the animal is turned into a document.<ref name=" Briet"/> It is analyzed, described, categorized, classified, and exhibited as a specimen, a process that constitutes a key paradigm to the project of colonial modernity. <ref name=" Colonial-Modernity"/>
  
−
These three topics form the main "blockages," as I will argue, for emancipatory, collective knowledge practices. With these three building blocks, I wrestled practically and theoretically throughout this inquiry, each with different entry points and from different perspectives.  
+
In short, this challenges the initial presumption that publishing is an outright positive and progressive act, a tool of giving voice and developing emancipatory agency. The research process (making, thinking and analyzing) put this idea into question and made it necessary to rethink the operating assumptions of the inquiry. Institutional pressure (publish or perish), for example, can erode the conditions for practices based on agency, creativity, criticality, experimentation, and collective knowledge making. Publishing (and writing) in institutional or semi-institutional contexts has been arguably "reduced from a process of communication, discovery, and exploration, to a system for the assembly of more and more new products, merely based on a logic of calculation."<ref name="Fitzpatrick1"/> Rebekka Kiesewetter (2019) observes that "the significance of a publication is often reduced to a consumable or proof of excellence and a claim for authority; and publishing activities mostly are pursued within an output-led environment, in which the suggested formats and the institutional, economic and procedural frames tempt the interpretation of every outcome, every representation as vessels for contents, static, backward-looking, absolute, finalized, and set." Several points are raised here: firstly, it points to systems of validation and audit culture; secondly, to the stasis of the "finite" object; and thirdly, to the authority these discrete objects produce.  
−
To be more specific: I set out to explore the coercive mutual reciprocity between authorship, authorization, and authority.  
 
  
−
In this sense, this inquiry seeks to get to insight, to make a discovery by moving from a vague apprehension of these three terms' mutual interactions to a clearer framing of their "coercive reciprocation." So the result of this inquiry could be described as the development of an insight as well as potential models for emancipatory, critical, intersectional feminist and de-colonial models of knowledge "making and sharing".
+
As I will argue, these three topics form the main "blockages" for emancipatory, collective knowledge practices. I wrestled with these blockages practically and theoretically throughout this inquiry, each with different entry points and from different perspectives. To be more specific: as the inquiry developed it became clearer that I set out to explore the coercive mutual reciprocity between authorship, authorization, and authority. In this sense, this inquiry seeks to move from a vague apprehension of these three terms' mutual interaction to a clearer framing of their "coercive reciprocation." The result of this inquiry could be described as the development of this insight alongside potential models for emancipatory, critical, intersectional feminist models of knowledge "making and sharing". In practice, doing things, one gets caught in tensions, paradoxes, and double binds. These double binds may become frozen or locked, especially if one stays at the level of writing, or thinking, or talking about it. As soon as one involves multiple ways of tackling the issue practically, experimenting with different ways of doing, it is often possible to find new resources with which to rethink the way the problem is set. By implementing these different experiments I began to refine the description of the problems in terms of the described set of blockages and their reciprocal interaction.
  
−
The majority of this work was conducted from 2010 onwards between the United Kingdom and Sweden. And a lot of policy context references are specifically UK policy context, for example, the REF. However, this might be taken as indicative of general tendencies in higher education and research elsewhere.
+
The majority of this work was conducted between the United Kingdom and Sweden, 2010–20. A significant amount of the policy referenced in this inquiry is specific to the UK, where I spent the majority of my "university life". The UK may also be taken as indicative of wider tendencies in higher education and research elsewhere – the UK started early on with an explicit formulation of the changing agenda in higher education and research, in the form of the Research Excellence Framework (REF), for example,<ref name= "UK REF"/> reflecting the broader shift towards a culture of audit and metrics.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
  
−
= "Thinking with": the format =
+
=="Thinking with": the format==
  
−
The format I choose for this Ph.D. inquiry is a compilation thesis, comprising a distinct set of practical experiments and the "kappa" (Swedish, translated to English "coat").{{Annotation|Kappa}} The kappa is what you are reading here on this wiki. The purpose of the kappa is to disclose the contribution made by the research project and to locate that contribution with reference to existing knowledge-practices.
+
The format I choose for this PhD inquiry is a compilation thesis, comprising a distinct set of practical experiments and a "kappa" (Swedish, translated to English as "cape" or "coat").{{Annotation|Kappa}} The kappa is what you are reading now, on this wiki. The purpose of the kappa is to disclose the contribution made by the research project and to locate that contribution with reference to existing knowledge practices.
−
In Swedish academia, the kappa is understood as a coat, a cape, a wrapper that bundles, connects, discusses, and reflects on the range of experiments I have carried out without turning them into one single integral entity, as does the other option, the monograph. The kappa is meant to allow the components to retain their discrete, self-contained identities, but joining them as elements of a larger construction. Potentially, as Gary Hall pointed out in one of my Ph.D. Progression Seminars, one could think of all the different elements of a coat: the sleeves, the collar, the lining, the buttons, all stitched together to form a larger construction. Here it would be interesting to think about the nature of the joints. Still, both metaphors seem not to be reflected in how I worked with this inquiry. The stitching together of the different parts still suggests a unified whole, the coat, and the other, the formless cape, the wrapper suggests an enclosure that shields the different parts from the outside.  
+
In Swedish academia, the kappa is understood as an outer layer that bundles, connects, discusses, and reflects on its contents. I use the kappa as a way to engage with the range of experiments I have carried out, without turning them into a monolithic entity (as can happen with a monograph, the typical format for a doctoral submission). The kappa is meant to allow the components to retain their discrete, self-contained identities, but also to enable them to be joined together as elements of a larger construction. As Gary Hall pointed out in an earlier discussion of the work in progress, one could think of all the different elements of a coat: the sleeves, the collar, the lining, the buttons, all stitched together to form a larger construction. (Here it could be interesting to think about the nature of the joints.) But these metaphors still do not reflect exactly how I worked in this inquiry. The stitching together of different parts suggests a unified whole – the coat – and the formless cape or wrapper suggests an enclosure that shields the different parts from the outside.  
−
Perhaps Ursula Le Guin's "carrier bag theory" is more fitting? The vessel, Le Guin suggests, is mankind's earliest tool, not the spear, as often claimed. "A leaf a gourd a shell a net a bag a sling a sack a bottle a pot a box a container. A holder. A recipient. [...] Since "what's the use of digging up a lot of potatoes if you have nothing to lug the ones you can't eat home in - with or before the tool that forces energy outward, we made a tool that brings energy home." The only problem is, as Le Guin notes, that a carrier bag story isn't, at first glance, very exciting. "It is hard to tell a really gripping tale of how I wrested a wild-oat seed from its husk, and then another, and then another, and then another, and then another, and then I scratched my gnat bites, and Ool said something funny, and we went to the creek and got a drink and watched newts for a while, and then I found another patch of oats…" <ref name= "Le Guin"/> As well as its wandering narrative, a carrier bag story contains no heroes. Instead, as Siobhan Leddy observes, there are "many different protagonists with equal importance to the plot [...] and the bag's inside is messy and sometimes conflicted. Like when you're trying to grab your sunglasses out of your bag, but those are stuck on your headphones, which are also tangled around your keys, and now the sunglasses have slipped into that hole in the lining. This lack of clear trajectory allowed Le Guin to test out all kinds of political eventualities, without the need to tie everything neatly together. It makes room for complexity and contradiction, for difference and simultaneity." <ref name="Siobhan Leddy" />
+
Perhaps Ursula Le Guin's "carrier bag theory" is more fitting? The vessel, Le Guin suggests, is mankind's earliest tool – not the spear, as often claimed. "A leaf a gourd a shell a net a bag a sling a sack a bottle a pot a box a container. A holder. A recipient. [...] what's the use of digging up a lot of potatoes if you have nothing to lug the ones you can't eat home in – with or before the tool that forces energy outward, we made a tool that brings energy home." The only problem, as Le Guin notes, is that a carrier bag story is not at first glance very exciting. "It is hard to tell a really gripping tale of how I wrested a wild-oat seed from its husk, and then another, and then another, and then another, and then another, and then I scratched my gnat bites, and Ool said something funny, and we went to the creek and got a drink and watched newts for a while, and then I found another patch of oats…" (Le Guin 1996). As well as its wandering narrative, a carrier bag story contains no heroes. Instead, as Siobhan Leddy (2019) observes, there are  
 +
::many different protagonists with equal importance to the plot [...] and the bag's inside is messy and sometimes conflicted. Like when you're trying to grab your sunglasses out of your bag, but those are stuck on your headphones, which are also tangled around your keys, and now the sunglasses have slipped into that hole in the lining. This lack of clear trajectory allowed Le Guin to test out all kinds of political eventualities, without the need to tie everything neatly together. It makes room for complexity and contradiction, for difference and simultaneity.
  
−
I have been thinking a lot about protagonists in this narrative, in this Ph.D.. Since most of the practices are collaborations, I saw the danger that It will be solely me who is narrating them, who is framing them, and to an extent historicizing them from my perspective alone. I have been struggling with differentiating the "I" and the "we" throughout this writing and thinking; they are often difficult to disentangle. This "I" also shifts, is not stable, perhaps incoherent, because it has been populated by others while working and thinking together.
+
I have been thinking a lot about protagonists in this narrative, in this PhD. Since most of the practices are collaborations, I saw a danger in the fact that it will be mostly me who is narrating, framing, and to an extent historicizing them from my perspective alone. The struggle was to differentiate the "I" and the "we" throughout this writing and thinking; they are often difficult to disentangle. This "I" also shifts, is not stable, perhaps incoherent, because it has been populated by others while working and thinking together.
  
−
I have also been thinking a lot about tools and "containers" for this kappa, and how the tools I use, shape the way I write and read. After one year into the writing, and after meeting folks from Constant at a three-day research meeting in Basel <ref name= "Constant at Creating Commons"/>, I decided to drop the solitary word document on my hard disk and continue in the form of a Wiki. <ref name= "MediaWiki"/> This for me was a "paradigm shift" from the protected, private and proprietary environment of my hard disk to a web-based, open, and some extent "public" environment of my tentatively thinking, writing and archiving. There were moments of anxiety when I shared the URL knowing that lots of stuff are not resolved, not thought through or tentatively worded. But it felt important to share this process because it created dialogues and conversations. It was still cooking, and lots of precious ingredients have been added by others through these conversations - only because it was open and accessible throughout.
+
I have also been thinking a lot about tools and "containers" for this kappa, and how the tools shape the way I write and read. After one year of writing, and after meeting Femke Snelting and Michael Murtaugh from Constant at a three-day research meeting in Basel, I decided to drop the solitary Word document on my hard disk and continue in the form of a MediaWiki.<ref name= "MediaWiki"/> This for me was a "paradigm shift" from the protected, private and proprietary environment of my hard disk to a web-based, open, and "public" environment for my tentative thinking, writing and archiving. There were moments of anxiety when I shared the URL, knowing that lots of things were unresolved, not thought through or tentatively worded. But it felt important to share this process because it created dialogues and conversations. It was always cooking, and lots of precious ingredients have been added by others throughout these conversations – only because it was open and accessible throughout.
  
