Difference between revisions of "Main Page"

From Eva Weinmayr Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
<br/>
 +
=Noun to Verb: an intersectional investigation of tactics, conflicts and micro-politics in publishing through artistic practice=
  
 +
This MediaWiki constitutes a Doctoral thesis which in combination with a portfolio of artistic works, is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Artistic Practice at HDK-Valand – Academy of Art and Design, Faculty of Fine, Applied and Performing Arts, University of Gothenburg – supervised by Prof. Jyoti Mistry and Prof. Mick Wilson (2018-2020), and Prof. Dave Beech and Prof. Andrea Phillips (2015-2018).
  
−
<br/>[[File:Rosalie hello reader-lres.jpg|170px|right]]
+
The open-source MediaWiki is a tool to develop, map, share, and communicate the writing of my PhD thesis. It is a platform for producing and disseminating the research. The wiki records and maps a looped, iterative, and knowledge-creating process of structuring, writing, thinking, discovering, discarding, and restructuring.
−
<p style="font-size:17px"><b>Short Index</b></p>
+
 
−
* [[Noun_to_Verb:_on_tactics,_conflicts_and_micro-politics_in_publishing_–_an_intersectional_investigation_through_artistic_practice | About this wiki]]
+
Finding practical ways to share and communicate my research has been an ongoing and, at times, difficult negotiation process between at least five forces seemingly pulling in different directions: academia, institutional policies, feminist and activist practice, the arts, and education.
−
* [[2_Setting | Setting]]
+
 
−
* [[3_Survey_of_the_field| Survey of the field]]
+
The wiki is a practical strategy to bring to life the standoff between those forces and thus make transparent the processes that are usually developed and discussed behind closed doors when a PhD thesis develops: the learning process, the struggle while articulating, the shaping of arguments, the various agreements and disagreements within my head and in dialogue with others.
−
* [[4_Summary_of_projects_and_submitted_material | Summary of projects and submitted material]]
+
The customized code of this open-source Mediawiki, developed by Manetta Berends and Cristina Cochior (Varia, Rotterdam) includes a comment column for my collaborators in the collective projects to add their voices and perspectives. Here the wiki turns a PhD submission itself into a site of ruptures, dialogue, and potential disagreements.
−
* [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects| Reflection, theorization of projects]]
+
<br/>
−
* [[6_Analysis | Analysis]]
+
<br/>
−
* [[7_References|References]]
+
<br/>
 +
[[File:LO GUeng cen2.jpg|150px|link=]]
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
<b>Noun to Verb: on tactics, conflicts and micro-politics in publishing<br/> – an intersectional investigation through artistic practice</b>
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
Doctoral thesis leading to the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Artistic Practice
 +
at HDK-Valand – Academy of Art and Design, Faculty of Fine, Applied and Performing Arts, University of Gothenburg, 2020.
 +
<br/>
 +
Supervised by Jyoti Mistry and Mick Wilson (2018-2020), and Dave Beech and Andrea Phillips (2015-2018).
 +
<br/>
 +
<br/>
 +
Author: Eva Weinmayr</br>
 +
Annotations: Andrea Francke, Andreas Engman, Femke Snelting, MC Coble, Rosalie Schweiker<br/>
 +
Coding: Manetta Berends & Cristina Cochior [https://varia.zone/en/ (VariaRotterdam)]</br>
 +
English proofreading: David Morris, Pedro C. Proenca</br>
 +
This doctoral dissertation is No xx in the series ArtMonitor Doctoral Dissertations and Licentiate Theses at the Faculty of Fine, Applied and Performing Arts, University of Gothenburg www.konst.gu.se/artmonitor</br>
 +
GUPEA: ??</br>
 +
Lincense: Collective Conditions for re-use (CC4r) [link to Constant]<br/>
 +
eva.weinmayr@akademinvaland.gu.se<br/>
 +
<br/>
 
