Main Page
MediaWiki has been installed.
Contents
about this wiki
This wiki is a site to develop and share my PhD writing it. It is a way to map a tentative process of writing, thinking and discovering, discarding and restructuring – all the messy decision making processes which differentiates "a practice" from a finished output. This wiki is also a method for me to depart from the solitary word document on my hard disk and make the moments of "taking shape" public and transparent. Finding ways to share my research and practice has been an ongoing – and at times difficult – negotiation between a set of forces pulling in different directions: academia, feminist and activist practice, the arts, and education. Using a wiki for my research dissemination allows me to make transparent what is usually developed and discussed behind closed doors. In a few months time, or when this draft has enough substance, I will invite peers to be in dialogue, to comment, to debate. My doctoral research is (and has been) supervised by Jyoti Mistry and Mick Wilson, Dave Beech and Andrea Phillips. It is conducted as a PhD in artistic practice at Valand Academy, University of Gothenburg.
Please be aware that what you are reading now is a draft. When you're going to cite it, please do reference this fact. If you have questions or comments [1] get in touch: eva.weinmayr (at) akademinvaland.gu.se
- ↑ please
1 Introduction
What is the enquiry about?
What are the possibilities within these operations to realise or to do Feminist / Emancipatory / Critical -Political “praxis” (i.e., a working-thinking-doing-speaking) both within institutional frameworks and outside/between institutions i.e., not simply a solo run)? To answer this question entails taking actions (e.g., setting up a reading room situation; doing publications etc.) and reflecting upon these actions in differing forums or with different constituencies and then testing these action-reflection-s against a criterion of “feminist /emancipatory/political” field of expanded publishing, what are the blockages, what are the possibilities? to anwer taking action, responding, acting, contextual,
2 Context of the enquiry
What are the operations that are specifically addressed? What are the blockages to realizing a Feminist / Emancipatory / Critical -Political “praxis” within the existing operational models – authoring, publishing, disseminating, cataloguing, taxonomies, librarianship models, course reading lists, pedagogical uses of published works and publishing … these moments not necessarily separate … diagnosis of the problem What do we mean by a Feminist / Emancipatory / Critical -Political “praxis” OR what would the effect of this look like? If a praxis is emancipatory what would show that it is so? enclosure / injustice – metadata restrictions…
3 identifies what is in the list of submitted materials
is the contetualising..... the material includes: a list, describes what is in the box.
chapters, papers, ephemera, (documenation of worksshop/representations)
4 The state of the art in this domain (expanded description of field of operation), "literature review"
What has already been proposed by others in this space? A set of examples authorship, publishing, librarianship, cataloguing, pedagogical Other practices, that make a claim to be critical, feminist etc....., historical taxonomy, certain way of thinking, theoritical.
An observation we can make here: Artists moved into publishing to exit or bypass certain perceived limitations of the dominant art system institutional frame but historically these practices have been (re-captured or re-anchored or re-integrated or co-opted or re-located ) into the current dominant art system institutional frames: an attempt at emancipatory action is seen to fail in some important sense) Another observation: Open access … dominant paradigm: standard model, describe: divison of labour, authorship, design, distribtion, how this has been contested/challenged by artists, activists
5 What are the experiments that have been done? (expand on list above)
How have these practices been simultaneously theorized/reflected? Description of how each “experiment” (work/publication/presentation/event) proceeds from the previous “experiment”… summary , listing, pointing to the writings, previously published chapters, extended version of an abstract don't get lost in detail, keep overview, first pass of description
6 Analysis
What possibilities have been accessed or opened up or demonstrated? Based on these experiments can we outline a transferable model or set of principles or operational guide … that could be implemented by a variety of institutional actors?
- art practice?
- cultural practice
- knowledge work
List of “operations”
- “Alternative” publishing and dissemination strategies
- “Alternative” reading practices
- “Alternative” writing practices – “collectively authored”
- “Alternative” library models
- pedagogical models
- knowledge work
- institutional frameworks or models of practice in publishing / dissemination / reading /cataloguing / providing access / *using “publications” within pedagogical processes…
7 Where is the enquiry located?
- Contemporary art field in a wide sense
- Within the context of educational turn
- Triangulating across A. Publishing B. Education C. Institutional cultures
- Variously intent upon realizing a Political practice Feminist practice Emancipatory practices
- “Alternative” is a place holder for something about locating the practices with a political agenda or project that draws *upon ideas of doing Feminist / Emancipatory / Critical -Political work/actions
How will the project submission be structured ?
- A “capa”
- and set of published texts;
- set of exhibited works;
- set of pedagogical interventions;
- set of other actions
The capa
- identifies what is in the list of submitted materials
- establishes the general context of the contribution
- describes the way the contribution(s) have been realized / made
- asserts the significance of the contribution to its wider field(s)
- indicates future direction for further research
introduction
This research is about the micro-politics of publishing at the intersection of contemporary art, radical education and institutional analysis. (Explain micro-politics.... It's the underlying structures, assumptions, the actual "doing". How things work in a day-to-day practice.)
It looks at micropolitics of production and micropolitics of circulation, that is reading practices and the production of meaning.
A preliminary list of topis to discuss:
- The "authorship problem" in art, pedagogy and institutional settings. Explain the dilemma with authorship. Ownership. Collectivity. Audit (or cultural capital) vs visibility for unrecognised voices (class, race, ethnicity, gender and sexuality), accountability. unauthored documents. visibilit vs invisibility. What matter who's speaking.
- Publication as open source. (The Piracy Project)
- Publication is an act of fixing something into a document? What is a document? (Lisa Gitelman) How does it circulate. How does it produce meaning?
- Circulation of these fixed documents. Enclosures. Shadow libraries.