−
One specific tool that had been coded by Cristina Cochior and Manetta Berends from Varia (Rotterdam) is the annotation feature. It is used by the folks in the various collaborations. So far, Andrea Francke (Piracy Project), Andreas Engman, MC Coble (Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?), and Rosalie Schweiker (AND, Boxing and Unboxing) have added anecdotes, thoughts, observations on working with these specific projects.  
+
One specific tool that had been coded by Cristina Cochior and Manetta Berends from Varia (Rotterdam) is the annotation feature.{{Annotation|Feedback loop}} It is used by the folks in the various collaborations. So far, Andrea Francke (Piracy Project), Andreas Engman, MC Coble (Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?), and Rosalie Schweiker (AND, Boxing and Unboxing) have added anecdotes, thoughts, and observations about working with these specific projects. In working together, there are always assumptions, motivations, and misunderstandings that are not necessarily articulated while plotting and "doing stuff". Strangely, you often assume that everyone else thinks the same as you do. Therefore, the annotation feature invites the collaborators to comment, add, and disagree with my accounts of the projects. And as such, it turns the thesis from an authoritative text into an occasion for negotiation, disagreement, and consultation. This approach is not a "writing up," but an experiment in itself. Lastly, this work is not locked up in a scholarly monograph in a university collection, but accessible via the internet – opening up its readership beyond those having access or are inclined to visit European university libraries (Cusicanqui 2011). This also means it is open to feed back into communities outside academia, in which most of the activities developed and are grounded in.<ref name= "Charlotte Cooper"/> And as such, it tries to avoid extractive economies that are addressed in Appendix 2*Interview with Femke Snelting.{{Interlink|Appendix_2*Interview_with_Femke_Snelting|see appendix 2*Interview with Femke Snelting}}
−
Since, when you work together, there is always a range of assumptions, motivations, and misunderstandings that are not necessarily articulated while plotting and "doing stuff". Strangely, you often assume that everyone else thinks the same as you do. Therefore, the annotation feature invites the collaborators to comment, add, disagree with my account of the processes and steps that made up the projects. And as such, it turns the thesis from constituting an authoritative text into an occasion of negotiation, disagreement, and consultation. This approach is not a "writing up", but an experiment in itself. Lastly, this work is not locked up in a scholarly monograph in a university library, but openly accessible, if someone has access to the internet. This is key for folks who don't have access or just don't visit Western university libraries. <ref name= "Cusiquanci"/> This openness allows for feeding back something into the communities outside of academia in which most parts of the activities developed and are grounded in. (see Charlotte Cooper Research Justice Diagram) And as such tries to avoid extractive economies that Femke Snelting addresses in the transcribed conversation "xxxtitle to come".{{Interlink|LINK|see conversation with Femke Snelting}}
+
<br/>
 +
<br/>
  
−
=Roadmap=
+
==Roadmap==
  
−
The kappa is structured in 14 sections. It is important to note that the kappa is not the final or only form of disclosure. It is a device being used to disclose the practice to meet the terms of a doctoral exam process – the work does circulate more widely in the world in other wrappers (carrier bags) and on different terms.  
+
The kappa, the textual format that synthesizes and summarizes the contribution made by the PhD research project, is structured in 6 chapters plus appendices. It is important to note that the kappa is not the final or only form of disclosure. The kappa is a device being used to disclose the practice to meet the terms of a doctoral examination process – the work also circulates more widely in the world in other wrappers (carrier bags) and on different terms.  
−
It will be useful to explain the different layers of the text you are reading on this wiki.  
+
It will be useful to explain the different layers of text you are reading on this wiki.  
−
The main text body (black) is the text I have written. It has a substantial '''notes section''' at the bottom of each wiki page that operates as a parallel layer to the main text. I wanted to keep the main text crisp and easy to follow. Therefore lots of detailed info, unpacking of specific terms or concepts takes place in the Notes section.
+
The main body text (black) is the text I have written. It has a substantial '''notes section''' at the bottom of each chapter that operates as a parallel layer to the main text. I wanted to keep the main text concise and easy to follow. Therefore, lots of more detailed information, and unpacking of specific terms or concepts takes place in the notes.
−
The left-hand column is the '''navigation menu''' that brings you to the individual pages (chapters). It does the same job as the index page but is easier to use since it stays visible on each page. In the right-hand column, you will find '''annotations''' by persons I collaborated with in the practice projects, and peers, friends, and colleagues who were thinking with me during this inquiry. These annotations vary between textual comments and visual comments{{Annotation|Carrier bag}} since not everyone felt that text is the medium they can best express themselves.  
+
The left-hand column is the <b>navigation menu</b> that brings you to the individual pages (chapters). It does the same job as the index page but is easier to use since it stays visible on each page. In the right-hand column, you will find '''annotations''' by persons I collaborated with in the projects, as well as peers, friends, and colleagues who were thinking with me during this inquiry. These annotations vary between textual comments and visual comments, since not everyone felt that text is the medium with which they can best express themselves.  
  
−
(2) The '''Introduction''' gives an overview of what the inquiry is about, of the basic research task, agenda, and purpose. It lays out the context, the problems I will address the questions I started with. It also gives info on how the wiki is structured and how it can be read.
+
The page <b>About this wiki</b> explains the purpose of this Mediawiki as constituting the submission of a Doctoral thesis leading to the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Artistic Practice. It also contains the abstract.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<b> Chapter 01*Contents</b> presents the table of contents of this kappa.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<b> Chapter 02*Setting</b> gives an overview of what the inquiry is about – of the basic research task, agenda, and purpose. It lays out the context, the problems I will address, and the questions I started with. It also gives information on how the wiki is structured and how it can be read.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<b> Chapter 03*Survey of the field</b> presents and discusses practices, movements, and concepts that others have developed. These examples are spread widely in terms of geography and history, and they draw on a wide range of disciplinary frames and epochs. This broad approach stems from a commitment to work transversally and not to be bound by the protocols of one field alone – such as contemporary art or feminist organizational practices or radical education. The examples I have chosen are all instances where the dominant paradigms of publishing and the formation of knowledge have been in one way or another adjusted, acting as declared counter-political projects. This chapter also maps a network of relationships, since I have been working with some of the discussed projects in the form of workshops, seminars, talks, friendships, and other moments of thinking and doing together.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<b> Chapter 04*Summary of projects & submitted material</b> provides a short factual description of the submitted material to make explicit the projects and activities that form the basis of the contribution made by this research project. It details five long-term practice projects, and includes published (fixed) materials, such as articles, chapters, papers, and ephemera as well as discursive (unfixed) practices describing the workshops, talks, and moments of "thinking with" that constitute not an "outcome" but a practice.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
Each of the <b> Project pages (1–5)</b> describes one of the five practice projects in more detail. They break down the context that each project responded to or intervened in. They also give a step-by-step sketch of their main elements, methods, and strategies employed. The five practice projects are: '''AND''' (1); '''Library of Omission and Inclusions''' (2); '''The Piracy Project''' (3); '''Let's Mobilize what is Feminist Pedagogy?''' (4); and '''Boxing and Unboxing''' (5). All of these projects are collaborations and developed over time.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<b>Chapter 05*Reflection and theorization of projects and submitted material</b> provides a more in-depth and extended reflection on the projects and experiments I have carried out. This is provided to disclose the significance and importance of the contribution made by the research project. It discusses the complexities and contradictions of each of the practice projects individually and articulates their underlying concepts and theories.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
Building on the reflection and theorization of the five practice projects, the <b> chapter 06*Analysis</b> zooms in on the micro-politics of knowledge practices and crystalizes a range of topics that surfaced throughout the projects. Touching on the politics of citation and experimental authorial practices, I analyze the experiment of writing this thesis in the form of a MediaWiki – as a way that practically experiments with some of the claims made.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<b>07*References</b> lists the resources that have informed the practices, thinking and writing of this research. It goes, therefore, beyond a strict list of "cited sources" since it includes materials that have informed my practice indirectly. Where possible, I have linked directly to sources or uploaded them to this wiki database. As such, this section also extends beyond a typical bibliography and operates partly as an archive.{{Annotation|Carrier bag}}
  
−
(3) The page '''Mapping the fields''' presents and discusses practices, movements, concepts that others have developed. These examples are spread widely in terms of geography and history, and they draw on a wide range of disciplinary frames and epochs. This broad field of sampling stems from a commitment to work transversally and not to be bound by the protocols of one field alone – such as contemporary art or feminist organizational practices or radical education. They are all instances where the dominant paradigms of publishing and the formation of knowledge have been in one way or another adjusted, acting as declared counter-political projects. This page also maps a network of relationships since I have been working with some of the discussed projects in the form of workshops, seminars, talks, friendships, or other moments of thinking and doing together.
 
  
−
(4) The '''Summary of projects & submitted material''' provides a short factual description of the submitted material to make explicit the material through which the contribution has been made. They include five long-term practice projects, the published (fixed) materials, such as articles, chapters, papers, and ephemera as well as the discursive (unfixed) practices describing the workshops, talks, moments of "thinking with" that constitute not an "outcome", but a practice.
+
<b>08*My integrated circuit</b> acknowledges the collaborative effort of this research project.
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
The appendices present further materials that did not fit within the index structure above.<br/>
 +
<b>Appendix*01: Let's Mobilize Revisited</b> presents a collaborative writing experiment with multi-layered commentary, conducted by Rose Borthwick, Andreas Engman, MC Coble, Eva Weinmayr in 2017.<br/>
 +
<b>Appendix*02: Interview: Femke Snelting, Eva Weinmayr, March 24–25, 2020 (Resolutions are always temporary)</b> features an interview with Femke Snelting (Constant, Brussels).<br/>
 +
<b>Appendix*03: Rosalie's Visual Comments</b> collects the visual annotations that Rosalie Schweiker produced for this kappa in 2020.<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
 
 +
==Notes (Setting)==
 +
 
 +
<references>
 +
<ref name= "knowledge">Without presenting a premature definition of knowledge, a short insert is needed here to point out that knowledge is connected to an apparatus of legitimization that is discussed and problematized in the following chapters. The term "acknowledging" points towards a dialogical and relational act, to acknowledge means "I see you". To acknowledge is an act of recognizing, of interacting "with other people’s worlds" in the words of Maria Lugones (2003, Introduction):
 +
::By traveling to other people’s “worlds,” we discover that there are “worlds” in which those who are the victims of arrogant perception are really subjects, lively beings, resisters, constructors of visions even though in the mainstream construction they are animated only by the arrogant perceiver and are pliable, foldable, file-awayable, classifiable. I always imagine the Aristotelian slave as pliable and foldable at night or after he or she cannot work anymore (when he or she dies as a tool). Aristotle tells us nothing about the slave apart from the master. We know the slave only through the master. The slave is a tool of the master. After working hours, he or she is folded and placed in a drawer until the next morning.</ref>
  
−
Each of the '''Project''' pages (5-9) describes one of the five practice projects in more detail. They break down the context of each project they responded to or intervene in. They also sketch out step by step their elements, methods, and strategies employed. They are '''AND''' (5), '''Library of Omission and Inclusions''' (6), '''The Piracy Project''' (7), '''Let's Mobilize what is Feminist Pedagogy?''' (8), '''Boxing and Unboxing''' (9). All of these practices are collaborations and developed over time.
 
  
−
(10) The page '''Reflection, theorization of projects and submitted material''' provides more depth in reflecting the projects and experiments I have carried out. This part is provided to disclose the significance and importance of the contribution made by the research project. This is a long chapter that discusses the complexities and contradictions of each of the practice projects individually and articulates its underlying concepts and theories.
 
  
−
(11) Building on the reflection and theorization of the five practice projects, the page '''Analysis''' zooms into the micro-politics knowledge practices more broadly with a focus on the scholarly field. Touching on the politics of citational practices, experimental authorial practices, a redefinition of inputs and outputs, I analyze this experiment in thesis writing on a wiki that practically tests and experiments with some of the claims made.  
+
<ref name= "public sphere"> The idea of public that I have in mind is not one that is built on Habermas's concept of the bourgeois public sphere (Habermas 1962), because it does not differentiate between <i> a </i> public and <i> the </i> public. Michael Warner (2003) describes <i> the </i> public as "a kind of social totality, the people in general" and <i> a </i> public as a concrete audience, "a crowd witnessing itself in visible space, as with a theatrical public. Such a public also has a sense of totality, bounded by the event or by the shared physical space". Also Nancy Fraser’s sense of “counterpublic” (Fraser 1997) seems problematic since a counter-public presupposes a universalizing concept of the bourgeois mainstream public that it can oppose, that can be "countered".
 +
Similar to Nancy Fraser's concept of counterpublics, María Pía Lara provides an account of counter publicity in subaltern groups and stresses, according to Lugones, that the public address is an "attainment of recognition […] that is addressed not just to subaltern groups, but in a wider direction."(Lugones 2000, 176). In her text "Multiculturalism and Publicity" (2000), Maria Lugones provides a short summary of Lara's argument:
 +
::Dialogue between author and public is necessary for recognition. Engaging the other in an understanding of the ego is crucial here; disclosure is crucial to identity formation. [...] thus, requires public recognition (Lara 1999, 87). Recognition is complete only when “acceptance of the public has taken place” (Lara 1999, 82). If differences are necessary for subjective expansion, their value must be “asserted in front of others” and the dialogue must not only show what makes one different but also that those differences are “part of what should be considered worthy” (Lara 1999, 156, 157). Groups needing to be heard must “conquer channels of communication to call attention to the way they have been treated”; recognition is thus a struggle (Lara 1999, 151, 157). It is their descriptions of what is missing in their lives that make their claims meaningful and understandable to others (Lara 1999, 151). In this case, subaltern publics must aim to reach recognition from both oppressors and oppressed. (Lugones 2000, 179)
 +
Maria Lugones discusses yet another dimension of public and publicity, one that refers to the hidden publics of infrapolitics, that deliberately forgo a publicist address. (On infrapolitics, see Scott 1987 and 1990.) The so-called "hidden transcript," as a dissident political culture in resistance to oppression, does not address the oppressor. Hidden transcripts, therefore are not just "outside 'the master's tools,' but also outside the master's perceptual field and the master's perceptual possibilities." (Lugones 2000, 178).
 +
My use of the term public corresponds to Warner's self-organized public that organizes around a concrete object, occasion (event) or discourse – a publication, for example. This comes close to Matthew Stadler's claim that "publication is the creation of new publics" (Stadler, 2012). Furthermore, the term public in this kappa refers also to public property and accessibility, such as the public domain and open access in contrast to private or corporate ownership.</ref>
  
−
(12) I wrote the '''Acknowledgments''' page in place of a colophon. The complexities of "colophons" are discussed in Appendix 01.
 