<br/>
 
<br/>
 
<br/>
 
<br/>
−
<p style="font-size:17px"><b>Expanded Index</b></p>
+
 
−
* [[Noun_to_Verb:_on_tactics,_conflicts_and_micro-politics_in_publishing_–_an_intersectional_investigation_through_artistic_practice | About this wiki]]
+
=Abstract=
−
* [[2_Setting | Setting]]
+
</br>
−
** [[2_Setting#Multiple_sites | Multiple Sites]]
+
This practice-based inquiry explores the social and political agency of publishing by investigating the micro-politics of making and sharing knowledges from an intersectional feminist perspective. Whether "bound" or "unbound," there has been much discussion of the political agency of the book as a medium, yet it is often assumed that the book's political potential extends primarily, indeed if not exclusively, in terms of its content. The focus of this inquiry, however, is the potentially radical, political and emancipatory ways and processes by which a publication is made (authored, edited, printed, bound), disseminated (circulated, described, cataloged), and read (used).
−
** [[2_Setting#More_verb.2C_less_noun:_the_practices |The Practices]]
+
 
−
** [[2_Setting#Authorship.2C_authorization.2C_authority:_the_questions |The Questions]]
+
The five projects at the core of this contribution have been developed collaboratively with different constellations of actors across the UK and Sweden and are comprised of: AND Publishing (2010–ongoing), The Library of Omissions and Inclusions (2016–18), The Piracy Project (2010–15), Let’s Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy? (2015–16), and Boxing and Unboxing (2018). These five projects explore intersectional feminist publishing strategies and ask: What if we understood publication not as a finite object? What if we gave attention and value to the processes and practices that lead up to a publication? How can collective processes of publishing themselves be a tactic to practically intervene, disrupt and change existing knowledge practices?
−
** [[2_Setting#.22Thinking_with.22:_the_format |The Format]]
+
 
−
** [[2_Setting#Roadmap|The Roadmap]]
+
Located at the intersection of contemporary art, radical education, and institutional analysis, this inquiry critically investigates the presumption that publishing is an outright positive and progressive act, a tool of giving voice and developing emancipatory agency. It identifies the paradoxes, conflicts, and contradictions for collective knowledge practices caused by systems of validation and audit culture, by the stasis of the "finite" object and by the authority these discrete objects produce. The research stretches beyond these points by exploring the coercive mutual reciprocity between authorship, authorization, and authority.
−
** [[2_Setting#Notes_.28Setting.29|Notes (Setting)]]
+
 
−
* [[3_Survey_of_the_field| Survey of the field]]
+
At its core, this inquiry aims to expand and test the normative criteria of what constitutes a publication. One of the emergent questions posed was whether publishing may be seen as a verb (a process) rather than a noun (i.e. the finished object). Could practice itself be understood as a form of publishing? A teaching situation, for example – a workshop, seminar, or group dialogue, where knowledge is collectively created and shared at the same time – could this also be considered as publishing? What kinds of publics are necessary or relevant to a publication process? A collaboration, a collective, a scene, a process, a dynamic, a method – can we frame any such situation or process as "publishing"? How fixed or stable does a transmission of knowledges need to be in order to be called a "publication"? And what is the function and effect of such stability?
−
** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Setting_up_alternative_infrastructures | Setting up alternative infrastructures]]
+
 
−
***[[3_Survey_of_the_field#Early_conceptual_artist_books:_Setting_up_infrastructures_of_production_and_distribution_.28the_60s_and_70s.29|Early conceptual artist books]]
+
Since the communication of the research findings (in the form of a PhD thesis) itself constitutes a form of publication, I experimented with an open and dialogical mode of publishing in the form of a MediaWiki – developed “in public” from its very beginning. As such, it turns the thesis from constituting an authoritative text into a site for multiple voices with occasions of negotiation, disagreement, and consultation.
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Descriptors_and_their_discontents:_artist_book.2C_artist.27s_publishing| Descriptors and their discontents]]
 
−
***[[3_Survey_of_the_field#Counter-cultural_alternative_media_.E2.80.93_Radical_Printshops_.2870s.2C_80s.2C_UK.29|Counter-cultural alternative media]]
 
−
***[[3_Survey_of_the_field#Open_Source:_Feminist_technologies:_Constant_.28Brussels.29| Open Source: feminist technologies]]
 
−
**[[3_Survey_of_the_field#Interventionist_strategies_.E2.80.9CInsertions_into_Ideological_Circuits.E2.80.9D | Interventionist Strategies ]]
 
−
**[[3_Survey_of_the_field#Library_as_Infrastructure|Library as Infrastructure]]
 