- Organising and classifying of publications, so they can be found. Biases in standard library classification systems. What is the problem with classification more generally? (Interference Library Brooklyn, wild organsing sytem produces a social space of discovery. Not efficient, but serendipity. Meeting like-minded people)
- Education as open source. Not the outcome, but the learning curve.
- Publishing vs publication. Verb vs noun. Practice vs object/outcome >> Not auditable.
- Potential model for institutional education?
- Publishing not to satisfy audit, but learn collectively, articulate, instigate dialogue, and action. >>contextual publishing.
- Problem with "impact" based on metrification/altmetrics. Can institutional policies rethink criteria for impact?
context
What has been done by others? What is the state of the art in this domain?
The artist book ––
as a conceptual and material means to question, intervene in and disturb existing practices and institutions
The history, concepts and materialities of artists books has been the topic of several monographs (Drucker, Ludovico, Lyons). Joanna Drucker published in 1997 "The century of the artist book", a compendium reflecting on a movement from early 20th century avantgarde (Russian constructivists, Futurists, to the conceptual art movement in the 60s and 70s. Concept art has been described by Lucy Lippard as a "process of dematerialisation" (Lippard 1997:5). It refers to the occurring shift from producing traditional art objects, such as sculpture or painting to processes like happenings, performances, site-specific interventions and land art.
There are several ways to look at the phenomenon. One is the experimenting with materiality, lay-out, format, the experimental strategies and approaches artists applied to expand our understanding of what a book is or could be, to challenge the properties of the traditional book.
Another way is to look at the political potential of the artists book as a conceptual and material means to question, intervene in and disturb existing practices and institutions. (Vanderlip 'The number of items in this present exhibition is proof enough that something is going on in art that is outside painting and sculpture and that it to a degree outside the normal art distribution system of galleries’.) Lucy Lippard states: artists’ books are ‘considered by many the easiest way out of the art world and into the heart of a broader audience’.
The challenge however was the setting up alternative production and distribution systems to circulate the books without falling back to exclusionary market mechanisms of the art system. Investigating whether artists could set up independent systems of circulation the editors of Art-Rite magazine put out a call:
“Artists’ Books – We are investigating the possibilities of a publishing and distribution system for artists’ books. (This does not mean catalogues.) Do you have: a) already published books that we can distribute or sell on consignment? b) Completely planned, unpublished books with or without dummies? c) names of other artists who have either one? Let us know. Please send information to: PRINTED MATTER, 164 Mulberry St., NYC 10013.”(ART RITE Magazine 11/12, winter/spring 1975/1976, p.3)
Due to their perceived potential to subvert the exclusive, commercial and profit-driven gallery system - artist books according to Joan Lyons played an important part in the rise of independent art structures. (Joan Lyons (ed), “Artists’ Books: a Critical Anthology and Sourcebook”, Rochester, New York, Visual Studies Workshop Press, 1993, p8.)
or different structure:
New proposal: New structure
- The author name on the front cover (politics of authorship, collectivity, audit, accountability, having a voice, authorship as ownership)
- The ISBN on the back cover (politics of distribution, mainstream trade, self-organised, informal)
- The Price (feminist budgeting and non-plausible economies)
- The colophon (who contributed in which dimension, visible and invisible labour)
- The book mark (Open the book at a specific page: reading practices)
- Annotations (book as dialog, reading practices)
- Print, paper, format (material qualities: complexity, anomaly, and disruption) Thoburn, Eisenstein, Johns
- The Binding (the binding as linear structure)
- The Spine (supposed to be stuck on the shelf. What if not?)
- Pagenumbers (GPS, point of reference)
- Bibliography (politics of citation, how and where is knowledge and references sought)
- References (politics of indirect and direct speech, building upon or taking out of context, appropriation, co-option)
- copyright sign (big topic)
- Acknowledgements (mapping the process and the poeple, who were helping)
- Foreword, Afterword (the framing, contextualising)
- Peer review (collaboration as peer-review)
- the books keywords, catalogue entry (the power of framing)
- What is not in the book (invisible work, organising, caring, hosting)
- What is not in the book (editorial work, dialogue)
- The wiki version of the book (mapping the process, mapping collaborations)
- Open Access (from bottom up to top down, metricisation, audit)
to do
send authorship text to Nourbese Phillips.
method
bibliography references
Alperin, J.P., Muñoz Nieves, C., Schimanski, L., Fischman, G.E., Niles, M.T. & McKiernan, E.C. (2018). How significant are the public dimensions of faculty work in review, promotion, and tenure documents? Humanities Commons [preprint]. doi: Media:http://dx.doi.org/10.17613/M6W950N35
Genette, Gérard, Paratexts, Thresholds of interpretation (Cambridge University Press, 1997)
Hall, Gary, “Digitize this Book, The Politics of New Media, or Why We Need Open Access Now”, Minnesota University Press, 2008
Hayles, Katherine N. , "How We Think: Digital Media and Contemporary Technogenesis" (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2012)
Leigh Star, Susan
Olson, Hope A., “How we construct Subjects: Feminist Analysis”, in Library Trends, Johns Hopkins University Press, Volume 56, Number 2, Fall 2007, pp. 509-541
van Mourik Broekman, P. , Hall, G. , Byfield, T. , Hides, S. and Worthington, S. "Open
education: A study in disruption" (London: Rowman & Littlefield International, 2014)
Media:https://curve.coventry.ac.uk/open/file/c04530ce-d16a-46ca-b359-a905195a76cb/1/Open education.pdf
Getting started
- Configuration settings list
- MediaWiki FAQ
- MediaWiki release mailing list
- Localise MediaWiki for your language
- Learn how to combat spam on your wiki
Consult the User's Guide for information on using the wiki software.
This is the start This was a coment Comments are visible only in the edit zone. and them....