  
−
(13) The page '''References''' lists the resources that have informed both practices and thinking and writing. It goes, therefore, beyond the strict "cited sources" task since it includes materials that have indirectly informed my practice. Where possible, I linked to their sources for reading or download or uploaded them directly to this wiki database. As such, this section extends to a degree the concept of bibliography and operates partly as an archive.
+
<ref name= "contemporary art">It may help to briefly explain how these three intersecting terms are employed here, by way of locating the inquiry. "Contemporary art" refers to the broad terrain of art production from the 1960s onward. However, rather than a period designation, it is used here to refer to a broad domain of practice that may be termed "post-representational" (Sternfeld 2018), "post-conceptualist" (Osborne 2010) or "relational" (Bishop 2006). "Radical education" refers to several distinct traditions of educational practice that is explicitly framed with revolutionary or politically transformative intentions and objectives. These traditions include, for example, Paulo Freire's <i>Pedagogy of the Oppressed</i> (Freire 1970) and bell hooks’ writings on intersectional feminist pedagogy, such as <i>Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of Freedom</i> (hooks 1994). Radical pedagogy has been practiced and tested by projects such as the "Anti-University" in London, the artist collective Ultra Red, and Malmö Free University for Women; and it has been theorized for example in the field of art and curating in books such as <i>Curating and the Educational Turn</i> (O'Neill and Wilson 2010) and in the field of higher education in, for instance, <i>The Imperial University: Academic Repression and Scholarly Dissent</i> (Chatterjee and Maira 2014). By "institutional analysis" I am intending not to describe a sub-domain of sociology, organizational studies or political science but rather the intellectual and practical traditions of institutional critique from within the contemporary art field as this intersects with feminist and intersectional analyses of power – which is of course informed by elements drawn from these other disciplines, but manifests a different tendency and different literature. For more on this see <i>Institutions by Artists</i> (Khonsary and Podesva 2012), <i>How Institutions Think</i> (O'Neill, Steeds and Wilson 2017), and the research project <i>Creating Commons</i> (University of the Arts Zürich, 2016–19).</ref>
  
−
(14 - xx) The '''Appendices''' contain sources and materials that did not fit in the index structure above.
 
  
−
Appendix 01 - Thoughts on the colophon
+
<ref name="Modern Project"> The feminist critique of modern epistemologies refers to modernity's claim for abstraction and universalism that originates, in Haraway's words, from a "vision from everywhere and nowhere equally and fully." (Haraway 1988, 584) Boaventura de Sousa Santos summarizes the characteristics of modern epistemologies, which he calls "Epistemologies of the North" as
−
Appendix 02 - Collected Visual Comments by Rosalie Schweiker
+
::(i) the absolute priority of science as rigorous knowledge; (ii) rigor, conceived of as determination; (iii) universalism [...] referring to any entity or condition the validity of which does not depend on any specific social, cultural, or political context; (iv) truth conceived of as the representation of reality; (v) a distinction between subject and object, the knower and the known; (vi) nature as <i> res extensa</i>; (vii) linear time; (viii) the progress of science via the disciplines and specialization; (ix) and social and political neutrality as a condition of objectivity. (de Sousa Santos 2018, 6)</ref>
−
Appendix 03 - "The name Eva Weinmayr..." log.  
+
 
−
Appendix 04 - Interview with Femke Snelting, (Constant)
+
<ref name= "Lugones Pilgrimages 648">For Lugones, streetwalker theorizing implies a "pedestrian view – the perspective from inside the midst of people, from inside the layers of relations and institutions and practices” (Lugones 2003, Introduction) In contrast, the bird’s-eye view promotes "the perspective from up high, planning the town, the takeover, or the analysis of life and history" (Lugones 2003, Introduction). With "streetwalker theorizing" Lugones proposes an active subjective agency (in place of the liberal model of agency) that “does not presuppose the individual subject and it does not presuppose collective intentionality of collectivities of the same. It is adumbrated to consciousness by a <i>moving with</i> people, by the difficulties as well as the concrete possibilities of such movings.” (Introduction, emphasis added). This "moving with" shifts the understanding of agency of individual subjectivity, which is here not ascribed to a single rational actor to formulate and pursue her own conceptions but rather "the oft-impeded, multi-directional efforts of social beings moving within and against power structures." (Chang et al. 2018)</ref>
−
Appendix 05 - Interview with Ann Butler Centre for Curatorial Studies Bard (CCS)
+
 
−
Appendix 06 - Interview with Karen Fletcher, Fine Art Librarian Central Saint Martins (UAL)
+
<ref name= "Santos Cognitive page 54"> From a decolonial perspective, Boaventura de Sousa Santos argues that the concept of the author in Western modernity forms part of the same cluster of idealist philosophies that underlie modern possessive individualism, namely originality, autonomy, and (individual) creativity. Such concepts, he claims, have little validity in the epistemologies of the South (as opposed to the epistemologies of the North, i.e Western modernity) as, "for them, the most relevant knowledges are either immemorial or generated in the social experiences of oppression and the struggles against it. In any case, they are rarely traceable to a single individual. Underlying such knowledges, there are always new or ancient collective experiences." (de Sousa Santos 2018, 54). See also the book chapter "Confronting Authorship, Constructing Practices", in which I discuss prevailing Western assumptions of authorship and ownership based on both property rights and moral rights and the blockages these assumptions create for collective knowledge practices (Weinmayr 2019, 267–307). 
−
Appendix 07 - Interview with Martino Morandi and Anita Burato (Infrastructural Maneuvres)
+
</ref>
−
Appendix 07 - Interview with Mick Wilson (HDK-Valand Academy)
+
 
−
...
+
<ref name= "Constant ongoing"> This citation, without pointing to a specific stabilized publication, might surprise the conventions of academic standards. It refers to a 20-year practice of Brussels-based feminist technology collective Constant, who explore and demonstrate through their practices modes of how "to practically intervene, disrupt and change existing systems of production, distribution, and consumption of knowledge" – a question I raised at the start of this inquiry. See: website "Constant", http://constantvzw.org/site.</ref>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<ref name=" Printed Matter">I took copies of my first two independently published publications – <i>Lery – a story of facts and faxes</i> (1998) and <i>Mexico</i> (1997, with Vera Büchlmann and Joachim Melf) – on my first trip to New York, walked into Printed Matter art book shop and sold them ten copies each on consignment. What an empowering moment – more exciting than any exhibition opportunity I ever had.</ref>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<ref name= "my publications"> Having published with big mainstream commercial publishing houses (Hatje Cantz) as well as small independent presses (Temporary Services, Half-Letter Press, Occasional Papers, Book Works) I got more and more interested in exploring and setting up a publishing infrastructure and subsequently co-founded in 2010, with American artist Lynn Harris, AND Publishing in London (today run with Rosalie Schweiker). </ref>
 +
 
  
−
=Notes Settings=
 
−
<references>
 
−
<ref name= "contemporary art">It may help to briefly explain how these three intersecting terms are employed here by way of locating the inquiry. Contemporary art here refers to the broad terrain of art production from 1960s onward. However, rather than a period designation, it is used here to refer to a broad domain of practice that may be termed "post-representational" (Sternfeld, 2018), "post-conceptualist" (Osborne, 2010) or "relational" (Bishop, 2006). "Radical education" here refers to several distinct traditions of educational practice that is explicitly framed with revolutionary or politically transformative intentions and objectives. These traditions include, for example, Paolo Freire's "Pedagogy of the Oppressed" and bell hooks writings on intersectional feminist pedagogy, such as "Teaching to transgress: education as the practice of freedom" (1994). Radical pedagogy has been practiced and tested by collectives such as the "Anti-University" in London, the artist collective Ultra Red,  Malmö Free University for Women and have been theorized for example in the field of art and curating ("Curating and the educational turn," O'Neill, Wilson, eds., 2010) and in the field of higher education by Piya Chatterjee and Sunaina Maira (eds.) in "The Imperial University" (2014). By "institutional analysis" I am intending not to describe a sub-domain of sociology, organizational studies or political science but rather the intellectual and practical traditions of institutional critique from within the contemporary art field as this intersects with feminist and intersectional analyses of power – which is of course informed by elements drawn from these other disciplines, but manifests a different tendency and a different literature. For more on this see "Institutions by Artists" (Vancouver 2012), "How Institutions Think," (O'Neill, Steeds and Wilson (eds.), 2017), "Creating Commons," University of the Arts Zürich, 2016-19).</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name= "Rebekka 1">Rebekka Kiesewetter, "Publishing as a Processual Device", "Šibenik Alternating Currents - Publishing
 
−
Acts II", published by DAI-SAI (Association of Istrian Architects) and dpr-barcelona under the umbrella of Future Architecture, 2019, page 5.</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name="Adema1">Janneke Adema and Gary Hall, 'The Political Nature Of The Book: On Artists’ Books And Radical Open Access', in ''New Formations'', vol 78, issue 1, 2014, pp. 138-156, p.140, DOI:10.3898/NEWF.78.07.2013</ref>
+
<ref name= "variability monograph"> Of course, within the field of scholarly publishing there is some variability, for instance, the role of the monograph in parts of the humanities in contrast to the role of the double-blind peer review article in some of the medical sciences, or the role of the critical edition in the humanities as against, say, the meta-research analysis paper in the social sciences. In short, there are different scholarly publishing hierarchies and protocols across the disciplines, but the overarching claim is still viable despite this. </ref>
  
−
<ref name="Adema2">Ibid., p.139.</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name="Florian Cramer 1"> Florian Cramer, "Unbound Books: Bound Ex Negativo", presentation at "The Unbound Book", Institute for Network Cultures, Hogeschool van Amsterdam, 19-21 May, 2012.</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name= "Anne Mangen 1"> Anne Mangen "Why bother with print? Some reflections on the role of fixity, linearity and structure for sustained reading", presentation at "The Unbound Book", Institute for Network Cultures, Hogeschool van Amsterdam, 19-21 May, 2012.</ref>
+
<ref name= "open access models"> For a summary of the range of open access models that have been introduced, such as "Gold," "Green," and "Hybrid," see "What is open access?" https://www.openaccess.nl/en/what-is-open-access.</ref>
  