−
** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Radical_Librarianship_.E2.80.93_.22extitutional.22:_Questions_of_access_and_validation| Radical Librarianship – "extitutional"]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#An_artwork:_.22Martha_Rosler_Library.22_.282007.29|An artwork: Martha Rosler Library]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#A_network_of_relationships:_Infoshops_.281990s_UK.29| A network of relationships: Infoshops]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Shadow_Libraries | Shadow Libraries]]
 
−
** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Radical_Librarianship_.E2.80.93_.22institutional.22:_Questions_of_organization_and_classification| Radical Librarianship – "institutional"]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Prejudices and Antipathies | Prejudices and Antipathies]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#KvinnSam, the National Resource Library for Gender Studies at Gothenburg University | KvinnSam, the National Resource Library for Gender Studies, Gothenburg University]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Feminist_Search_Tool | Feminist Search Tool, Utrecht University Library]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Infrastructural_Manoevres.2C_Rietveld_Library_Amsterdam | Infrastructural Manoevres, Rietveld and Sandberg Library, Amsterdam]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Teaching the Radical Catalog | Teaching The Radical Catalog]]
 
−
*** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Performative_Propositions:_Policy_Document_at_ERG | Performative Propositions: Policy Document at erg, Brussels]]
 
−
** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#What's next | What's next]]
 
−
** [[3_Survey_of_the_field#Notes: Survey of the field| Notes (Survey of the field)]]
 
−
* [[4_Summary_of_projects_and_submitted_material | Summary of projects and submitted material]]
 
−
** [[4_Summary_of_projects_and_submitted_material#Projects | Projects]]
 
−
***[[Project_1_*_AND_Publishing| *AND Publishing]]
 
−
***[[Project_2_*_Library_of_Inclusions_and_Omissions| *Library of Inclusions and Omissions]]
 
−
***[[Project_3_*_The_Piracy_Project| *Piracy Project]]
 
−
***[[Project_4_*_Let%27s_Mobilize:_What_is_Feminist_Pedagogy%3F| *Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?]]
 
−
***[[Project_5_*_Boxing_and_Unboxing| *Boxing and Unboxing]]
 
−
** [[4_Summary_of_projects_and_submitted_material#Published_.28Fixed.29 | Published (Fixed)]]
 
−
** [[4_Summary_of_projects_and_submitted_material#Discursive_.E2.80.93_teaching.2C_workshops.2C_presentations.2C_discussions.2C_think-ins_.28Unfixed.29 | Discursive  (Unfixed)]]
 
−
*[[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects| Reflection, theorization of projects]]
 
−
** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Library_of_Inclusions_and_Omissions_.E2.80.93_radical_publishing_practices_require_radical_librarianship|Library of Inclusions and Omissions – radical publishing practices require radical librarianship]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Library_of_Inclusions_and_Omissions_.E2.80.93_radical_publishing_practices_require_radical_librarianship|Which narratives enter?]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Perspectives_and_framing_under_the_disguise_of_neutrality| Perspectives and framing under the disguise of neutrality]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Library_as_disciplinary_institution | Library as disciplinary institution]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Classification_.E2.80.93_a_hierarchical_architecture_to_house_the_universe_of_knowledge | Classification — an architecture to house the universe of knowledge]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Sameness_and_Difference | Sameness and Difference]]
 
−
** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#The_Piracy_Project | The Piracy Project]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Queering_the_authority_of_the_printed_book | Queering the authority of the printed book]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Who_has_the_right_to_be_an_author:_Copyright_and_IP | Who has the right to be an author: copyright and IP]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Unsolicited_Collaborations:_queering_the_authorial_voice| Unsolicited Collaborations: queering the authorial voice]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#The_social_agency_of_piracy | The social agency of piracy]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#The_limits_of_framing_and_exhibiting| The limits of framing and exhibiting]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Why_we_decided_to_end_the_project| Why we decided to end the project]]
 
−
** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Let.27s_Mobilize:_What_is_Feminist_Pedagogy.3F_.E2.80.93_Institutional_Pedagogy| Let's Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy?]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#The_event:_.22un-authored.22_practices_of_feminist_organizing_and_changing_institutional_habits| The "un-authored" practices of feminist organizing and changing institutional habits]]
 
−
**** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#The_administrator_as_co-author| The administrators as co-authors]]
 
−
**** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Collectivity:_Desires_and_Complications | Collectivity: Desires and Complications]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Questions_of_efficiency_and_unmeasurable_labor | Questions of efficiency and unmeasurable labor]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#The_Workbook:_contingent.2C_contextual_publishing| The workbook: contingent, contextual publishing]][[File:Rosalie scroll b&w cropped.jpg|180px|right]]
 
−
**** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#The_editorial_process| The editorial process]]
 
−
**** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Public_Assembling_Day:_Distribution_as_social_encounter| Public assembling day: Distribution as social encounter]]
 
−
****[[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Walkable_Book:_Situated_publishing| Walkable Book: situated publishing]]
 
−
***[[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Workbook_and_event:_an_.22institutional_object.22| Workbook and event: an institutional object]]
 
−
***[[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Wrap_Up_3| Wrap up]]
 
−
** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Boxing_and_Unboxing_.E2.80.93_against_immunization| Boxing and Unboxing]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Boxing_Club_.E2.80.93_Sparring | Boxing Club – Sparring]]
 
−
*** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Boxing_and_Unboxing_.E2.80.93_community.2C_immunity_and_the_figure_of_the_.22proper.22| Community, immunity and the figure of the "proper"]]
 
−
** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#What.27s_next| What's next]]
 
−
** [[5_Reflection,_theorization_of_projects#Notes_.28Reflection.2C_theorization_of_projects.29| Notes (Reflection, theorization of projects)]]
 
−
* [[6_Analysis | Analysis]]
 
−
**[[6_Analysis#Collectivity| Collectivity]]
 
−
**[[6_Analysis#Politics_of_Naming| Politics of naming]]
 
−
**[[6_Analysis#Politics_of_Fixing| Politics of fixing]]
 
−
**[[6_Analysis#Politics_of_Mediating:_the_prop.2C_the_third_object.2C_and_institutional_pedagogy| Politics of Mediating: institutional pedagogy ]]
 
−
** [[6_Analysis#Politics_of_Citing | Politics of citing ]]
 
−
** [[6_Analysis#How_could_we_imagine_authorship_without_ownership.3F | How could we understand authorship without ownership ]]
 
−
*** [[6_Analysis#It_doesn.27t_matter_who_is_speaking | It doesn't matter who is speaking]]
 
−
***[[6_Analysis#It_does_matter_who_is_speaking:_a_feminist.2C_decolonial_perspective | It does matter who is speaking: a feminist, de-colonial perspective]]
 
−
** [[6_Analysis#A_more_flexible_idea_of_authorship_altogether:_from_.22output.22_to_.22input.22:_contingent.2C_contextual | A altogether more flexible idea of authorship:  From Output to Input]]
 
−
**[[6_Analysis#Milieu:_Compost._Feeding.2C_digesting.2C_excreting | Compost: feeding, digesting, excreting]]
 
−
** [[6_Analysis#Authorship.2C_authorization.2C_authority:_remarks_on_the_collaborative_wiki | Authorship, authorization, authority: remarks on the collaborative wiki]]
 
−
** [[6_Analysis#Notes_.28Analysis.29 | Notes (Analysis)]]
 
−
* [[7_References|References]]
 
−
* [[Acknowledgments | Acknowledgments]]
 
−
* [[Appendix_1*Let%27s_Mobilize_Revisited|Appendix 1*Let's Mobilize Revisted]]
 
−
* [[Appendix 2*Interview with Femke Snelting|Appendix 2*Interview with Femke Snelting (Constant)]]
 
−
* [[Appendix_3*Rosalie%27s_visual_comments|Appendix 3*Rosalie's Visual Comments]]
 

Revision as of 19:10, 30 September 2020


Noun to Verb: an intersectional investigation of tactics, conflicts and micro-politics in publishing through artistic practice

This MediaWiki constitutes a Doctoral thesis which in combination with a portfolio of artistic works, is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Artistic Practice at HDK-Valand – Academy of Art and Design, Faculty of Fine, Applied and Performing Arts, University of Gothenburg – supervised by Prof. Jyoti Mistry and Prof. Mick Wilson (2018-2020), and Prof. Dave Beech and Prof. Andrea Phillips (2015-2018).

The open-source MediaWiki is a tool to develop, map, share, and communicate the writing of my PhD thesis. It is a platform for producing and disseminating the research. The wiki records and maps a looped, iterative, and knowledge-creating process of structuring, writing, thinking, discovering, discarding, and restructuring.