−
<ref name=" Landow 1"> George P. Landow, "Hypertext: The Convergence of Contemporary Literary Theory and Technology," Baltimore and London: John Hopkins University Press, 1992, page 2.</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name=" Gary Hall Unbound Book"> Gary Hall, "Pirate Philosophy, Hall, Gary, Pirate Philosophy, for a Digital Posthumanities," Cambridge, MA and London, The MIT Press, 2016, page 158 </ref>
+
<ref name="Radical Open Access"> The focus of these newly emerging open access presses is not limited to "providing online access to scholarly
 +
publications but was also about rethinking what an academic publishing culture should look like in a digital environment." (Adema, Moore 2018). One example would be the Radical Open Access Collective (ROAC), a community of scholar-led, not-for-profit presses, journals and other open access projects that at the moment consists of more than 50 members promoting a progressive vision for open publishing in the humanities and social sciences. http://radicaloa.disruptivemedia.org.uk/about/.
 +
The collective's aim is "to push back against the growing dominance of market-driven versions of open access – particularly those connected to exorbitant, and ultimately unsustainable, article and book processing charges – in order to promote non-commercial and not-for-profit forms of publishing that work against the neoliberal grain." http://radicaloa.disruptivemedia.org.uk/philosophy/. See also the range of topics debated at the two Radical Open Access conferences organized: "Radical Open Access" (2015) http://radicalopenaccess.disruptivemedia.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Booklet.pdf, and "Radical Open Access and the Ethics of Care" (2018) at Disruptive Media Lab at Coventry University, http://radicaloa.disruptivemedia.org.uk/conferences/roa2/concept/.</ref>
  
−
<ref name= "Constant ongoing"> This citation without pointing to a specific stabilized publication might surprise the conventions of academic standards. It refers to a 20-year practice of feminist technology collective Constant in Brussels, that explore and demonstrate through their practices, "how to practically intervene, disrupt and change existing systems of production, distribution, and consumption of knowledge". See  [http://constantvzw.org/site Constant]</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name= "Femke GWYDH"> "Performing Graphic Design Practice", Femke Snelting in conversation with Cornelia Sollfrank in the context of the research project "Giving what you don't have", 2014. http://artwarez.org/projects/GWYDH/snelting.html</ref>
 
  
 
<ref name="Inhumanist Manifesto">
 
<ref name="Inhumanist Manifesto">
Line 144: Line 201:
 
8. Use different personas or masks to experiment with producing multiple authorial 'I's, different to the liberal humanist subjectivity that is the default adopted by even the most supposedly radical of theorists.<br/>
 
8. Use different personas or masks to experiment with producing multiple authorial 'I's, different to the liberal humanist subjectivity that is the default adopted by even the most supposedly radical of theorists.<br/>
 
9. Reinvent both the humanities and the posthumanities as the inhumanities by adopting ways of being and doing as theorists that actually take account of and assume an intra-active relation with the nonhuman.
 
9. Reinvent both the humanities and the posthumanities as the inhumanities by adopting ways of being and doing as theorists that actually take account of and assume an intra-active relation with the nonhuman.
−
Gary Hall, "The Inhumanist Manifesto", Media Theory, August 2017, pp. 168-178, page 177.<http://journalcontent.mediatheoryjournal.org/index.php/mt/article/view/29>.</ref>
+
(Hall 2017, 177).</ref>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<ref name="mayflybooks"> See <i>Mayfly Books</i>,"About Mayfly Books", http://mayflybooks.org/?page_id=2.</ref>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<ref name="counter-politically"> The term "counter-political" is not to be read as "against politics" or "anti-politics". Counter-political is thought of as a practice that exceeds politics as an act of public demonstration and proclamation, or declarative, symbolic gestures. Its political agency lies in "doing things", the creation of facts, employing specific methods to achieve a certain goal. Counter-political comes close to infrapolitics with the difference that for infrapolitics anonymity is a key concern, "a politics that 'dare not speak its name,' a diagonal politics, a careful and evasive politics that avoided dangerous risks." (Scott 2012). See also the discussion of publicness and the public sphere. (02*Setting, note 3).</ref>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<ref name="Valand change of name" >I am using the name "HDK-Valand Academy of Arts and Design", or its short form "HDK-Valand" throughout this kappa. During the time when the project was in progress the Art Academy's name was "Valand Academy". "HDK-Valand" is the new name of the merger (2020) of the two art schools, Valand Art Academy and HDK Academy for Design and Craft.</ref>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<ref name="Tarde"> 
 +
French sociologist Gabriel Tarde stresses in his book <i>La lois d’imitation</i> (1890), <i>The Laws of Imitation</i> (translated into English in 1903)  the fundamental collective and pluralistic dimension of society by examining how any societal effort of invention is built on imitation. He states there is no tabula rasa on which ideas and knowledge emerge from, but ideas always build on already existing ideas. "Our acts are what they are because they are the fittest to satisfy and develop the wants which previous imitation of other inventions had first seeded in us; our thoughts, because they were the most consistent with the knowledge acquired by us of other thoughts which were themselves acquired because they were confirmed by other preliminary ideas or by visual, tactile, and other kinds of impressions which we got by renewing for ourselves certain scientific experiences or observations, after the example of those who first undertook them". (1903, 94) </ref>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<ref name= "Briet">Suzanne Briet wrote this treatise as a contribution to the discourse of what constitutes a document. This question was fiercely discussed in the early 1900s, with Paul Otlet claiming that not just written documents but also three-dimensional objects could constitute a document when they serve as evidential objects. Briet expanded this concept by saying that naturally occurring phenomena could as well be documents, such as stars, pebbles, and animals when they had been observed and recorded and classified by an individual (Briet 1951). </ref>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
 
  
−
<ref name= "my publications"> Having published with big mainstream commercial publishing houses (Hatje Cantz) as well as small independent presses (Temporary Services, Half-Letter Press, Occasional Papers and BookWorks in London) I got more and more interested in exploring and setting up own publishing infrastructures and subsequently co-founded (with American artist Lynn Harris) AND Publishing in London (today run with Rosalie Schweiker). </ref>
 
  
−
<ref name= "variability monograph"> Of course, within the field of scholarly publishing there is some variability, for instance, the role of the monograph in parts of the humanities in contrast to the role of the double-blind peer review article in some of the medical sciences, or the role for the critical edition in the humanities as against, say, the meta-research analysis paper in the social sciences, in short, there are different scholarly publishing hierarchies and protocols across the disciplines, but the overarching claim is still viable despite this. </ref>
+
<ref name="Colonial-Modernity"> I relate colonial modernity to the concept of coloniality, as Nelson Maldonado-Torres explains:
 +
::Coloniality is different from colonialism. Colonialism denotes a political and economic relation in which the sovereignty of a nation or a people rests on the power of another nation, which makes such nation an empire. Coloniality, instead, refers to long-standing patterns of power that emerged as a result of colonialism, but that define culture, labor, intersubjective relations, and knowledge production well beyond the strict limits of colonial administrations. Thus, coloniality survives colonialism. (Maldonado-Torres 2007, 243). </ref>
  
−
<ref name="Radical Open Access"> See for example ''Radical Open Access'' in 2015 [[http://radicalopenaccess.disruptivemedia.org.uk/programme/]] ''Radical Open Access and the Ethics of Care'' in 2018 at Disruptive Media Lab at Coventry University, [[http://radicaloa.disruptivemedia.org.uk/conferences/roa2/concept/]]</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name= "open access models"> For a summary of the range of instituted models, such as "Gold", "Green", "Hybrid" see "What is open access?". https://www.openaccess.nl/en/what-is-open-access</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name="Constant at Creating Commons" >Femke Snelting and Michael Murtaugh</ref>
+
<ref name="Fitzpatrick1">See Kathleen Fitzpatrick’s <i>Generous Thinking</i> – I refer to the published draft version: <i>Generous Thinking: The University and the Public Good</i>, especially the chapter "Critique and Competition" (Fitzpatrick 2018). Fitzpatrick’s working method with writing this book presents an interesting approach to scholarly publishing. She published the draft of her book online on Humanities Commons, inviting readers to comment. Based on these responses, what one could call a process of open peer review, she revised the initial draft for publication with John Hopkins University Press. While one could say this is some form of collective authorship, the now published title carries her individual name. The final print version is published as <i>Generous Thinking: A Radical Approach to Saving the University</i> (Fitzpatrick 2019). </ref>
  
−
<ref name="Siobhan Leddy" >Siobhan Leddy, "We should all be reading more Ursula Le Guin", '''The Outline'', 28 August 2019. https://theoutline.com/post/7886/ursula-le-guin-carrier-bag-theory?zd=3&zi=zsnwrv3k [accessed 4 April 2020]</ref>
+
<ref name= "UK REF">For example, the "Research Excellence Framework" (REF) is the UK system for assessing the quality of research in UK higher education institutions. The primary purpose of REF is to assess the quality of research and produce outcomes for each submission made by institutions. The four higher education funding bodies will use the assessment outcomes to inform the selective allocation of their grant for research to the institutions. The assessment is meant to provide accountability for public investment in research and to produce evidence of the benefits of this investment. The assessment outcomes aim to provide benchmarking information and to establish reputational yardsticks, for use within the higher education (HE) sector and for public information.
  
−
<ref name= "Le Guin"> Ursula Le Guin, The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction", in C. Glotfelty and H. Fromm (eds.), "The Ecocriticism Reader: Landmarks in Literary Ecology, 1996, pp.149-54, pp. 150-51. </ref>
+
The quality of research is assessed according to three criteria: (i) the quality of outputs (e.g. publications, performances, and exhibitions), (ii) their impact beyond academia, and (iii) the environment that supports research. Note that the criteria to assess the research environment are based on quantitative indicators such as
 +
(a) data on research doctoral degrees awarded, (b) research income, and (c) research income-in-kind). The shortcomings of quantitative assessment will further be discussed in chapter 06*Analysis.
  
−
<ref name= "Briet">Suzanne Briet's treatise has been written as a contribution to the discourse of what constitutes a document. A question that was fiercely discussed in the early 1900s with Paul Otlet claiming that not just written documents, but also three-dimensional objects could constitute a document, when they serve as evidential objects. Briet expanded this concept by saying that naturally occurring phenomena could as well be documents, such as stars, pebbles, and animals when they had been observed and recorded and classified by an individual. See Suzanne Briet, "Qu'est-ce que la documentation?" Bibliothèque Nationale de France, EDIT, Paris, 1951. English edition, translated and edited by Ronald E. Day and Laurent Martinet with Hermina G. B. Anghelescu, Lanham, Maryland, Scarecrow Press, 2006, 84 pages. Find pdf here: https://monoskop.org/log/?p=11894</ref>
+
The REF was first carried out in 2014 (replacing the previous Research Assessment Exercise in 2009) the second one is scheduled for 2021. It is undertaken by the four UK higher education funding bodies: Research England, the Scottish Funding Council (SFC), the Higher Education Funding Council for Wales (HEFCW), and the Department for the Economy, Northern Ireland (DfE). https://www.ref.ac.uk/2014/</ref>
  
−
<ref name="MediaWiki"> a web-based content management software that also powers Wikipedia.
 
−
The first wiki software (WikiWikiWeb) was developed by Ward Cunningham in the mid-1990s to enable a community of software developers to work together. Wikis are web-based content management systems that allow users to collaborate
 
−
on content asynchronously. They contain a series of extendable hyperlinked pages to which users can add, edit and delete information, alter the structure, and so on. Every change is automatically recorded, viewable and reversible by users. Wikis use a very simplified mark up language and as such users require no knowledge of code, nor any specialist software or
 
−
plugins. Cunningham described wikis as the "simplest online database that could possibly work." See http://www.wiki.org/wiki.cgi?WhatIsWiki.[accessed 30 April 2020].</ref>
 
  
−
<ref name= "Cusiquanci"> Silvia Rivera Cusiquanci, El Colectivo 2, La Paz-Chukiyawu, "A Stroll through the Colonial Library", unpublished paper presented at the conference Dis/Locating Culture: Narratives and Epistemologies of Displacement, Rice University, Houston, December 9-10, 2011.</ref>
+
<ref name="MediaWiki"> Mediawiki is an open-source web-based content management software that also powers Wikipedia. The first wiki software (WikiWikiWeb) was developed by Ward Cunningham in the mid-1990s to enable a community of software developers to work together. Wikis are web-based content management systems that allow users to collaborate on content asynchronously. They contain a series of extendable hyperlinked pages to which users can add, edit and delete information, alter the structure, and so on. Every change is automatically recorded, viewable and reversible by users. Wikis use a very simplified mark up language and as such users require no knowledge of code, nor any specialist software or plugins. Cunningham described wikis as the "simplest online database that could possibly work." See http://www.wiki.org/wiki.cgi?WhatIsWiki.</ref>
  
−
<ref name="mayflybooks"> See Mayfly Books [[http://mayflybooks.org/?page_id=2]]</ref>
+
<ref name= "Charlotte Cooper"> Charlotte Cooper produced a helpful "Research Justice Diagram" that shows the ethics of research that draws on communities outside academia; in Charlotte's case research on Fat Activism. For the diagram see: http://www.antiuniversity.org/Fat-Activism-and-Research-Justice. See also Charlotte Cooper’s website, http://charlottecooper.net/. </ref>
−
 
−
<ref name=" Printed Matter">I took copies of my first two independently published publications, ("Lery - a story of facts and faxes," 1998 and "Mexico," 1997, with Vera Büchlmann and Joachim Melf) on my first trip to New York, walked into Printed Matter art book shop and sold them ten copies each on consignment. What an empowering moment, which was more exciting than any exhibition opportunity I ever had.</ref>
 
 
</references>
 
</references>

Latest revision as of 08:21, 13 October 2020

Multiple sites

This wiki provides an overview of a doctoral research project, entitled "Noun to Verb: an investigation of the micro-politics of publishing through artistic practice." The project explores the social and political agency of publishing, investigating the micro-politics of making, articulating, and sharing knowledges from an intersectional feminist perspective.