Finding practical ways to share and communicate my research has been an ongoing and, at times, difficult negotiation process between at least five forces seemingly pulling in different directions: academia, institutional policies, feminist and activist practice, the arts, and education.

The wiki is a practical strategy to bring to life the standoff between those forces and thus make transparent the processes that are usually developed and discussed behind closed doors when a PhD thesis develops: the learning process, the struggle while articulating, the shaping of arguments, the various agreements and disagreements within my head and in dialogue with others. The customized code of this open-source Mediawiki, developed by Manetta Berends and Cristina Cochior (Varia, Rotterdam) includes a comment column for my collaborators in the collective projects to add their voices and perspectives. Here the wiki turns a PhD submission itself into a site of ruptures, dialogue, and potential disagreements.


LO GUeng cen2.jpg


Noun to Verb: on tactics, conflicts and micro-politics in publishing
– an intersectional investigation through artistic practice


Doctoral thesis leading to the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Artistic Practice at HDK-Valand – Academy of Art and Design, Faculty of Fine, Applied and Performing Arts, University of Gothenburg, 2020.
Supervised by Jyoti Mistry and Mick Wilson (2018-2020), and Dave Beech and Andrea Phillips (2015-2018).

Author: Eva Weinmayr
Annotations: Andrea Francke, Andreas Engman, Femke Snelting, MC Coble, Rosalie Schweiker
Coding: Manetta Berends & Cristina Cochior (VariaRotterdam)
English proofreading: David Morris, Pedro C. Proenca
This doctoral dissertation is No xx in the series ArtMonitor Doctoral Dissertations and Licentiate Theses at the Faculty of Fine, Applied and Performing Arts, University of Gothenburg www.konst.gu.se/artmonitor
GUPEA: ??
Lincense: Collective Conditions for re-use (CC4r) [link to Constant]
eva.weinmayr@akademinvaland.gu.se



Abstract


This practice-based inquiry explores the social and political agency of publishing by investigating the micro-politics of making and sharing knowledges from an intersectional feminist perspective. Whether "bound" or "unbound," there has been much discussion of the political agency of the book as a medium, yet it is often assumed that the book's political potential extends primarily, indeed if not exclusively, in terms of its content. The focus of this inquiry, however, is the potentially radical, political and emancipatory ways and processes by which a publication is made (authored, edited, printed, bound), disseminated (circulated, described, cataloged), and read (used).

The five projects at the core of this contribution have been developed collaboratively with different constellations of actors across the UK and Sweden and are comprised of: AND Publishing (2010–ongoing), The Library of Omissions and Inclusions (2016–18), The Piracy Project (2010–15), Let’s Mobilize: What is Feminist Pedagogy? (2015–16), and Boxing and Unboxing (2018). These five projects explore intersectional feminist publishing strategies and ask: What if we understood publication not as a finite object? What if we gave attention and value to the processes and practices that lead up to a publication? How can collective processes of publishing themselves be a tactic to practically intervene, disrupt and change existing knowledge practices?

Located at the intersection of contemporary art, radical education, and institutional analysis, this inquiry critically investigates the presumption that publishing is an outright positive and progressive act, a tool of giving voice and developing emancipatory agency. It identifies the paradoxes, conflicts, and contradictions for collective knowledge practices caused by systems of validation and audit culture, by the stasis of the "finite" object and by the authority these discrete objects produce. The research stretches beyond these points by exploring the coercive mutual reciprocity between authorship, authorization, and authority.

At its core, this inquiry aims to expand and test the normative criteria of what constitutes a publication. One of the emergent questions posed was whether publishing may be seen as a verb (a process) rather than a noun (i.e. the finished object). Could practice itself be understood as a form of publishing? A teaching situation, for example – a workshop, seminar, or group dialogue, where knowledge is collectively created and shared at the same time – could this also be considered as publishing? What kinds of publics are necessary or relevant to a publication process? A collaboration, a collective, a scene, a process, a dynamic, a method – can we frame any such situation or process as "publishing"? How fixed or stable does a transmission of knowledges need to be in order to be called a "publication"? And what is the function and effect of such stability?

Since the communication of the research findings (in the form of a PhD thesis) itself constitutes a form of publication, I experimented with an open and dialogical mode of publishing in the form of a MediaWiki – developed “in public” from its very beginning. As such, it turns the thesis from constituting an authoritative text into a site for multiple voices with occasions of negotiation, disagreement, and consultation.