In practical terms, the research process comprises (i) a range of activities, (art-making, workshopping, publishing, editorial work, collaborative practices, conferencing, organizing, pedagogical interventions, discursive events, etc.) and (ii) a range of "stabilizations" (publications, chapters, essays, posters, ephemera, archives, reading rooms, exhibitions, etc.). Both (i) and (ii) are developed collaboratively.

Publishing may be understood as a means of sharing, of disclosing, of passing on, or as an act of 'making public' that includes texts, images, ideas, and what we may summarily call "knowledges". Publishing may also be understood as a temporary stabilization of knowledge, fixing the act of making-public into a material and mobile form (paper, ink, screen, code) – fixing it into an object. As an object, detached from the makers (person), moment (time) and ecologies (context) of its production, a publication can circulate and spread across regions, contexts, and epochs – in Florian Cramer's (2012) words, "the idea of the book is one that can be read in one, five, and one hundred years' time." It develops a social and intellectual life of its own.

While publication can enable the one to speak to the many, and as such be seen as a mode of address that constructs patterns of dominance, the act of publication can also be seen as a tool to give voice and recognition to bodies and experiences that are not yet acknowledged, articulated or prioritized within the range of existing knowledges.[1] Therefore publication can be seen as a process that invites both assent and dissent, and that produces countervailing views and alternative readings, something that has fueled much debate on "the public sphere."[2]Speechbubble.png

Rosalie-eva phd 35-lres.jpg

Annotated by RS

Such themes have been widely discussed in relation to the rise of European print culture (Eisenstein, 1982; Johns, 1998), but these debates are not the main focus here. Instead, the present research specifically addresses the micro-politics of publishing practices at the intersection of contemporary art, radical education, and institutional analysis.[3] Furthermore, publishing practices are not exclusively considered here in terms of print culture, but rather are understood as part of a wider multiplicity of modes and formats that operate as "stabilizations" of knowledges, as indicated above.

I use the word "knowledges" in plural to problematize the idea of singular, disembodied and universal knowledge that is associated with modern Western epistemologies.[4] Knowledges in this inquiry are understood in Donna Haraway's sense as "ruled by partial sight and limited voice – not partiality for its own sake but, rather, for the sake of the connections and unexpected openings situated knowledges make possible." (Haraway 1988, 590). Therefore knowledges in my view are fundamentally contingent and interactive. "Situated knowledges are about communities, not about isolated individuals. The only way to find a larger vision is to be somewhere in particular." (Haraway 1988, 590). To be somewhere in particular means also to be response-able. Here, knowing is understood as a fundamental relational act. Take the "streetwalker theorist" invoked by Maria Lugones, for example, who "cultivates a multiplicity and depth of perception and connection and 'hangs out'." The streetwalker theorist's "knowing is necessarily dialogical; it does not lie in her". (Lugones, 2003, chapter 10 “Tactical Strategies of the Streetwalker”, "Streetwalker Theorizing").[5]

The emphasis here is on a dialogical process – "knowing with". The use of the verb "knowing", an active form, stands in contrast to "knowledge", an objectifying noun implying that knowledge can be appropriated and owned. In this sense, "knowing with" (rather than "having knowledge" or "knowing about") runs counter to the prevailing Western assumptions of authorship and ownership[6] that I discuss in the book chapter "Confronting Authorship, Constructing Practices" (Weinmayr 2019). The "knowing with" is foregrounding knowledge as a "situated conversation at every level of its articulation" (Haraway 1988, 594) as I will argue throughout this research project – including, but not limited to, articulations in the form of publishing.

Of course, publishing practices extend far beyond the printed page. A core concern of this inquiry is to expand and test the normative criteria of what constitutes a publication. One question that emerged was whether publishing may be seen as a verb, a process, rather than a noun (i.e. the finished object) – analogous to the above distinction between "knowing" and "knowledge". Could practice itself be understood as a form of publishing? A teaching situation, for example – a workshop, seminar, or group dialogue, where knowledge is collectively created and shared at the same time – could this also be considered as publishing? What kinds of publics are necessary or relevant to a publication process? A collaboration, a collective, a scene, a process, a dynamic, a method – can we frame any such situation or process as "publishing"? How fixed or stable does a transmission of knowledges need to be in order to be called a "publication"? And what is the function and effect of such stability?

Networked digital media technologies also replace "the fixity and the static (and, by implication, limiting) linearity of print by adding multimedia features, interactivity, hyperstructure and virtually limitless possibilities for non-verbal, interactive, reading and communication for the reader" (Mangen 2012). It is the "unbound" character of the digital that unsettles "conceptual systems founded upon ideas of center, margin, hierarchy, and linearity and replaces them with ones of multi-linearity, modes, links, and networks." (Landow 1992, 2). The unbound is a moment of recapitulation, and, according to George Landow (1992, 3), "a direct response to the strengths and weaknesses of the printed book." And Gary Hall (2016, 158) notes that the defamiliarizing effects of these new conceptions

offer us a chance to raise the kind of questions regarding our ideas of the book (but also of the unified, sovereign, proprietorial subject; the individualized author, the signature, the proper name; originality, fixity, the finished object; the canon, the discipline, tradition, intellectual property; the Commons, community, and so on), we should have been raising all along.

Whether "bound" or "unbound," there has been much discussion of the political agency of the book, and it is often assumed that the book's political potential extends only as far as its 'content'. Yet what is of interest in the present inquiry is the book's capacity as a conceptual and material means to practically intervene, disrupt, and change existing systems of production, distribution, and consumption of knowledge. (Adema and Hall, 2014; Thoburn, 2014; Constant, ongoing)[7]

This inquiry is grounded in my individual and collective publishing practice, which has been a long-term part of my work as an artist. Publication became a main mode of my practice early on: perhaps because as a student I spent a significant part of my studies working next to the photocopy machines in the art academy; and perhaps because through publishing it appeared that I could shape the terms and conditions of production and distribution and could act without the authorization of galleries, curators, collectors, etc.[8] However, while this research is embedded in my long-term artistic practice using the form of publication as a carrier for ideas,[9] this inquiry is not focusing on artists' books in particular. The descriptor "artists' books" is too narrow, in limiting the investigation to publications made by artists. The questions I will ask are more fundamental: directed towards the processes and agencies of publishing that operate across disciplines and fields, rather than limiting these to the specific commodity genre of the artists' book.

Take, for example, the early conceptual artists' books in the context of the 1960s and 1970s in the US. They have been described as "a means of democratizing and subverting existing institutions by distributing an increasingly cheap and accessible medium (the book) [...] in order to reimagine what art is and how it can be accessed and viewed." (Adema and Hall 2013, 140). As such they expanded the limits of what was commonly perceived (and traded) as art, and they challenged existing hierarchies and institutions.⟶  see chapter 03*Survey of the field: Setting up alternative infrastructures My understanding is that the critical agency of the artist’s book, as elaborated in this initial phase of experimentation, has become watered down over the years – the making of "artists' books" has become a mainstream artistic practice and market. This is evidenced by hundreds of newly emerging artist book fairs across the globe, sometimes hosted by the most prestigious mainstream museums, such as MoMA PS1 in New York, or Tate Modern and Whitechapel Gallery in London. Florian Cramer (2012) provocatively declares that artists' books today tend to be "a genre of graphic design." In printed form, "they strive to become coffee table books, often with warm, fuzzy and unbound characteristics," and therefore turn into "boutique collectibles for rich people."

In the field of open-source and free software, and feminist approaches in particular – exemplified by Constant, a feminist technology collective based in Brussels – we observe a very different critical energy. As Femke Snelting (2014) argues, software is a cultural object:

Free Software culture takes care of sharing the recipes of how this technology (in a cultural sense, not a technocentric) has been developed. [...] And this produces many different other tools, ways of working, ways of speaking, vocabularies, because it changes radically the way we make and the way we produce hierarchies. So that means, if you produce a graphic design artifact, for example, you share all the source files that were necessary to make it. But you also share, as much as you can, descriptions and narrations of how it came to be, which does include, maybe, how much was paid for it, what difficulties were in negotiating with the printer, what elements were included, [...] what software was used to make it and where it might have resisted. [...] You care about all these different layers of the work, all the different conditions that actually make the work happen.

Free software culture, therefore, investigates how technologies and their protocols disrupt economies of authorship and ownership, and implicitly redefines the hierarchies and enclosures that are embedded in more mainstream publishing practices.

This is also true of certain emerging tendencies within academic publishing, where new material conditions of book production, organization and consumption allow for experiments with forms and concepts of scholarly publishing.[10] Here digital publishing and open access place in question, in Janneke Adema's words, "the very print-based system of scholarly communication – complete with its ideas of quality, stability, and authority – on which so much of the academic institution rests." (Adema and Hall 2013, 139). Open access policies, which demand that publicly funded research must be made freely available, are based on the argument that the public has already funded the research which should be consequently be made publicly available at no cost. Yet the implementation of these policies may also carry the threat of corporate take-over. In many cases commercial academic presses have merely shifted the costs from the reader (who would previously be required to pay for articles directly) back to the author, researcher, or their institution. By imposing "author or article processing charges" (APC),[11] academic presses maintain their income-generating model, thereby creating a range of new enclosures and inequalities that are discussed in more detail in the interview "Thinking where the thinking happens" with the director of Goldsmiths Press Sarah Kember.⟶  see chapter 04*Summary of projects and submitted material: Rethinking where the thinking happens, interview with Sarah Kember

Universities and academic activists have addressed the "exorbitant, unaffordable and unsustainable publishing fees" charged by many scholarly journals by campaigning for "new forms of communality, designed to support the building of commons-based open access publishing infrastructures, and promote a more diverse, not-for-profit ecosystem of scholarly communication." (Adema 2018)[12] Gary Hall laid some strategies out in his "Inhumanist Manifesto"[13] and Mayfly Books have summed up the current situation up as follows:

it seems today that scholarly publishing is drawn in two directions: On the one hand, this is a time of the most exciting theoretical, political and artistic projects that respond to and seek to move beyond global administered society. On the other hand, the publishing industries are vying for total control of the ever-lucrative arena of scholarly publication, creating a situation in which the means of distribution of books grounded in research and in radical interrogation of the present are increasingly restricted.[14]

This brief mapping of developments in different fields of publishing practice also reflects the fact that my practice is situated across art, academia, and activism. The five projects I will present, typically of a long term and collaborative nature, each explore a range of specific questions in a way that is layered and complex. They are not discrete single-issue, single-question experiments but rather complex tangles of issues unfolding in real-world situations and "live" fields of operation. They often developed as responses to specific situations and to emergent problems or questions in concrete locations. As such, they don't intend to operate as works "about politics." Instead, these projects aim at finding operational models to work counter-politically – through the actual practice itself.[15] Hence my artistic concern is not to illustrate a political position but to actively engage in political experiments in publishing and ecologies of knowledge.


More verb, less noun: the practices

⟶  see project 2*Library of Inclusions and Omissions The Library of Inclusions and Omissions (2016) is a practice-based experiment in critical knowledge infrastructures. Setting up a community-run reading room around intersectional feminist and decolonial materials, the project explores the politics (potentials and limitations) of libraries, online and physical, for accessing, activating, and disseminating knowledge. Defining the library as a knowledge infrastructure (Mattern, 2014), the project tests dominant policies of validation (access) and classification (organization). Furthermore, it investigates the difference between a community-run resource such as this and more institutional libraries, in terms of their selection and validation processes. With the Library of Inclusions and Omissions, I seek to develop a curatorial concept to give voice to hidden, suppressed, or unacknowledged materials and struggles. In what ways could such a curatorial strategy thereby turn the library from a repository of knowledge (Samek 2003, Springer 2015) into a space of social and intellectual encounter and action? Can such a library project help build a community or connect different communities?

⟶  see project 3*The Piracy Project The Piracy Project (2010–15), based in London, is a long-term collaboration with Peruvian artist Andrea Francke. It explores dominant understandings of authorship, originality, and the implications of intellectual property and copyright policies for knowledge practices. Through an open call for pirated books and our research into pirate book markets in Peru, China, and Turkey, The Piracy Project gathered a collection of around 150 copied, emulated, appropriated and modified books from across the world. Their copying approaches vary widely, from playful strategies of reproduction, modification, and reinterpretation of existing works, to circumventing enclosures such as censorship or market monopolies, to acts of piracy generated by commercial interests. Through temporary reading rooms, workshops, lectures, discussions, and debates, The Piracy Project explores the philosophical, legal, and social implications of cultural piracy. In this project, Andrea and I examine the ways in which the pirated, modified, emulated books in the collection transgress normative concepts of authorization, challenging the idea of individual authorship and the assumed authority of the printed book. In the theorization of this project, I will show how the project's unauthorized interventions into "stable" and authoritative knowledge reveal and undo the reciprocity between authorship, originality and intellectual property – a triangulation that, as I will demonstrate, constitutes one of the main blockages for collective knowledge practices.

⟶  see project 4*Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy? Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy? (2015–16) is a collective investigation into intersectional feminist pedagogies, that led to (i) the organization of a three-day international mobilization at HDK-Valand Academy of Art and Design (at the time Valand Art Academy), University of Gothenburg[16] and (ii) the publishing of a workbook with the same title. It began from a working group that formed at the Academy consisting of students, staff, and administrators (Kanchan Burathoki, Rose Borthwick, MC Coble, Andreas Engman, Gabo Camnitzer, Eva Weinmayr). The group’s aim was twofold. Firstly, to provide a space to discuss the highs and lows in our own learning and teaching and to study and review university policies and institutional habits. Secondly, to organize an international conference (mobilization) to fundamentally rethink how knowledge is produced, transmitted, and disseminated. We were keen to find strategies to address the Eurocentric canon and its exclusions, to question institutional habits and procedures, and to create an understanding of equality that is not blind to difference. The mobilization itself was a practice-based investigation experimenting with non-normative uses of the classroom, paying attention to time and temporalities, languages, and the empirical body. The published workbook is understood as an "input" rather than an "output." It aims at a redefinition of the dominant understanding of "impact" in current systems of academic evaluation – an understanding often based on a reductive logic of calculation. The project proposes to reassess the instituted taxonomy of values within learning, teaching and research at the art academy. It asks what would happen if we valued and gave formal credit to all the knowledges and processes involved in how we publish. The project asks how open, enabling, and diverse our knowledge practices are; and how inclusive are our tools and protocols? It does so by practically examining the moments, formats, and temporalities of how knowledge is "practiced" within the art academy. More broadly, this experiment scrutinizes how institutional habits – how we meet, the terminologies we use, the procurement procedures we are asked to follow, the forms of "outcomes" that are expected – enable or hinder collective and inclusive critical knowledge practices.

⟶  see project 5*Boxing and Unboxing Boxing and Unboxing, a collaboration with artist Rosalie Schweiker, took place during the course of AND Publishing's six-month research residency at Marabouparken konsthall in Stockholm. It consisted of learning how to "box" and "unbox", and cutting up boxes – dealing with questions of categorization inspired by Rhani Lee Remedes's (2002) "SCUB Manifesto: Society for cutting up boxes". Together with curator Jenny Richards, AND organized a boxing club for self-identifying women. The question was whether sparring, when defined as physical play and not as competition, might allow us to rehearse ways to relate to each other in other areas. The experiment conceived of boxing not in terms of masculinity and violence or the survival of the fittest, but as a moment of intense negotiation of border space, contagion, and border linking (Ettinger 2006). In this sense, boxing renders permeable the borderlines of our "proper" subjects (an "individual" conceived as founded in the sole ownership of oneself). As a nonverbal bodily dialogue, it transgresses boundaries that we elsewhere seek to protect. During sparring, I deliberately forgo this established immunity – my contours become vulnerable through the mutuality of the touch: my fist touches and is being touched at the same time. In the reflection on this project, I connect thoughts about immunity and community (Esposito, 2010; Lorey, 2013) to the exhilarating, troubling, and demanding experiences that the sparring sessions produced. I will reflect on sparring as a radical bodily dialogue, considering its potential for learning how to compete without needing to win, and how to practice respectful disagreement.

This variety of projects, sites and strategies is important as part of a wider strategy of feminist publishing that operates in different arenas and reaches beyond traditional notions of publication. As Chantal Mouffe (2005, 114) has noted, "the globalized space is 'striated', with a diversity of sites where relations of power are articulated in specific local, regional and national configurations," highlighting the need for a variety of strategies. Mouffe describes this as "a counter-hegemonic struggle", "a process involving a multiplicity of ruptures" (Errejón and Mouffe 2016, 40). I am cautious to use the term "counter-hegemonic" since the binary implicit in "counter" simplifies (i) the multi-layered infra-actions at play in the practice itself (collective, transversal), and (ii) the complexities of the contexts in which they operate. But Mouffe helps to argue for the plurality of forms and approaches in my practice that respond to specific issues across a number of different sites: art, education, activism, institutions, culture, business, politics, technology, and media.

This inquiry is situated within a Western context and – as will emerge in the analysis and theorization of the projects – it is situated with respect to such overarching constructs as colonial modernity, possessive individualism, and the neoliberal subject. As a White European female subject, I move between practices, institutions and discourses mostly within Europe and North America. It is from this position that I investigate the micro-politics of knowledge practices, informed by concepts found in feminist theory, media theory, radical pedagogy, as well as social science and philosophy.


Authorship, authorization, authority: the questions

I started this PhD research with a range of observations and questions based on my practice to date. These initial questions were refined through the internal logic of a multifaceted inquiry – they moved, opened up, got destabilized a little.Speechbubble.png

Rosalie–eva phd 2020-04-18 12-21-09.jpg

Annotated by RS

Through thinking embedded in practice, the multiple ways of doing things, and the different entry points I found, I came to reframe, re-describe, and refine the initial problems and assumptions of my inquiry.

Drawing upon Gabriel Tarde's proposition that knowledge is a mode of socialization and social communication (1903)[17] I set out to investigate publication as a social, pedagogical, and political process. How can publishing create spaces for better mutual understanding and rethinking relations between people? What is the relationship between "making" and "making public"? Between experience and articulation? How does the "outside space" (distribution) shape the "inside space" of publication (content) and vice versa? What is contextual publishing? Is publishing necessarily always tied to a document, whether it be the printed page or via other media such as film, drawing, or photography? What is a document? In her study Qu'est-ce que la documentation? (1951) the French librarian and pioneer of information science Suzanne Briet describes as follows: an antelope running wild in the Savannah is considered an animal, yet through being captured and brought to Europe to be exhibited in the zoo – through being caged, described, measured, and classified – the animal is turned into a document.[18] It is analyzed, described, categorized, classified, and exhibited as a specimen, a process that constitutes a key paradigm to the project of colonial modernity. [19]

In short, this challenges the initial presumption that publishing is an outright positive and progressive act, a tool of giving voice and developing emancipatory agency. The research process (making, thinking and analyzing) put this idea into question and made it necessary to rethink the operating assumptions of the inquiry. Institutional pressure (publish or perish), for example, can erode the conditions for practices based on agency, creativity, criticality, experimentation, and collective knowledge making. Publishing (and writing) in institutional or semi-institutional contexts has been arguably "reduced from a process of communication, discovery, and exploration, to a system for the assembly of more and more new products, merely based on a logic of calculation."[20] Rebekka Kiesewetter (2019) observes that "the significance of a publication is often reduced to a consumable or proof of excellence and a claim for authority; and publishing activities mostly are pursued within an output-led environment, in which the suggested formats and the institutional, economic and procedural frames tempt the interpretation of every outcome, every representation as vessels for contents, static, backward-looking, absolute, finalized, and set." Several points are raised here: firstly, it points to systems of validation and audit culture; secondly, to the stasis of the "finite" object; and thirdly, to the authority these discrete objects produce.

As I will argue, these three topics form the main "blockages" for emancipatory, collective knowledge practices. I wrestled with these blockages practically and theoretically throughout this inquiry, each with different entry points and from different perspectives. To be more specific: as the inquiry developed it became clearer that I set out to explore the coercive mutual reciprocity between authorship, authorization, and authority. In this sense, this inquiry seeks to move from a vague apprehension of these three terms' mutual interaction to a clearer framing of their "coercive reciprocation." The result of this inquiry could be described as the development of this insight alongside potential models for emancipatory, critical, intersectional feminist models of knowledge "making and sharing". In practice, doing things, one gets caught in tensions, paradoxes, and double binds. These double binds may become frozen or locked, especially if one stays at the level of writing, or thinking, or talking about it. As soon as one involves multiple ways of tackling the issue practically, experimenting with different ways of doing, it is often possible to find new resources with which to rethink the way the problem is set. By implementing these different experiments I began to refine the description of the problems in terms of the described set of blockages and their reciprocal interaction.

The majority of this work was conducted between the United Kingdom and Sweden, 2010–20. A significant amount of the policy referenced in this inquiry is specific to the UK, where I spent the majority of my "university life". The UK may also be taken as indicative of wider tendencies in higher education and research elsewhere – the UK started early on with an explicit formulation of the changing agenda in higher education and research, in the form of the Research Excellence Framework (REF), for example,[21] reflecting the broader shift towards a culture of audit and metrics.


"Thinking with": the format

The format I choose for this PhD inquiry is a compilation thesis, comprising a distinct set of practical experiments and a "kappa" (Swedish, translated to English as "cape" or "coat").Speechbubble.png

Rosalie-eva phd 40-lres.jpg

Annotated by RS

The kappa is what you are reading now, on this wiki. The purpose of the kappa is to disclose the contribution made by the research project and to locate that contribution with reference to existing knowledge practices.

In Swedish academia, the kappa is understood as an outer layer that bundles, connects, discusses, and reflects on its contents. I use the kappa as a way to engage with the range of experiments I have carried out, without turning them into a monolithic entity (as can happen with a monograph, the typical format for a doctoral submission). The kappa is meant to allow the components to retain their discrete, self-contained identities, but also to enable them to be joined together as elements of a larger construction. As Gary Hall pointed out in an earlier discussion of the work in progress, one could think of all the different elements of a coat: the sleeves, the collar, the lining, the buttons, all stitched together to form a larger construction. (Here it could be interesting to think about the nature of the joints.) But these metaphors still do not reflect exactly how I worked in this inquiry. The stitching together of different parts suggests a unified whole – the coat – and the formless cape or wrapper suggests an enclosure that shields the different parts from the outside. Perhaps Ursula Le Guin's "carrier bag theory" is more fitting? The vessel, Le Guin suggests, is mankind's earliest tool – not the spear, as often claimed. "A leaf a gourd a shell a net a bag a sling a sack a bottle a pot a box a container. A holder. A recipient. [...] what's the use of digging up a lot of potatoes if you have nothing to lug the ones you can't eat home in – with or before the tool that forces energy outward, we made a tool that brings energy home." The only problem, as Le Guin notes, is that a carrier bag story is not at first glance very exciting. "It is hard to tell a really gripping tale of how I wrested a wild-oat seed from its husk, and then another, and then another, and then another, and then another, and then I scratched my gnat bites, and Ool said something funny, and we went to the creek and got a drink and watched newts for a while, and then I found another patch of oats…" (Le Guin 1996). As well as its wandering narrative, a carrier bag story contains no heroes. Instead, as Siobhan Leddy (2019) observes, there are

many different protagonists with equal importance to the plot [...] and the bag's inside is messy and sometimes conflicted. Like when you're trying to grab your sunglasses out of your bag, but those are stuck on your headphones, which are also tangled around your keys, and now the sunglasses have slipped into that hole in the lining. This lack of clear trajectory allowed Le Guin to test out all kinds of political eventualities, without the need to tie everything neatly together. It makes room for complexity and contradiction, for difference and simultaneity.

I have been thinking a lot about protagonists in this narrative, in this PhD. Since most of the practices are collaborations, I saw a danger in the fact that it will be mostly me who is narrating, framing, and to an extent historicizing them from my perspective alone. The struggle was to differentiate the "I" and the "we" throughout this writing and thinking; they are often difficult to disentangle. This "I" also shifts, is not stable, perhaps incoherent, because it has been populated by others while working and thinking together.

I have also been thinking a lot about tools and "containers" for this kappa, and how the tools shape the way I write and read. After one year of writing, and after meeting Femke Snelting and Michael Murtaugh from Constant at a three-day research meeting in Basel, I decided to drop the solitary Word document on my hard disk and continue in the form of a MediaWiki.[22] This for me was a "paradigm shift" from the protected, private and proprietary environment of my hard disk to a web-based, open, and "public" environment for my tentative thinking, writing and archiving. There were moments of anxiety when I shared the URL, knowing that lots of things were unresolved, not thought through or tentatively worded. But it felt important to share this process because it created dialogues and conversations. It was always cooking, and lots of precious ingredients have been added by others throughout these conversations – only because it was open and accessible throughout.

One specific tool that had been coded by Cristina Cochior and Manetta Berends from Varia (Rotterdam) is the annotation feature.Speechbubble.png

Rosalie-eva phd 42-lres.jpg

Annotated by RS

It is used by the folks in the various collaborations. So far, Andrea Francke (Piracy Project), Andreas Engman, MC Coble (Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?), and Rosalie Schweiker (AND, Boxing and Unboxing) have added anecdotes, thoughts, and observations about working with these specific projects. In working together, there are always assumptions, motivations, and misunderstandings that are not necessarily articulated while plotting and "doing stuff". Strangely, you often assume that everyone else thinks the same as you do. Therefore, the annotation feature invites the collaborators to comment, add, and disagree with my accounts of the projects. And as such, it turns the thesis from an authoritative text into an occasion for negotiation, disagreement, and consultation. This approach is not a "writing up," but an experiment in itself. Lastly, this work is not locked up in a scholarly monograph in a university collection, but accessible via the internet – opening up its readership beyond those having access or are inclined to visit European university libraries (Cusicanqui 2011). This also means it is open to feed back into communities outside academia, in which most of the activities developed and are grounded in.[23] And as such, it tries to avoid extractive economies that are addressed in Appendix 2*Interview with Femke Snelting.⟶  see appendix 2*Interview with Femke Snelting



Roadmap

The kappa, the textual format that synthesizes and summarizes the contribution made by the PhD research project, is structured in 6 chapters plus appendices. It is important to note that the kappa is not the final or only form of disclosure. The kappa is a device being used to disclose the practice to meet the terms of a doctoral examination process – the work also circulates more widely in the world in other wrappers (carrier bags) and on different terms. It will be useful to explain the different layers of text you are reading on this wiki. The main body text (black) is the text I have written. It has a substantial notes section at the bottom of each chapter that operates as a parallel layer to the main text. I wanted to keep the main text concise and easy to follow. Therefore, lots of more detailed information, and unpacking of specific terms or concepts takes place in the notes. The left-hand column is the navigation menu that brings you to the individual pages (chapters). It does the same job as the index page but is easier to use since it stays visible on each page. In the right-hand column, you will find annotations by persons I collaborated with in the projects, as well as peers, friends, and colleagues who were thinking with me during this inquiry. These annotations vary between textual comments and visual comments, since not everyone felt that text is the medium with which they can best express themselves.

The page About this wiki explains the purpose of this Mediawiki as constituting the submission of a Doctoral thesis leading to the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Artistic Practice. It also contains the abstract.

Chapter 01*Contents presents the table of contents of this kappa.

Chapter 02*Setting gives an overview of what the inquiry is about – of the basic research task, agenda, and purpose. It lays out the context, the problems I will address, and the questions I started with. It also gives information on how the wiki is structured and how it can be read.

Chapter 03*Survey of the field presents and discusses practices, movements, and concepts that others have developed. These examples are spread widely in terms of geography and history, and they draw on a wide range of disciplinary frames and epochs. This broad approach stems from a commitment to work transversally and not to be bound by the protocols of one field alone – such as contemporary art or feminist organizational practices or radical education. The examples I have chosen are all instances where the dominant paradigms of publishing and the formation of knowledge have been in one way or another adjusted, acting as declared counter-political projects. This chapter also maps a network of relationships, since I have been working with some of the discussed projects in the form of workshops, seminars, talks, friendships, and other moments of thinking and doing together.

Chapter 04*Summary of projects & submitted material provides a short factual description of the submitted material to make explicit the projects and activities that form the basis of the contribution made by this research project. It details five long-term practice projects, and includes published (fixed) materials, such as articles, chapters, papers, and ephemera as well as discursive (unfixed) practices describing the workshops, talks, and moments of "thinking with" that constitute not an "outcome" but a practice.

Each of the Project pages (1–5) describes one of the five practice projects in more detail. They break down the context that each project responded to or intervened in. They also give a step-by-step sketch of their main elements, methods, and strategies employed. The five practice projects are: AND (1); Library of Omission and Inclusions (2); The Piracy Project (3); Let's Mobilize what is Feminist Pedagogy? (4); and Boxing and Unboxing (5). All of these projects are collaborations and developed over time.

Chapter 05*Reflection and theorization of projects and submitted material provides a more in-depth and extended reflection on the projects and experiments I have carried out. This is provided to disclose the significance and importance of the contribution made by the research project. It discusses the complexities and contradictions of each of the practice projects individually and articulates their underlying concepts and theories.

Building on the reflection and theorization of the five practice projects, the chapter 06*Analysis zooms in on the micro-politics of knowledge practices and crystalizes a range of topics that surfaced throughout the projects. Touching on the politics of citation and experimental authorial practices, I analyze the experiment of writing this thesis in the form of a MediaWiki – as a way that practically experiments with some of the claims made.

07*References lists the resources that have informed the practices, thinking and writing of this research. It goes, therefore, beyond a strict list of "cited sources" since it includes materials that have informed my practice indirectly. Where possible, I have linked directly to sources or uploaded them to this wiki database. As such, this section also extends beyond a typical bibliography and operates partly as an archive.Speechbubble.png

Rosalie-eva phd 37 lres.jpg

Annotated by RS


08*My integrated circuit acknowledges the collaborative effort of this research project.

The appendices present further materials that did not fit within the index structure above.
Appendix*01: Let's Mobilize Revisited presents a collaborative writing experiment with multi-layered commentary, conducted by Rose Borthwick, Andreas Engman, MC Coble, Eva Weinmayr in 2017.
Appendix*02: Interview: Femke Snelting, Eva Weinmayr, March 24–25, 2020 (Resolutions are always temporary) features an interview with Femke Snelting (Constant, Brussels).
Appendix*03: Rosalie's Visual Comments collects the visual annotations that Rosalie Schweiker produced for this kappa in 2020.



Notes (Setting)

  1. ↑ Without presenting a premature definition of knowledge, a short insert is needed here to point out that knowledge is connected to an apparatus of legitimization that is discussed and problematized in the following chapters. The term "acknowledging" points towards a dialogical and relational act, to acknowledge means "I see you". To acknowledge is an act of recognizing, of interacting "with other people’s worlds" in the words of Maria Lugones (2003, Introduction):
    By traveling to other people’s “worlds,” we discover that there are “worlds” in which those who are the victims of arrogant perception are really subjects, lively beings, resisters, constructors of visions even though in the mainstream construction they are animated only by the arrogant perceiver and are pliable, foldable, file-awayable, classifiable. I always imagine the Aristotelian slave as pliable and foldable at night or after he or she cannot work anymore (when he or she dies as a tool). Aristotle tells us nothing about the slave apart from the master. We know the slave only through the master. The slave is a tool of the master. After working hours, he or she is folded and placed in a drawer until the next morning.
  2. ↑ The idea of public that I have in mind is not one that is built on Habermas's concept of the bourgeois public sphere (Habermas 1962), because it does not differentiate between a public and the public. Michael Warner (2003) describes the public as "a kind of social totality, the people in general" and a public as a concrete audience, "a crowd witnessing itself in visible space, as with a theatrical public. Such a public also has a sense of totality, bounded by the event or by the shared physical space". Also Nancy Fraser’s sense of “counterpublic” (Fraser 1997) seems problematic since a counter-public presupposes a universalizing concept of the bourgeois mainstream public that it can oppose, that can be "countered". Similar to Nancy Fraser's concept of counterpublics, María Pía Lara provides an account of counter publicity in subaltern groups and stresses, according to Lugones, that the public address is an "attainment of recognition […] that is addressed not just to subaltern groups, but in a wider direction."(Lugones 2000, 176). In her text "Multiculturalism and Publicity" (2000), Maria Lugones provides a short summary of Lara's argument:
    Dialogue between author and public is necessary for recognition. Engaging the other in an understanding of the ego is crucial here; disclosure is crucial to identity formation. [...] thus, requires public recognition (Lara 1999, 87). Recognition is complete only when “acceptance of the public has taken place” (Lara 1999, 82). If differences are necessary for subjective expansion, their value must be “asserted in front of others” and the dialogue must not only show what makes one different but also that those differences are “part of what should be considered worthy” (Lara 1999, 156, 157). Groups needing to be heard must “conquer channels of communication to call attention to the way they have been treated”; recognition is thus a struggle (Lara 1999, 151, 157). It is their descriptions of what is missing in their lives that make their claims meaningful and understandable to others (Lara 1999, 151). In this case, subaltern publics must aim to reach recognition from both oppressors and oppressed. (Lugones 2000, 179)
    Maria Lugones discusses yet another dimension of public and publicity, one that refers to the hidden publics of infrapolitics, that deliberately forgo a publicist address. (On infrapolitics, see Scott 1987 and 1990.) The so-called "hidden transcript," as a dissident political culture in resistance to oppression, does not address the oppressor. Hidden transcripts, therefore are not just "outside 'the master's tools,' but also outside the master's perceptual field and the master's perceptual possibilities." (Lugones 2000, 178). My use of the term public corresponds to Warner's self-organized public that organizes around a concrete object, occasion (event) or discourse – a publication, for example. This comes close to Matthew Stadler's claim that "publication is the creation of new publics" (Stadler, 2012). Furthermore, the term public in this kappa refers also to public property and accessibility, such as the public domain and open access in contrast to private or corporate ownership.
  3. ↑ It may help to briefly explain how these three intersecting terms are employed here, by way of locating the inquiry. "Contemporary art" refers to the broad terrain of art production from the 1960s onward. However, rather than a period designation, it is used here to refer to a broad domain of practice that may be termed "post-representational" (Sternfeld 2018), "post-conceptualist" (Osborne 2010) or "relational" (Bishop 2006). "Radical education" refers to several distinct traditions of educational practice that is explicitly framed with revolutionary or politically transformative intentions and objectives. These traditions include, for example, Paulo Freire's Pedagogy of the Oppressed (Freire 1970) and bell hooks’ writings on intersectional feminist pedagogy, such as Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of Freedom (hooks 1994). Radical pedagogy has been practiced and tested by projects such as the "Anti-University" in London, the artist collective Ultra Red, and Malmö Free University for Women; and it has been theorized for example in the field of art and curating in books such as Curating and the Educational Turn (O'Neill and Wilson 2010) and in the field of higher education in, for instance, The Imperial University: Academic Repression and Scholarly Dissent (Chatterjee and Maira 2014). By "institutional analysis" I am intending not to describe a sub-domain of sociology, organizational studies or political science but rather the intellectual and practical traditions of institutional critique from within the contemporary art field as this intersects with feminist and intersectional analyses of power – which is of course informed by elements drawn from these other disciplines, but manifests a different tendency and different literature. For more on this see Institutions by Artists (Khonsary and Podesva 2012), How Institutions Think (O'Neill, Steeds and Wilson 2017), and the research project Creating Commons (University of the Arts Zürich, 2016–19).
  4. ↑ The feminist critique of modern epistemologies refers to modernity's claim for abstraction and universalism that originates, in Haraway's words, from a "vision from everywhere and nowhere equally and fully." (Haraway 1988, 584) Boaventura de Sousa Santos summarizes the characteristics of modern epistemologies, which he calls "Epistemologies of the North" as
    (i) the absolute priority of science as rigorous knowledge; (ii) rigor, conceived of as determination; (iii) universalism [...] referring to any entity or condition the validity of which does not depend on any specific social, cultural, or political context; (iv) truth conceived of as the representation of reality; (v) a distinction between subject and object, the knower and the known; (vi) nature as res extensa; (vii) linear time; (viii) the progress of science via the disciplines and specialization; (ix) and social and political neutrality as a condition of objectivity. (de Sousa Santos 2018, 6)
  5. ↑ For Lugones, streetwalker theorizing implies a "pedestrian view – the perspective from inside the midst of people, from inside the layers of relations and institutions and practices” (Lugones 2003, Introduction) In contrast, the bird’s-eye view promotes "the perspective from up high, planning the town, the takeover, or the analysis of life and history" (Lugones 2003, Introduction). With "streetwalker theorizing" Lugones proposes an active subjective agency (in place of the liberal model of agency) that “does not presuppose the individual subject and it does not presuppose collective intentionality of collectivities of the same. It is adumbrated to consciousness by a moving with people, by the difficulties as well as the concrete possibilities of such movings.” (Introduction, emphasis added). This "moving with" shifts the understanding of agency of individual subjectivity, which is here not ascribed to a single rational actor to formulate and pursue her own conceptions but rather "the oft-impeded, multi-directional efforts of social beings moving within and against power structures." (Chang et al. 2018)
  6. ↑ From a decolonial perspective, Boaventura de Sousa Santos argues that the concept of the author in Western modernity forms part of the same cluster of idealist philosophies that underlie modern possessive individualism, namely originality, autonomy, and (individual) creativity. Such concepts, he claims, have little validity in the epistemologies of the South (as opposed to the epistemologies of the North, i.e Western modernity) as, "for them, the most relevant knowledges are either immemorial or generated in the social experiences of oppression and the struggles against it. In any case, they are rarely traceable to a single individual. Underlying such knowledges, there are always new or ancient collective experiences." (de Sousa Santos 2018, 54). See also the book chapter "Confronting Authorship, Constructing Practices", in which I discuss prevailing Western assumptions of authorship and ownership based on both property rights and moral rights and the blockages these assumptions create for collective knowledge practices (Weinmayr 2019, 267–307).
  7. ↑ This citation, without pointing to a specific stabilized publication, might surprise the conventions of academic standards. It refers to a 20-year practice of Brussels-based feminist technology collective Constant, who explore and demonstrate through their practices modes of how "to practically intervene, disrupt and change existing systems of production, distribution, and consumption of knowledge" – a question I raised at the start of this inquiry. See: website "Constant", http://constantvzw.org/site.
  8. ↑ I took copies of my first two independently published publications – Lery – a story of facts and faxes (1998) and Mexico (1997, with Vera Büchlmann and Joachim Melf) – on my first trip to New York, walked into Printed Matter art book shop and sold them ten copies each on consignment. What an empowering moment – more exciting than any exhibition opportunity I ever had.
  9. ↑ Having published with big mainstream commercial publishing houses (Hatje Cantz) as well as small independent presses (Temporary Services, Half-Letter Press, Occasional Papers, Book Works) I got more and more interested in exploring and setting up a publishing infrastructure and subsequently co-founded in 2010, with American artist Lynn Harris, AND Publishing in London (today run with Rosalie Schweiker).
  10. ↑ Of course, within the field of scholarly publishing there is some variability, for instance, the role of the monograph in parts of the humanities in contrast to the role of the double-blind peer review article in some of the medical sciences, or the role of the critical edition in the humanities as against, say, the meta-research analysis paper in the social sciences. In short, there are different scholarly publishing hierarchies and protocols across the disciplines, but the overarching claim is still viable despite this.
  11. ↑ For a summary of the range of open access models that have been introduced, such as "Gold," "Green," and "Hybrid," see "What is open access?" https://www.openaccess.nl/en/what-is-open-access.
  12. ↑ The focus of these newly emerging open access presses is not limited to "providing online access to scholarly publications but was also about rethinking what an academic publishing culture should look like in a digital environment." (Adema, Moore 2018). One example would be the Radical Open Access Collective (ROAC), a community of scholar-led, not-for-profit presses, journals and other open access projects that at the moment consists of more than 50 members promoting a progressive vision for open publishing in the humanities and social sciences. http://radicaloa.disruptivemedia.org.uk/about/. The collective's aim is "to push back against the growing dominance of market-driven versions of open access – particularly those connected to exorbitant, and ultimately unsustainable, article and book processing charges – in order to promote non-commercial and not-for-profit forms of publishing that work against the neoliberal grain." http://radicaloa.disruptivemedia.org.uk/philosophy/. See also the range of topics debated at the two Radical Open Access conferences organized: "Radical Open Access" (2015) http://radicalopenaccess.disruptivemedia.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Booklet.pdf, and "Radical Open Access and the Ethics of Care" (2018) at Disruptive Media Lab at Coventry University, http://radicaloa.disruptivemedia.org.uk/conferences/roa2/concept/.
  13. ↑ Gary Hall's "Inhumanist Manifesto" proposes ten strategies:
    1. Work collaboratively and collectively.
    2. Operate according to a non-profit philosophy.
    3. Act in a non-rivalrous, non-competitive fashion to explore new models for property, ownership and the economy.
    4. Take a hyper-political approach. Gift labor as a means of developing notions of the community, the common and of commoning that break with the conditions supporting the unified, sovereign, proprietorial subject.
    5. Generate projects that are concerned, not only with representing or critiquing the world but also with intra-acting with the world.
    6. Interrogate those propositions that are often taken for granted by theory. The list is a long one. It includes data, the digital, the human, technology, the printed text, the network, and copyright. Other propositions that are assumed by theorists when drawing conclusions about the media are capitalism, liberalism, humanism, freedom, democracy, community, communism, and the commons.
    7. Engage with the existing institutions – especially those to which theorists are most closely tied such as the university, the library, and the scholarly publishing industry – so as to transform them.
    8. Use different personas or masks to experiment with producing multiple authorial 'I's, different to the liberal humanist subjectivity that is the default adopted by even the most supposedly radical of theorists.
    9. Reinvent both the humanities and the posthumanities as the inhumanities by adopting ways of being and doing as theorists that actually take account of and assume an intra-active relation with the nonhuman. (Hall 2017, 177).
  14. ↑ See Mayfly Books,"About Mayfly Books", http://mayflybooks.org/?page_id=2.
  15. ↑ The term "counter-political" is not to be read as "against politics" or "anti-politics". Counter-political is thought of as a practice that exceeds politics as an act of public demonstration and proclamation, or declarative, symbolic gestures. Its political agency lies in "doing things", the creation of facts, employing specific methods to achieve a certain goal. Counter-political comes close to infrapolitics with the difference that for infrapolitics anonymity is a key concern, "a politics that 'dare not speak its name,' a diagonal politics, a careful and evasive politics that avoided dangerous risks." (Scott 2012). See also the discussion of publicness and the public sphere. (02*Setting, note 3).
  16. ↑ I am using the name "HDK-Valand Academy of Arts and Design", or its short form "HDK-Valand" throughout this kappa. During the time when the project was in progress the Art Academy's name was "Valand Academy". "HDK-Valand" is the new name of the merger (2020) of the two art schools, Valand Art Academy and HDK Academy for Design and Craft.
  17. ↑ French sociologist Gabriel Tarde stresses in his book La lois d’imitation (1890), The Laws of Imitation (translated into English in 1903) the fundamental collective and pluralistic dimension of society by examining how any societal effort of invention is built on imitation. He states there is no tabula rasa on which ideas and knowledge emerge from, but ideas always build on already existing ideas. "Our acts are what they are because they are the fittest to satisfy and develop the wants which previous imitation of other inventions had first seeded in us; our thoughts, because they were the most consistent with the knowledge acquired by us of other thoughts which were themselves acquired because they were confirmed by other preliminary ideas or by visual, tactile, and other kinds of impressions which we got by renewing for ourselves certain scientific experiences or observations, after the example of those who first undertook them". (1903, 94)
  18. ↑ Suzanne Briet wrote this treatise as a contribution to the discourse of what constitutes a document. This question was fiercely discussed in the early 1900s, with Paul Otlet claiming that not just written documents but also three-dimensional objects could constitute a document when they serve as evidential objects. Briet expanded this concept by saying that naturally occurring phenomena could as well be documents, such as stars, pebbles, and animals when they had been observed and recorded and classified by an individual (Briet 1951).
  19. ↑ I relate colonial modernity to the concept of coloniality, as Nelson Maldonado-Torres explains:
    Coloniality is different from colonialism. Colonialism denotes a political and economic relation in which the sovereignty of a nation or a people rests on the power of another nation, which makes such nation an empire. Coloniality, instead, refers to long-standing patterns of power that emerged as a result of colonialism, but that define culture, labor, intersubjective relations, and knowledge production well beyond the strict limits of colonial administrations. Thus, coloniality survives colonialism. (Maldonado-Torres 2007, 243).
  20. ↑ See Kathleen Fitzpatrick’s Generous Thinking – I refer to the published draft version: Generous Thinking: The University and the Public Good, especially the chapter "Critique and Competition" (Fitzpatrick 2018). Fitzpatrick’s working method with writing this book presents an interesting approach to scholarly publishing. She published the draft of her book online on Humanities Commons, inviting readers to comment. Based on these responses, what one could call a process of open peer review, she revised the initial draft for publication with John Hopkins University Press. While one could say this is some form of collective authorship, the now published title carries her individual name. The final print version is published as Generous Thinking: A Radical Approach to Saving the University (Fitzpatrick 2019).
  21. ↑ For example, the "Research Excellence Framework" (REF) is the UK system for assessing the quality of research in UK higher education institutions. The primary purpose of REF is to assess the quality of research and produce outcomes for each submission made by institutions. The four higher education funding bodies will use the assessment outcomes to inform the selective allocation of their grant for research to the institutions. The assessment is meant to provide accountability for public investment in research and to produce evidence of the benefits of this investment. The assessment outcomes aim to provide benchmarking information and to establish reputational yardsticks, for use within the higher education (HE) sector and for public information. The quality of research is assessed according to three criteria: (i) the quality of outputs (e.g. publications, performances, and exhibitions), (ii) their impact beyond academia, and (iii) the environment that supports research. Note that the criteria to assess the research environment are based on quantitative indicators such as (a) data on research doctoral degrees awarded, (b) research income, and (c) research income-in-kind). The shortcomings of quantitative assessment will further be discussed in chapter 06*Analysis. The REF was first carried out in 2014 (replacing the previous Research Assessment Exercise in 2009) the second one is scheduled for 2021. It is undertaken by the four UK higher education funding bodies: Research England, the Scottish Funding Council (SFC), the Higher Education Funding Council for Wales (HEFCW), and the Department for the Economy, Northern Ireland (DfE). https://www.ref.ac.uk/2014/
  22. ↑ Mediawiki is an open-source web-based content management software that also powers Wikipedia. The first wiki software (WikiWikiWeb) was developed by Ward Cunningham in the mid-1990s to enable a community of software developers to work together. Wikis are web-based content management systems that allow users to collaborate on content asynchronously. They contain a series of extendable hyperlinked pages to which users can add, edit and delete information, alter the structure, and so on. Every change is automatically recorded, viewable and reversible by users. Wikis use a very simplified mark up language and as such users require no knowledge of code, nor any specialist software or plugins. Cunningham described wikis as the "simplest online database that could possibly work." See http://www.wiki.org/wiki.cgi?WhatIsWiki.
  23. ↑ Charlotte Cooper produced a helpful "Research Justice Diagram" that shows the ethics of research that draws on communities outside academia; in Charlotte's case research on Fat Activism. For the diagram see: http://www.antiuniversity.org/Fat-Activism-and-Research-Justice. See also Charlotte Cooper’s website, http://charlottecooper.net/.